Computer Implemented Invention (CII) – Decisions

(information in regard to the categories below)

=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0768/17; 2023-1-26; Authenticating wireless payments/VODAFONE

TECHNOLOGY: #Financial_Transaction_and_Payment_Technologies #Cardless_Payment_Authentication
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Alleged_Technical_Contribution_Not_Established_Across_Claim_Scope
APPLICATION FIELD: #Mobile_Payments_and_Contactless_Transactions
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claim concerns authentication of wireless payments using a mobile device, a point-of-sale system and a backend server communicating over separate channels.
– Technical effect at issue: The alleged detection of transmission errors, fraud and human mistakes was not credibly obtained throughout the broad claim scope; semantic comparison of independently created transaction data is not equivalent to bit-level checksum integrity checking (Reasons 4.4-4.8).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed mobile device, interfaces and backend processor provide the claim with technical character as a whole.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The acceptance and comparison rules were treated as business requirements; the technical implementation using known communication channels was obvious under COMVIK (Reasons 4.9-4.12).
– Applicatioin field: The system concerns merchant payments authenticated using a mobile device and a point-of-sale terminal.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was decisive; the Board also considered the admission of amended requests after the summons.
– Outcome: The Board dismissed the appeal because none of the requests fulfilled the EPC requirements, in particular Article 56 EPC.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Vodafone Holding GmbH
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – authenticating a wireless payment by comparing information about a transaction provided independently by a customer’s mobile device and a merchant system (no – obvious implementation of a business requirement)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1158/17; 2022-12-12; Routing electronic message/ESCHER GROUP

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Network_Protocols
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Data_Communication
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Additional_Prior_Art_Search
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The electronic business-postal system employs message servers, access portals, system nodes and an electronic delivery subsystem for routing messages.
– Technical effect at issue: Electronic message routing, checks of whether transmitted messages remain intact and discarding/resending failed messages involve genuine technical communication considerations (Reasons 3.2.5-3.2.12).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The Board rejected characterisation of the whole scheme as administrative merely because its functions resemble postal procedures or are specified abstractly.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The communication and integrity-checking features were recognised as technical contributions that must be assessed against prior art; whether they are inventive remained undecided.
– Applicatioin field: The implementation serves an electronic business postal service and secure delivery of business communications.
– Decisive legal issue: The first-instance assessment wrongly omitted technical features from the inventive-step analysis; a detailed prior-art comparison and potentially a broader search were needed (Reasons 3.2.13-4.5).
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the application remitted for further examination; no order to grant was made.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
A similarity [of the claimed subject-matter] to a business or administrative solution is not a sufficient reason for denying a technical contribution of a claim feature applied in a technical context and involving technical considerations. Put another way, technical considerations in the technical context cannot be negated merely on the basis of a non‑technical analogy.
… The analogy to a post office, essentially invoked by the contested decision, is used in technical literature in order to describe functionality of the transport layer (layer 4) of the OSI model. However, in the Board’s view, it would not be sound to assert, only based on this analogy, that communication protocols implementing this layer’s functionality lack technical character. (See points 3.2.7 and 3.2.8 of the reasons).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Escher Group (IRL) Limited
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 111(1); RPBA 2020 Art. 11, 13(1)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Technical contribution – routing an electronic message and ensuring its integrity (yes – no mere automation of an administrative scheme) ; Remittal to the department of first instance (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 1082/13
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0282/17; 2021-12-15

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Human_Computer_Interaction
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Telecommunications
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Novelty #Added_Subject_Matter #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Maintain_Patent

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The patent concerns a user-selectable interface for sending image information captured during an active mobile telecommunication connection.
– Technical effect at issue: Offering a direct sending option after image capture credibly assists quick image transmission and avoids manually locating the image and entering its destination (Reasons 7.3 et seq.).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claim is directed to a technical telecommunications device with an operative user interface.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board recognised a technical interaction improvement and ultimately found the maintained amended claims novel and inventive over the cited art.
– Applicatioin field: The operative setting is mobile telecommunication with capture and transfer of images during an ongoing call.
– Decisive legal issue: Admission of the revised auxiliary request, extension of protection, added matter, novelty and inventive step were addressed.
– Outcome: The impugned decision was set aside and the case remitted with the binding order to maintain the patent in amended form, not as granted.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Nokia Corporation
OPPOSING-PARTY: Hanna Moore & Curley Limited
LEGAL PROVISIONS: RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2); RPBA Art. 12(4); EPC Art. 123(2), 123(3); EPC 1973 Art. 54(1), 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Respondent’s revised second auxiliary request – admittance (yes) ; Respondent’s revised second auxiliary request – extension of protection (no) ; Respondent’s revised second auxiliary request – added subject-matter (no) ; Respondent’s revised second auxiliary request – novelty (yes) ; Respondent’s revised second auxiliary request – inventive step (yes) ; Admittance of document E5 (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1480/16, T 0995/18, T 1792/19, T 0981/17, T 2243/18, T 1151/18, T 0724/08, T 1911/15, T 2696/16, T 2091/18
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1227/17; 2021-11-19; E-mail read status indication/UNIFY

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Information_Presentation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Telecommunications
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The case concerns displaying e-mail messages and their read/unread indications, including status changes depending on attachment opening.
– Technical effect at issue: The timing rule for marking a message as read was an administrative convention or subjective user preference, not an additional technical effect (Reasons 2.3-2.7).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): An electronic e-mail display apparatus is technical, but this does not make every displayed status criterion technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Automatic flag switching was already known; the claimed distinction was only the non-technical rule determining when the flag is set.
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns e-mail communications and message-list display.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under COMVIK, together with the admissibility of several auxiliary requests, determined the result.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed following the failure of the allowable requests to establish inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Unify Patente GmbH & Co. KG
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – setting read flag when both message and attachment have been opened (no – administrative rule)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1892/17; 2021-8-27

TECHNOLOGY: #Automation_Control_and_Embedded_Systems #Energy_Management
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Physical_Process_Control
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Energy_and_Environment
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Patent_Maintained_As_Granted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed load-management method determines consumption curves and forecasts and uses them to apportion electrical power among consumers.
– Technical effect at issue: The prediction and planning steps contribute to actual measurement and control of electrical power; the Board recognised a synergistic effect relevant to more accurate power-consumption control (Reasons 2.1.4, 2.4 and 2.5.3).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The combination of power measurement, planning and control is technical even where some computational steps could in isolation be carried out mentally.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board took the modelling and allocation features into account, found the claimed combination non-obvious and rejected the late new inventive-step objection based on O1.
– Applicatioin field: The invention belongs to electrical energy and load management.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step and the admission of a fresh objection after the summons were decisive.
– Outcome: The patent proprietor succeeded: the appealed decision was set aside and the patent maintained as granted.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: SMA Solar Technology AG
OPPOSING-PARTY: Fronius International GmbH
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 100(a), 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Main request – Inventive step – (yes) ; Amendment of appeal case after summons – exceptional circumstances (no)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19, T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2448/16; 2021-6-25

TECHNOLOGY: #Simulation_CAD_and_Engineering_Design #CAD
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Added_Subject_Matter #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Added_Matter_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention concerns placing and editing two-dimensional software consumables within a three-dimensional spatial graphical editing application.
– Technical effect at issue: The Board found no non-obvious improvement of the computer or graphical interface from the claimed content manipulation and language-settings functionality (Reasons 3.1-3.6).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed computer-based graphical editing system has technical character, although many of its distinguishing instructions are cognitive or administrative.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The remaining technical implementation was conventional or obvious in view of the cited 3D editing art, and the admitted later claim amendments raised added-matter concerns.
– Applicatioin field: The setting is computer-based spatial/3D editing, discussed with reference to CAD-type functionality.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step, added subject-matter and admission of late auxiliary requests determined the examination.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed; the admitted requests failed on inventive step and additional amendment objections, while a later request was not admitted.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: On24, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 123(2); RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no) – mixture of technical and non-technical features ; Amendments – allowable (no) ; Amendment after summons – exceptional circumstances (yes) – exercise of discretion – taken into account (Auxiliary Request 2) (yes) – taken into account (Auxiliary Request 3) (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, G 0003/08, G 0001/19, T 1080/15
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0977/17; 2021-6-17; Storing electronic receipts/OTTO GROUP SOLUTION PROVIDER

TECHNOLOGY: #Digital_Commerce_and_Personalisation #Electronic_Receipt_Management_and_Resale
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Digital_Commerce_and_Content_Distribution
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claims cover storage and processing of purchase receipts, prediction of purchases, scanning printed receipts and attaching receipts to online resale offers.
– Technical effect at issue: Purchase prediction and resale documentation pursue business objectives; scanning a printed receipt did not add any non-obvious technical effect.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claims use real databases, scanners and computer equipment, so the technical-character threshold is met.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The purchase-analysis and resale features were non-technical, while the additional receipt scanning was an obvious technical implementation (Reasons 2-4).
– Applicatioin field: The system serves retail commerce, payment-receipt management and resale through an online marketplace.
– Decisive legal issue: The key question was inventive step in a claim combining administrative purchase-processing rules with familiar computer hardware.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because the main and auxiliary claims lacked inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Otto Group Solution Provider (OSP) GmbH
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – predicting future purchases using stored electronic payment receipts (no – business method) – scanning printed payment receipts (no – obvious) – automatically attaching electronic receipt to online resale offer (no – business method)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 0154/04
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0589/17; 2021-4-20; Guiding the user to a shop/SONY

TECHNOLOGY: #Digital_Commerce_and_Personalisation #Customer_Referral_and_Loyalty_Rewards
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Digital_Commerce_and_Content_Distribution
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The system uses a shop terminal, central server and mobile phone to guide a shopper to another shop and reward a follow-up purchase.
– Technical effect at issue: Customer redirection and bonus awards were commercial goals; the alleged reduction of manual transaction steps did not establish an inventive technical solution.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed retail network contains technical payment and communication equipment.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Using POS purchase data to verify the retail guidance condition and sending a bonus to a phone were obvious implementations of the given business scheme (Reasons 2.1-2.9).
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns retail cross-promotion and customer loyalty incentives.
– Decisive legal issue: The COMVIK analysis of the non-technical referral scheme and its routine computer implementation was decisive.
– Outcome: The main and auxiliary requests failed on inventive step, and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Sony Group Corporation
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – guiding customer to make a purchase (no – non-technical) – using POS information at server to check if customer has followed guidance (no – obvious implementation) – transmitting bonus to customer’s phone (no – obvious implementation)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1463/11, T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2522/16; 2021-3-25

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Data_Storage
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Manufacturing_and_Production_Planning
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The manufacturing collaboration hub synchronises and converts administrative production/material records across geographically separated plants.
– Technical effect at issue: Consistency of administrative information, centralised material-record control and data conversion were not technical effects beyond those of routine networked information exchange (Reasons 3.2.1-3.5).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A networked computer system is technical even when its stored data concern business administration.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The distinguishing material-master definitions, mirroring rules and production-order logic constituted administrative requirements implemented on conventional computers.
– Applicatioin field: The context is the planning and administration of manufacturing and production logistics.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step required differentiating actual physical process control from administrative data about production.
– Outcome: The main and auxiliary requests lacked inventive step and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Accenture Global Services Limited
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no) – auxiliary request (no) – mixture of technical and non-technical features
CITED DECISIONS: G 0003/08, G 0001/19, T 0769/92, T 0641/00, T 1670/07, T 1463/11, T 2049/12, T 0731/17
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1790/17; 2021-3-18; Redesigning product or process parameters/PROCTER & GAMBLE

TECHNOLOGY: #Automation_Control_and_Embedded_Systems #Process_Control
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Physical_Process_Control
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Manufacturing_and_Production_Planning
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Patent_Eligible_Subject_Matter #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests #Additional_Prior_Art_Search
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The amended claim connects data-based redesign of a product to a controller, technical process parameters and actual manufacture by a converting apparatus.
– Technical effect at issue: Unlike the initially claimed product redesign based on consumer feedback, the auxiliary request applies technical process data to physical manufacture (Reasons 8-10).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The original scheme was regarded as a non-technical business method under Article 52(2) EPC; the amended claim includes an express technical manufacturing step and is an invention.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): A technical contribution was recognised for the amended manufacturing-control features, but the Board did not decide their novelty or inventive step.
– Applicatioin field: The operative field is manufacturing process optimisation and control.
– Decisive legal issue: Patent eligibility, admission of the amended request after the summons and the need for full subsequent patentability examination were decisive.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted for a fresh examination; grant was not ordered.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
The purpose of the oral proceedings for the appellant is to better explain his case and for the Board to understand and clarify points which, perhaps, up to that point were not sufficiently clear. This is particularly relevant in ex parte cases where besides the applicant/appellant no other party is involved. If amendments resulting from such discussions were not possible, oral proceedings would be pointless. The new [substantially amended] auxiliary request was filed as a direct reaction following the exchange of arguments in the oral proceedings and addressing the objections and concerns the Board had. Furthermore, this request overcame the grounds on which the appealed decision was based. The Board considers the filing of such a request is justified by exceptional circumstances and therefore admits it into the proceedings. (See point 7 of the reasons)

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: The Procter & Gamble Company
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(2), 111(1); RPBA 2020 Art. 11, 12(2), 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Patentable invention – redesigning a product based on user feedback (no – business method) – controlling manufacture of a product with improved process data (yes – technical) ; Amendment after summons (yes – exceptional circumstances) ; Remittal (yes – exceptional circumstances)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2486/16; 2021-1-12

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Privacy_Technologies
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Insurance_and_Risk_Management
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The application processes vehicle location and driving information into risk scores for insurance pricing without sending raw location data to the insurer.
– Technical effect at issue: The disclosed privacy aim is to limit information disclosed to the insurer; this policy is distinct from protecting data against unauthorised third-party access and did not imply a new technical security effect (Reasons 5.2-5.10).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Onboard measurement/processing and transmission of scores occur in a technical computer/vehicle environment.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The data-disclosure restriction was a non-technical requirement, and computing a risk score on the vehicle and sending it instead of the detailed location data followed obviously from D1.
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns vehicle telematics used for insurance risk rating.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step and admission of auxiliary requests after the summons were decisive; the procedural headnotes emphasise the strict RPBA 2020 exceptional-circumstances test.
– Outcome: Novelty of the main request was acknowledged, but inventive step failed and the late auxiliary requests were not admitted; the appeal was dismissed.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
1. In applying Article 13(2) RPBA 2020 the Board may also rely on the criteria set out in Article 13(1) RPBA 2020 … . The criteria of Article 13(1) RPBA 2020 may therefore supplement, but do not supplant, the separate requirements of Article 13(2) RPBA 2020 (Reasons, point 6.4.1).
2. When filing requests within the period mentioned in Article 13(2) RPBA 2020, the party, in providing its “cogent reasons”, should not only identify the circumstances invoked and explain why they are to be regarded as “exceptional”, it should also explain why these circumstances had the direct result of preventing the party from filing its requests at an earlier stage. (Reasons, point 6.5.6).
3. The mere fact that, in a communication under Article 15(1) RPBA 2020, the Board departs in some respects from the reasoning of the Examining Division on inventive step (while reaching the same conclusion) does not constitute “exceptional circumstances” within the meaning of Article 13(2) RPBA 2020, nor does it open the door to the filing of new requests as a response (Reasons, point 6.6.3).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Appy Risk Technologies Limited
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(1), 54, 56, 122; EPC R. 136; RPBA 2020 Art. 12(3), 13(1), 13(2), 15(1)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Novelty – main request (yes) ; Inventive step – main request (no) – mixture of technical and non-technical features ; Late-filed auxiliary requests – admitted (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0495/91, T 0469/93, T 0641/00, T 2429/17
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1865/17; 2020-12-4; Generating two-dimensional visual objects/GMC SOFTWARE

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Human_Computer_Interaction
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention concerns rendering characters and other visual objects using local temporary representations and server-provided fonts or visual data.
– Technical effect at issue: Immediate readability and correct cursor positioning during continuing text entry are relevant to human-machine interaction, but mere cognitive readability alone is not necessarily technical (Reasons 4.5-4.6 and 8.2).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The method uses technical display and data-entry systems.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board considered the individual technical UI effects but found the local-font substitution and cursor relocation obvious, and rejected unsupported client-resource savings.
– Applicatioin field: The system is a general-purpose text/graphics user interface with network-supplied rendering information.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step for multiple claim sets and admissibility of a revised, late-filed auxiliary request determined the result.
– Outcome: All admitted requests lacked inventive step; the revised third auxiliary request was not admitted and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: GMC Software AG
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main request, revised main request, first to third auxiliary requests (no) ; Late-filed request – revised third auxiliary request – admitted (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 1143/06, T 1235/07, T 1741/08, T 1834/10, T 1802/13, T 2276/13, T 0336/14, T 0452/14, T 1091/17, T 0543/18
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0683/17; 2020-12-3

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Distributed_Computing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Enhanced_Security
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #Gaming_and_Entertainment
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed electronic roulette betting platform distributes functions over a central server architecture and remote gaming tables.
– Technical effect at issue: The applicant alleged extra security from repeated server-side bet authentication; the Board found ordinary player identification already implicit in the prior system, with no inventive security improvement (Reasons 3.5-3.8).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claims are directed to actual network servers, controllers and electronic roulette interfaces, so technical character is not in dispute.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Centralising known gaming-system functions constitutes a technical system-architecture choice, but the advantages and trade-offs of centralisation were common general knowledge and the implementation obvious.
– Applicatioin field: The application field is networked electronic roulette gaming.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive issues were inventive step and admission of auxiliary requests that had not been properly substantiated.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed after the main request failed for lack of inventive step and the auxiliary requests were not admitted.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Grubmüller, Walter
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA Art. 12(4)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main request (no) ; Auxiliary Requests – not substantiated – not admitted
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2573/16; 2019-11-6; OLAP-cube specification/ACCENTURE GLOBAL SERVICES

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Data_Structures
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention lets a user generate metadata files that specify multidimensional online analytical processing (OLAP) cubes for subsequent database analysis.
– Technical effect at issue: The four modules did not provide a property of the resulting metadata that caused an additional technical effect when ordinary OLAP processing used the file (Reasons 5.3-5.5).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The system consists of a physical computer, files and user-interface modules, and therefore is not excluded as a non-invention (Reason 5.1).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Selecting and modifying a template metadata file implements a non-technical clerical procedure by routine programming, without a non-obvious database-processing improvement.
– Applicatioin field: The system serves OLAP configuration for business data analysis.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step and the inadmissibility of the second auxiliary request were decisive.
– Outcome: The Board dismissed the appeal after no admitted claim request met Article 56 EPC.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Accenture Global Services Limited
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA Art. 12(4)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main request and first and third auxiliary requests (no) ; Late-filed request – second auxiliary request (not admitted)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/04, T 0154/04, T 1954/08, T 0817/16, T 0697/17
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1718/17; 2019-4-29; User habit list/HUAWEI

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Graphical_User_Interfaces
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Processing_Efficiency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Consumer_Electronics_and_Appliances
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed mobile-terminal interface displays a preference-ranked user-habit list, including time-dependent sub-tables for different periods of a day.
– Technical effect at issue: Precomputing sub-tables might increase interface responsiveness, but that is the familiar speed-versus-memory trade-off; an improved technical effect of the particular ranking rules was not established (Reasons 11.4-11.9 and 13.1-13.4).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A mobile terminal and its graphical interface have technical character.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Time-dependent adaptation, frequency/recency ranking and precomputation followed from known interface designs or ordinary computing knowledge; subjective priority rules without proven technical effects could not establish inventive step.
– Applicatioin field: The invention concerns smartphone and mobile-terminal user interfaces.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step over known adaptive user interfaces was decisive.
– Outcome: The Board dismissed the appeal for lack of inventive step in all requests.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step (no)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0199/16; 2021-10-14

TECHNOLOGY: #Automation_Control_and_Embedded_Systems #Sensor_Systems
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Logistics_and_Terminal_Operations
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claim concerns forklift usage-data acquisition, sensor readings, wireless transmission and central processing in a vehicle-fleet setting. The distinguishing calculation of a usage fee is a business rule.
– Technical effect at issue: Although transferring sensor readings to a central computer was presented as a way of reducing demands on embedded controllers, D4 already disclosed the relevant wireless monitoring architecture. No additional technical effect was established by calculating rental charges (reasons 4.2 and 4.6).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed method uses sensors, a wireless connection and a central processing unit and therefore has technical character as a whole.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The fee calculation is commercial and can be implemented by routine programming of the known host computer. The additional forklift, WLAN and driver-identification features did not establish an inventive technical distinction (reasons 4.6 and 6.6).
– Applicatioin field: The method is applied to the collection and commercial evaluation of operating data from industrial trucks used in material handling.
– Decisive legal issue: The principal question was inventive step under Article 56 EPC applying COMVIK. The Board additionally excluded late-filed auxiliary requests 2 to 6 under the applicable Rules of Procedure (reasons 6.4-6.7).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed: the main request and auxiliary request 1 lacked inventive step and auxiliary requests 2 to 6 were not admitted.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: STILL GmbH
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPÜ Art. 56; VOBK Art. 12(4); VOBK 2020 Art. 13(1), 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Erfinderische Tätigkeit – Aufgabe-Lösungs-Ansatz – Mischung technischer und nichttechnischer Merkmale – Hauptantrag (nein) – Hilfsantrag (nein); Spät eingereichter Antrag – eingereicht kurz vor der mündlichen Verhandlung – zugelassen (nein) – Antrag hätte bereits im erstinstanzlichen Verfahren vorgebracht werden können (ja) – Antrag eindeutig gewährbar (nein)
AI-TRANSLATED-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – problem-solution approach – mixture of technical and non-technical features – main request (no) – auxiliary request (no); Late-filed request – filed shortly before oral proceedings – admitted (no) – request could already have been filed in first-instance proceedings (yes) – request clearly allowable (no)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0003/08, G 0001/19, T 0641/00, T 0133/12, T 0143/14, T 1075/14, T 2147/16
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1746/16; 2021-3-4

TECHNOLOGY: #Financial_Transaction_and_Payment_Technologies #QR_Code_Mobile_Payment_Processing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Reduced_Data_Transfer #Enhanced_Security
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Mobile_Payments_and_Contactless_Transactions
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention implements a QR-code-based payment between a merchant and customer using two mobile phones, with transaction data decoded on the customer device and an encrypted authorisation SMS sent to a server.
– Technical effect at issue: Processing the payment with one encrypted mobile-network message instead of the multiple server communications in D1 reduces network traffic and dependencies while maintaining transaction security (reasons 2.5 and 2.7.8-2.7.13).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The mobile devices, optical code handling, encryption and communications plainly establish the technical character of the claimed method.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board took account of the cooperating implementation features, including some that might be non-technical in isolation, because they achieved reduced communications and maintained security. D1 taught away from this architecture (reasons 2.7.4-2.7.14).
– Applicatioin field: The claimed technology concerns mobile peer-to-peer payment initiation and authorisation using QR codes and SMS.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive issue was inventive step of the complete communication and authorisation arrangement under Article 56 EPC.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted with an order to grant a patent on the specified claims, description and drawings.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Cavaterra, Marco; Di Tucci, Cosmo
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (yes) – mixture of technical and non-technical features – skilled person
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19, T 0697/17, T 2314/16, T 1463/11
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0929/15; 2020-11-17; Identifying a user issuing a voice request/ACCENTURE

TECHNOLOGY: #Media_and_Signal_Processing #Speech_Recognition
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Voice_Biometric_User_Identification
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Biometric_Authentication
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed client-server voice interface processes spoken requests and identifies the speaker by extracting voice features and matching them against stored voiceprints.
– Technical effect at issue: The distinctive technical effect is associating each spoken request with its actual speaker without a separate identity-entry step, permitting reliable and convenient speaker-to-request mapping (reasons 2.2-2.5).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed network, voice processing and speaker identification are technical subject matter.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The speaker-recognition step forms part of processing the incoming request; the prior art instead required identification before a request could be accepted. The Board found that distinction non-obvious (reasons 2.6-2.8).
– Applicatioin field: The relevant practical application is voice-based biometric identification in a multi-user digital device network.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was decisive. The amended claims were also held allowable under Articles 123(2) and 84 EPC and admitted under Article 13(2) RPBA 2020.
– Outcome: The decision was set aside and the examining division was ordered to grant a patent on the amended claims, with description and figures to be adapted.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Accenture Global Services Limited
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 123(2), 84, 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Amendments – allowable (yes); Claims – clarity after amendment (yes); Inventive step – after amendment (yes)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0426/16; 2020-9-17

TECHNOLOGY: #Statistical_Modelling_and_Data_Analytics #Commodity_Price_Index_Modelling
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Financial_Markets_and_Trading
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The proposed method generates and updates an investment index for fresh water using product prices, water quantities, market weights and appraisal information.
– Technical effect at issue: The calculated index and values of collateral represent financial valuations. The alleged water-appraisal and display features did not establish an additional technical effect beyond using conventional computer equipment (reasons 4.3-4.9).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): At least the processor, memory and display confer technical character on the computer-implemented claims, although most substantive steps describe a business scheme.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The index calculations and water-certificate marketing are non-technical business requirements that a programmer could implement on a standard computer without inventive technical measures (reasons 4.9-4.10).
– Applicatioin field: The claims concern commodities investment and valuation of water-backed financial instruments.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step applying the distinction between technical implementation and non-technical financial requirements determined the refusal. The Board separately expressed added-matter concerns for certain amendments.
– Outcome: All requests failed under Article 56 EPC and the appeal was dismissed; the concerns under Article 123(2) EPC were not the sole basis for the order.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Aqua Index Ltd.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 123(2), 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – mixture of technical and non-technical features – (no) – all requests
CITED DECISIONS: G 0003/08, T 0769/92, T 0931/95, T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0595/16; 2020-9-14; Kontrollbedüftiges Fahrzeug/TOLLCOLLECT

TECHNOLOGY: #Transportation_and_Tolling_Systems #Road_Toll_Enforcement
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Transportation_and_Travel
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention selects potentially non-compliant toll-paying vehicles into case groups and forwards vehicle information for checks at roadside control points.
– Technical effect at issue: The allocation of suspicious cases and prioritisation according to available inspection personnel express operational or legal requirements; they do not solve a further technical problem (reasons 1.4-1.6).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Data processing and transmission within a toll-enforcement system are technical means, so the invention has technical character overall.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The distinguishing control-point designation and personnel-directed case grouping add no inventive technical contribution over the prior toll verification arrangement.
– Applicatioin field: The subject matter is enforcement and operational administration of road toll collection.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was decisive; the decision also dealt with partial reimbursement of the appeal fee under Rule 103(4)(c) EPC.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed for lack of inventive step. Separately, 25% of the appeal fee was ordered to be reimbursed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Toll Collect GmbH
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPÜ Art. 56; EPÜ R. 103
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Erfinderische Tätigkeit – (nein)
AI-TRANSLATED-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2379/16; 2020-9-11

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Information_Presentation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Event_Ticketing_and_Attendance
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention provides customer ratings and computed quality assessments for event seats and standing areas through a web-based reservation interface.
– Technical effect at issue: A quality-optimised seat choice is a commercial or cognitive benefit, not an objectively established technical effect. Interpolation and weighting of seat assessments did not change this (reasons 3.3-4.3).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The use of a networked computer, memory and input/output equipment suffices for technical character of the claimed combination.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Producing and displaying seat ratings is a business requirement implemented with commonplace computer functions; no specific technical database, hardware or user-interaction improvement was claimed.
– Applicatioin field: The claimed system is used for ticket selection and seat reservation for events.
– Decisive legal issue: The Board applied Article 56 EPC and the COMVIK approach; it distinguished technical implementation from non-technical information content and customer preferences.
– Outcome: The main and all three auxiliary requests lacked inventive step, so the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Laurini, Frank
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPÜ Art. 52(2)(c), 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Patentierbare Erfindung – technische und nichttechnische Merkmale – technischer Charakter der Erfindung – computerimplementierte Erfindung; Erfinderische Tätigkeit – (nein) – Aufgabe-Lösungs-Ansatz
AI-TRANSLATED-KEYWORDS: Patentable invention – technical and non-technical features – technical character of the invention – computer-implemented invention; Inventive step – (no) – problem-solution approach
CITED DECISIONS: G 0003/08, T 0641/00, T 0643/00, T 0619/02, T 0172/03, T 0258/03, T 0306/04, T 0336/07, T 1670/07
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1353/15; 2020-8-27

TECHNOLOGY: #Digital_Commerce_and_Personalisation #Customer_Profile_Based_Product_Selection
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Pet_Food_Customisation_and_Direct_Sales
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention gathers pet characteristics, creates a pet profile, recommends products, accepts orders and arranges manufacture and packaging of customised pet food.
– Technical effect at issue: The Board found no claimed functional link by which pet-profile data technically controlled manufacturing or packaging, nor evidence of improved customisation or a simpler ordering process (reasons 3.5.1-3.5.4).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Physical manufacturing and packaging operations, and the computer-network embodiments, supply technical means; the overall claims are not excluded as non-technical subject matter as such.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The pet-profile, product-selection and ordering rules are administrative. Generic servers and familiar manufacturing steps do not provide an inventive technical implementation.
– Applicatioin field: The practical field is consumer-direct customised pet food selection, ordering and production.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step turned on the absence of a technical causal relationship between customer information and the alleged production benefit.
– Outcome: The main request and auxiliary requests I-IX all lacked inventive step, and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Société des Produits Nestlé S.A.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC 1973 Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – all requests (no)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2087/15; 2020-7-21

TECHNOLOGY: #Statistical_Modelling_and_Data_Analytics #Competence_Scoring_and_Assessment
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Education_and_E_Learning
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed computer selects exam questions from a database, evaluates them using prior answers and discards items that fail predetermined test-quality criteria.
– Technical effect at issue: The improved pedagogical quality and perceived objectivity of a question set are not technical effects. Greater computing efficiency was not shown across the broad claim scope (reasons 4.3-4.3.6).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A general-purpose computer, storage device and evaluation software establish the technical character of the overall computer-implemented method.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Selection and evaluation rules belong to teaching and test preparation. Implementing those non-technical constraints on a conventional computer was routine (reasons 4.4-4.7).
– Applicatioin field: The application is automated examination-question selection and educational assessment.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive question was inventive step of independent method claim 8 in a mixed technical/non-technical invention.
– Outcome: Claim 8 of the sole request lacked inventive step and the appeal was dismissed; the Board did not need a final ruling on system claim 1.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Reliant Exams AS
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 12(8)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – claim 8 of sole request (no) – mixture of technical and non-technical features
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 0172/03, T 0258/03, T 1543/06
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0943/16; 2020-6-25; Tier assignments/MICROSOFT TECHNOLOGY LICENSING

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Indexing #Data_Storage
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Reduced_Latency #Improved_Processing_Efficiency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Additional_Prior_Art_Search
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed search engine uses historical queries and search results to optimise the placement of indexed digital items in storage tiers having different access speeds.
– Technical effect at issue: Optimised tier placement changes actual storage locations and statistically improves average retrieval times. This is a technical effect, not merely the consequence of a business choice (reasons 4.3-4.4).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Computer-implemented allocation of indexed data to physical storage tiers is technical subject matter.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board expressly recognised the technical contribution of workload-based placement. It rejected D1 as an unsuitable starting point, but did not finally determine inventive step over potentially relevant further prior art.
– Applicatioin field: The invention operates in search-engine indexes and tiered computer-storage systems.
– Decisive legal issue: The appealed inventive-step reasoning was erroneous. An incomplete search meant inventive step could not be finally assessed; special reasons justified remittal (reasons 5.2-5.3).
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted for further prosecution, without an order to grant.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Microsoft Technology Licensing, LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 111(1); RPBA 2020 Art. 11, 12(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – claimed subject-matter not rendered obvious by D1; Remittal to the department of first instance – special reasons for remitting the case (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1965/11, T 0565/17, T 0697/17
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0848/15; 2020-6-24

TECHNOLOGY: #Statistical_Modelling_and_Data_Analytics #Risk_Index_Modelling
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Insurance_and_Risk_Management
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention fits selected statistical loss-distribution functions to historic insurance-loss data in order to estimate risks for different lines of business.
– Technical effect at issue: The computed loss probabilities and tail distributions represent abstract economic risk estimates. No claimed physical model or computational improvement supported an additional technical effect (reasons 3.2 and 6).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): An ordinary computer, database and graphical interface suffice for technical character, but do not make the underlying economic modelling technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Model selection and fitting depend on the economist’s financial requirements. Implementing those requirements on conventional hardware was straightforward (reasons 3.2 and 5).
– Applicatioin field: The claimed application is actuarial and insurance-risk modelling.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC 1973 was decisive. The Board also refused the requested remittal for a further search.
– Outcome: The main and both auxiliary requests failed and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Swiss Reinsurance Company Ltd.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC 1973 Art. 56, 111(1)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Remittal to the department of first instance – (no); Inventive step – (no) – mixture of technical and non-technical features
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2363/16; 2019-12-6; URL based email filtering/MICROSOFT TECHNOLOGY LICENSING

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Access_Control
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Cybersecurity
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The system extracts URLs from emails, retrieves website-appropriateness ratings and blocks messages under a threshold-based filtering policy.
– Technical effect at issue: The claimed blocking thresholds and rating granularity express user content preferences rather than an improvement in computer filtering performance. Standard client-side filtering added no unexpected technical effect.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Parsing email, querying rating servers and performing filtering on a computer are technical operations.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The differences over D11 concerned non-technical criteria for assessing message content and their obvious implementation; the user-defined blocking policy did not contribute inventive technical subject matter (reasons 3.2-5.2).
– Applicatioin field: The claimed context is email-content filtering and web-access control.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step hinged on whether the content-appropriateness policy contributed technically under the COMVIK analysis.
– Outcome: Both the main and auxiliary request lacked inventive step and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Microsoft Technology Licensing, LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0022/12
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1139/16; 2019-4-9; Bestätigungselement/KARL STORZ

TECHNOLOGY: #Automation_Control_and_Embedded_Systems #Process_Control
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Healthcare_and_Medical
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed system centrally sets procedure-specific parameters of surgical devices and uses an operator-confirmation control before accepting those parameters.
– Technical effect at issue: The alleged increase in patient safety relied on the surgeon consciously reading and assessing displayed settings. This cognitive link did not establish a direct technical effect (the broken-technical-chain reasoning, reasons 1.6 and 2.3).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Control units, displays, confirmation elements and medical-device parameters confer technical character on the system.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The confirmation requirement did not solve a demonstrated objective technical problem; further device-control modifications were known or obvious. The timing argument of auxiliary request 4 also did not show an improvement over D1.
– Applicatioin field: The technology is used in the preparation and control of medical equipment for surgical procedures.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step and the non-admission of a late-filed auxiliary request were decisive.
– Outcome: The requests considered on their merits lacked inventive step, the late-filed request was not admitted, and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Karl Storz SE & Co. KG
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPÜ Art. 56; VOBK Art. 13(1)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Erfinderische Tätigkeit – (nein); Spät eingereichter Antrag – zugelassen (nein)
AI-TRANSLATED-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no); Late-filed request – admitted (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1670/07
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1823/15; 2019-2-19

TECHNOLOGY: #Automation_Control_and_Embedded_Systems #Sensor_Systems
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Determination_of_Physical_Parameters
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Cash_Handling_and_Point_of_Sale_Equipment
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed method determines a reference measurement for counting physical coins and notes using readings of a load cell integrated into a cash till.
– Technical effect at issue: The algorithm processes actual weight-sensor readings to derive a physical measurement and thus serves an adequately defined technical purpose (reasons 2.13-2.14).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A load-cell measurement and cash-till monitoring apparatus are technical subject matter, not an excluded mathematical method as such.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The mathematical steps contribute to technical character because they are functionally limited to physical weighing. Their inventive step must be assessed, but the Board did not decide whether the algorithm was non-obvious.
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns cash handling and weight-based monitoring in cash tills.
– Decisive legal issue: The central error was excluding the sensor-processing algorithm as non-technical in the inventive-step analysis. Clarity and added-matter objections were also resolved in the applicant’s favour.
– Outcome: The decision was set aside and remitted for a fresh inventive-step assessment including the algorithm; no order to grant was issued.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Cash Bases Limited
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(1), 56, 84, 111(1), 123(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Amendments – added subject-matter (no); Claims – clarity (yes); Remittal to the department of first instance – (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1227/05, T 1784/06
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0277/16; 2018-6-26; Location-based computer access/GOOGLE

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Authentication #Access_Control
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Enhanced_Security #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Cybersecurity
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention learns familiar geographical areas from clusters of successful logins and dynamically selects more or less burdensome authentication methods according to device location.
– Technical effect at issue: The learning mechanism adjusts access control seamlessly while helping prevent unauthorised access after device theft; it provides a concrete balance between security and user convenience (reasons 9.3-10.3).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Electronic authentication, location measurements and access control are technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board rejected the view that the adaptive zone criteria were merely a non-technical policy: they directly changed technical device access and usability. Neither D1, D2 nor D3 suggested the claimed learning mechanism.
– Applicatioin field: The system concerns location-aware device authentication and security.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step turned on whether dynamic security-policy criteria contributed technically under the COMVIK approach.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted with an order to grant a patent on the specified documents.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Google LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – yes – mixture of technical and non-technical features
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2362/13; 2020-9-1; Logistics central station/SCHNEIDER LOGISTICS

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Graphical_User_Interfaces
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Logistics_and_Terminal_Operations
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claim concerns a logistics central station that offers different functions and user interfaces to sender, recipient and other user roles; it does not claim a technical mechanism for physically shipping goods.
– Technical effect at issue: The alleged improvements in shipment transfer and interface ease of use were not accepted as technical effects of the distinguishing features. Role-specific availability of administrative functions follows business requirements.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Computer, network interface, processor, database and user-interface elements give the claimed system technical character; this was not the obstacle to patentability.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The allocation of functions to user classes is an administrative specification. Implementing it on an ordinary centralised or client-server computer was routine and did not provide an inventive technical contribution.
– Applicatioin field: The application is concerned with the administration of product shipments and access to logistics functions, not with technical transport-control equipment.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive question was inventive step under Article 56 EPC, assessed using the distinction between administrative requirements and their technical implementation. The main and auxiliary requests failed.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because the claims of the main request and the two auxiliary requests lacked an inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Schneider Logistics, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 52(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – providing different user interfaces and functions to different classes of users – (no – obvious implementation of non-technical requirements)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 0983/11, T 0003/90
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0452/14; 2020-2-13; Integrating charts in documents / MICROSOFT

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Human_Computer_Interaction
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Lower_Memory_Usage
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claims deal with editing and updating embedded charts through cooperation between a host application and spreadsheet software, including choosing a visible or non-visible spreadsheet instance.
– Technical effect at issue: Reduced memory and computer-resource use was alleged for non-visible spreadsheet instances, but the Board found that assertion too general and speculative without specifying the underlying actions. User-friendliness through shortcuts was a credible effect instead.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The computer-implemented cooperation of applications and their user interfaces is technical as a whole.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Invoking spreadsheet actions through shortcuts and suppressing unnecessary visual indications involve technical implementation decisions, but were obvious to the skilled person. Keeping a chart synchronised with its underlying data was treated as a non-technical requirement to implement.
– Applicatioin field: The invention concerns general-purpose office computing, document authoring, spreadsheets and chart editing.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was assessed against D5 and common general knowledge. The absence of a supported resource-saving effect prevented formulation of the more ambitious technical problem proposed by the appellant.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed; neither the main request nor the auxiliary requests established an inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Microsoft Technology Licensing, LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – handling user action with non-visible instance of spreadsheet (no – obvious)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1308/13; 2019-12-17; Customised shared environment/DISNEY

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Information_Presentation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Gaming_and_Entertainment
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention customises visual elements in a shared virtual world and adapts interaction data, such as chat text, to each participant’s customised view.
– Technical effect at issue: The Board held that personalising the shared environment and translating references to its elements concerned presentation of information or the rules of a game, not the solution of a technical problem.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The online environment and its computer implementation furnish technical means, but the distinguishing customisation rules are non-technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Under COMVIK, the customisation and message-adaptation requirements form part of the non-technical specification; implementing them through routine programming was obvious.
– Applicatioin field: The disclosed example is a multi-user virtual world or computer game in which different users see different representations of the same shared item.
– Decisive legal issue: Article 56 EPC was decisive. The Board rejected the asserted technical problem of reconciling individual personalisation with a shared social environment.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed for lack of inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Disney Enterprises, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – customising a shared enviornment – translation of interaction data (no – not technical)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1177/97, T 0769/92, T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1039/13; 2019-12-11; Updating information/EQUIFAX

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Data_Record_Classification_and_Linking
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The method updates customer information between an information supplier and buyers, using distinct identifiers for records and a mapping between customer and supplier identifiers.
– Technical effect at issue: The appellant invoked better database security and retrieval efficiency. The Board regarded limiting information disclosure as a commercial requirement, and identifier assignment and mapping as standard database practice; no inventive technical effect was demonstrated.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The database and its computerised exchange of information provide technical implementation, although the information-service concept is commercial.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Customer-file delivery, retention of data control and separation of buyers were treated as business requirements. Different primary keys and a conversion table were natural or known technical implementations in view of D6.
– Applicatioin field: The context is the sale, maintenance and updating of information about economic entities and customers.
– Decisive legal issue: The inventive-step analysis drew the COMVIK boundary between business requirements and technical implementation, expressly discussing the notional business person from T 1463/11.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because the main request and both auxiliary requests lacked an inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Equifax, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – information supplier receiving and updating information buyer’s database (no – non technical requirement)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 1463/11
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1818/14; 2019-12-2; User interface for appliance/ELECTROLUX

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Information_Presentation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Consumer_Electronics_and_Appliances
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed appliance interface represents an operating mode through an animated graphics icon combining static and dynamic visual content.
– Technical effect at issue: The Board found no demonstrated improvement in operating the oven or other appliance; the distinguishing graphic presentation was essentially aesthetic. Its elementary implementation as a pictogram overlaid with image frames was obvious.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A controller and display in an appliance are technical, but visual attractiveness alone does not make the particular information presentation inventive.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The icon arrangement contributed at most a conventional technical implementation of a non-technical display concept. The appeal also raised separate procedural questions concerning admissibility of auxiliary requests.
– Applicatioin field: The claimed interface is intended for domestic or industrial appliances, with an oven used in the technical analysis.
– Decisive legal issue: The main request failed under Article 56 EPC. Auxiliary requests were not admitted under Articles 12 and 13 RPBA owing to insufficient substantiation, lack of convergence or prima facie defects, including unclear wording in later requests.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed. The Board found the main request obvious and admitted no auxiliary request capable of changing the result.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Electrolux Home Products Corporation N.V.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA Art. 12, 13
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Document D4 made available to the public (yes); Inventive step (no) – main request; Admissibility of auxiliary requests (no) – either not substantiated or prima facie not allowable
CITED DECISIONS: G 0010/93, T 0055/01, T 1185/13, T 0641/00, T 1903/13, T 1634/09, T 0217/10
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1902/13; 2019-7-4; Assessing competence levels/SWISS RE

TECHNOLOGY: #Statistical_Modelling_and_Data_Analytics #Competence_Scoring_and_Assessment
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The application calculates organisational competence levels from questions, responses, weights and scores, including graphical depictions of the resulting indicators.
– Technical effect at issue: Neither automation of scoring and weighting nor a spider diagram produced a further technical effect. The diagrams were directed to human interpretation of assessment data.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claims use commonplace networked computers, memory and electronic processing, so the claimed combination has technical character overall.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The scoring rules are an abstract administrative assessment concept given to the programmer as requirements. Its implementation using ordinary computing operations is obvious, with no distinctive technical arrangement or synergy shown.
– Applicatioin field: The subject matter is organisational competence assessment in business administration; it is not a technical model of physical processes.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive issue was inventive step under Article 56 EPC, including the proper formulation of the objective problem as implementing a business assessment method, not simply speeding it up.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because all relevant requests failed to satisfy Article 56 EPC.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Swiss Reinsurance Company Ltd.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 111(1)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – assessing the competence of an organisation by processing score data (no – obvious implementation of a business method)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1194/97, T 0641/00, T 0258/03
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0239/14; 2019-6-13; CHARGING FOR DIRECTED PROVISIONING OF USER APPLICATIONS ON LIMITED-RESOURCE DEVICES/ALCATEL

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Mobile_Communications
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Digital_Commerce_and_Content_Distribution
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed mobile client-server system charges users for consumed digital content using server-side billing rules and client-side licence or authorisation terms.
– Technical effect at issue: Locating licensing rules on the client and billing terms on the server did not generate a further technical effect. The possible offline availability of licensing rules was considered part of the billing concept rather than a technical contribution.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The client, server, communication and processing equipment make the method technical as a whole within Article 52 EPC.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Content authorisations, licence terms and charging parameters were treated as cognitive and administrative data. Their automated handling in the known mobile communications infrastructure of D1 was straightforward.
– Applicatioin field: The relevant commercial context is billing and licensing of mobile digital content and user applications.
– Decisive legal issue: The decision turns on the application of Article 56 EPC and COMVIK to a mixed technical and non-technical charging method; the main and auxiliary claims were analysed.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed for lack of inventive step in both the main and auxiliary requests.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Alcatel-Lucent USA Inc.; Gidron, Yoad; Holder, Ophir; Teichholtz, Haim
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – mixture of technical and non-technical features – main and auxiliary request (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0258/03, T 0641/00, T 1194/97
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1648/13; 2018-11-12; Video editing/CORE WIRELESS

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Human_Computer_Interaction
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Digital_Video_Editing_and_Production
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Novelty
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention concerns a GUI for editing two video streams on a small display using a minimal input device, including horizontal and vertical timelines and an overlapping frame-selection area.
– Technical effect at issue: In the amended first auxiliary request, the arrangement supported an actual video-editing operation by enabling the user to select frames from the two streams. This functional user-computer interaction, unlike mere display layout, had a technical effect.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Both requests use technical computer and display means; the main request nevertheless claimed only information presentation and lacked an inventive technical contribution.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The additional interactive editing features made the GUI arrangement technically relevant. The Board found no obvious route to that solution from the cited video-editing or browsing prior art.
– Applicatioin field: Digital video editing and multimedia production is a more accurate application field than generic imaging or content distribution; this tag is newly added.
– Decisive legal issue: Novelty and inventive step of the first auxiliary request were assessed, including the relevance of an earlier European application and documents D4, D7 and D5.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted with an order to grant a patent on the amended first auxiliary request, subject to description adaptation.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Core Wireless Licensing S.à r.l.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(2)(d), 54(1), 56; EPC 1973 Art. 54(3), 54(4)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main request (no) – auxiliary request (yes) – mixture of technical and non-technical features; Novelty – auxiliary request (yes) – prior European application
CITED DECISIONS: T 1214/09, T 0505/13
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2330/13; 2018-5-9; Checking selection conditions/SAP

TECHNOLOGY: #Software_and_Computer_Architecture #Parallel_Processing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Processing_Efficiency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Manufacturing_and_Production_Planning
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Additional_Prior_Art_Search
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The computer-implemented method checks consistency of selection rules in a product configuration system using specific bit strings, bit matrices, sub-matrices and parallel processing.
– Technical effect at issue: Parallel evaluation of sub-matrices was credibly capable of improving computational efficiency. In contrast, checking the logical consistency of configuration rules and generating a bill of materials were not technical aims in themselves.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The computer-implemented claim has technical character, but technical significance of its distinguishing algorithmic features required a separate COMVIK analysis.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board recognised the bit structures and operations specifically adapted for parallel processing as contributing to technical character, even without a claim restricted to a particular hardware architecture.
– Applicatioin field: The setting is checking constraints for configured manufactured products and their component variants.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step had to be reassessed against relevant prior art rather than only a notorious general-purpose computer. The Board also found that amended claims overcame the main clarity and added-matter objections.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the application remitted for further prosecution; patent grant or inventive step was not finally decided.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: SAP SE
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(2), 52(3), 56, 84, 123(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – mixture of technical and non-technical features; Claims – clarity after amendment (yes); Amendments – added subject-matter (objections overcome)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0003/08, T 0208/84, T 0935/97, T 1194/97, T 0049/99, T 0641/00, T 0424/03, T 0154/04, T 1351/04, T 1784/06, T 1954/08, T 0042/09, T 0426/09, T 0042/10, T 1321/11, T 1965/11, T 0969/12
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0556/14; 2016-7-28; Masking a private key/CERTICOM

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Cryptography
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Enhanced_Security
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Cybersecurity
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Maintain_Patent

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The patent relates to masking private keys for elliptic-curve cryptographic calculations by randomised splitting and corresponding computations on a smart card.
– Technical effect at issue: Protecting a hardware cryptographic computation against power-analysis side-channel attacks is a technical effect. The hardware execution is essential: an abstract mathematical masking method alone would not establish that effect.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Smart-card storage and execution give the method technical character; the claim is not confined to a mathematical method as such.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board accepted the hardware-linked resistance to power analysis as a technical effect and found the claimed randomised key splitting non-obvious over D2, particularly compared with the effective-zero masking approach.
– Applicatioin field: The invention addresses practical security of cryptographic implementations on physical devices.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was decisive after amendments; the Board also considered novelty, added subject-matter and sufficiency objections in the opposition appeal.
– Outcome: The revocation was set aside and the case remitted with an order to maintain the patent in amended form on the specified claims, description and drawings.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Certicom Corp.
OPPOSING-PARTY: Müller, Christoph
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC 1973 Art. 54, 56, 100; EPC Art. 52, 54(3), 123(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: The protection of a cryptographic computation against power analysis attacks is a technical effect; Inventive step – after amendment (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1173/97, T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1098/12; 2017-7-12; Computer program with limited lifetime/Nokia

TECHNOLOGY: #Software_and_Computer_Architecture #Memory_Management
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Lower_Memory_Usage
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #Digital_Commerce_and_Content_Distribution
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed scheme distributes time-limited software to mobile terminals and provides automatic uninstallation and retention of customised settings; memory management is the technically relevant software aspect.
– Technical effect at issue: Automatic deletion of expired applications can free scarce mobile-device memory. The Board considered this resource-management measure obvious, even on the applicant’s proposed technical problem.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Use of mobile terminals, software downloads and database operations supplies technical means, so the claims are not excluded as a business method as such.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The limited-time software sales model was non-technical. Automatic uninstallation, licence records and the preservation of settings were routine implementations or obvious memory-management measures.
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns commercial distribution, time-limited licensing and download of software for mobile terminals.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive question was inventive step under Article 56 EPC 1973; the Board also addressed the Article 52 computer-program/business-method exclusion.
– Outcome: Neither the main nor the auxiliary request was inventive; the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Nokia Technologies Oy
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC 1973 Art. 94(1), 52(2)(c), 52(3), 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0434/13; 2017-1-26; Generating availability data of a called party/MITEL

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Call_Routing_and_Management
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Telecommunications
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The computer-based call-handling proposal predicts a called party’s availability from calendar and meeting information; the technical setting is telecommunications.
– Technical effect at issue: The asserted savings in communications resources depended on possible future calls, which claim 1 did not require. A specific further technical effect of the availability estimate was not established.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The computer implementation gives the method technical character in the threshold sense of Article 52 EPC.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Calendar comparison, confidence assessment and availability prediction were non-technical; software agents and database queries amounted to routine computer implementation.
– Applicatioin field: The predicted availability information was intended for call handling in communications systems.
– Decisive legal issue: The main request failed for lack of inventive step under COMVIK. The late auxiliary request was not admitted under Article 13(1) RPBA.
– Outcome: With the main request unallowable and the auxiliary request inadmissible, the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Mitel Networks Corporation
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA Art. 13(1)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step (main request) – no; Admissibility (auxiliary request) – no
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0625/11; 2017-1-19

TECHNOLOGY: #Simulation_CAD_and_Engineering_Design #Computer_Simulations
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Determination_of_Physical_Parameters
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Energy_and_Environment
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Patent_Eligible_Subject_Matter
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention uses computer simulation of nuclear-reactor operating transients and fuel-rod cladding stresses to determine a reactor operating-parameter limit.
– Technical effect at issue: The calculated limit corresponds to a physical cladding-rupture criterion; it describes a technically meaningful boundary for reactor operation, even without an actual reactor-control step.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Computer implementation establishes technical character under Article 52(1) EPC. More importantly, the claim is tied to reactor-specific physical quantities.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board recognised a technical contribution extending beyond the ordinary algorithm–computer interaction: the simulated physical parameters and reactor operating limit have an intrinsic technical context.
– Applicatioin field: The method concerns the engineering and safe operation of nuclear reactors.
– Decisive legal issue: The core issue was inventive step of a technical simulation, with related issues of claim interpretation and Article 52 technical character.
– Outcome: The Board allowed the main request, set aside the refusal and remitted with an order to grant a patent on the stated documents.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: AREVA NP
LEGAL PROVISIONS: CBE Art. 123(2), 52(1); CBE 1973 Art. 56, 84
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Invention brevetable – caractère technique de l’invention; Principes applicables en matière d’interprétation des revendications
AI-TRANSLATED-KEYWORDS: Patentable invention – technical character of the invention; Principles applicable to claim interpretation
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/03, T 0939/92, T 0641/00, T 0619/02, T 0258/03, T 0154/04, T 0471/05, T 1227/05, T 1265/09, T 1586/09, T 1393/11, T 0531/09
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1145/10; 2016-2-26; Document region protection/MICROSOFT TECHNOLOGY LICENSING

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Access_Control
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Enhanced_Security #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The word-processing method restricts editing of selected document regions and provides dynamic user indications of access permissions.
– Technical effect at issue: Enforcing read/write access rights to stored document data was recognised as technical; displaying editing status could also improve interaction with the protected document.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Operation of the word-processing system and enforcement of access rights make the claimed subject-matter technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board criticised an overly generic reliance on a notorious computer but ultimately found the claimed access-control and status-message implementations obvious in view of the actual prior art.
– Applicatioin field: The invention concerns electronic document editing and protection in general-purpose word processors.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive issue was inventive step of mixed administrative access rules and technical implementation.
– Outcome: The main request and the relevant auxiliary requests did not involve an inventive step; the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Microsoft Technology Licensing, LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no) – mixture of technical and non-technical features
CITED DECISIONS: T 0643/00, T 0154/04, T 0690/06
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1286/09; 2015-6-11; Image classifier/INTELLECTUAL VENTURES

TECHNOLOGY: #Artificial_Intelligence_and_Machine_Learning #Model_Training
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Image_Classification_Reliability
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Digital_Imaging_and_Scene_Recognition
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The method trains a semantic image classifier using a systematically expanded training set generated by mirroring, cropping and altering colours or illumination.
– Technical effect at issue: Expanded exemplar diversity improves recognition of real-world scene variation in the semantic classification of digital colour images.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Processing actual digital images to train and use a classifier is a computer-implemented technical image-processing activity.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board distinguished the claimed colour-scene training procedure from the cited optical-character-recognition prior art and found the claimed subject-matter inventive.
– Applicatioin field: The application lies in digital image processing and semantic scene recognition, rather than geolocation.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was decisive, in conjunction with amendments addressing formal clarity and added-subject-matter concerns.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted with an order to grant on the approved single claim, with the description and drawings to be adapted.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Intellectual Ventures Fund 83 LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (yes)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0318/10; 2014-9-2; Load Distribution/CLUB IT

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Distributed_Computing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Balanced_Server_Resource_Utilisation
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A server/client load distributor selects a processing server using estimated CPU and memory demands and a distance measure relative to balanced resource capacity.
– Technical effect at issue: The resource-based allocation policy balances server utilisation and improves the technical distribution of processing requests among servers.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed allocation is carried out in a real network of servers and clients, and the mathematics is tied to computing-resource management.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The resource-distance selection was not dismissed as a mathematical formulation as such; the Board did not find an obvious path from the cited prior art to the claimed allocation.
– Applicatioin field: The system is general server and distributed-computing infrastructure.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive issue was inventive step, following amendments that overcame claim-form and reference-sign objections.
– Outcome: The appealed refusal was set aside and the case remitted with an order to grant on the main request.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Club IT Corporation
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC 1973 Art. 56, 84; EPC 1973 R. 35(3), 29(2); EPC Art. 52(2)(a)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (yes); “Non-technical mathematical formulation” – (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0208/84
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0631/08; 2014-3-7; Improving image quality/SONY

TECHNOLOGY: #Media_and_Signal_Processing #Image_Processing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Alleged_Technical_Contribution_Not_Established_Across_Claim_Scope
APPLICATION FIELD: #Digital_Commerce_and_Content_Distribution
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The content server profiles users and varies the relative quality of image portions according to inferred user interests.
– Technical effect at issue: The purported image-transmission improvement did not follow throughout the claim scope: relative quality could be changed by degrading other portions, merely drawing attention to content.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed content server and communication system employ technical computer and image-handling means.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): User-interest profiling was non-technical; a technical image-transmission or rendering benefit of the claimed relative-quality change was not established.
– Applicatioin field: The system personalises digital media content transmitted from a server to users.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC turned on whether the allegedly improved image quality supplied an actual technical contribution.
– Outcome: The remaining differences were non-technical or routine implementation; the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Sony Corporation
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – mixture of technical and non-technical features (no)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1413/07; 2012-10-19

TECHNOLOGY: #Financial_Transaction_and_Payment_Technologies #Cardless_Payment_Authentication
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Enhanced_Security
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Electronic_Payment_Acceptance_Terminals
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Novelty #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed cardless purchase method authenticates a customer by an alias and PIN entered at the same device, without requiring a physical credit card or mobile telephone.
– Technical effect at issue: The amended authentication arrangement maintains transaction security while improving the technical usability of the payment arrangement without a separate customer device.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claim uses financial servers, network communication and terminal-based transaction authentication.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The particular PIN-and-alias entry arrangement was not taught by the cited combinations and provided a non-obvious secure and convenient implementation.
– Applicatioin field: The invention relates to cardless transactions at electronic payment terminals.
– Decisive legal issue: The final amended claims were assessed for novelty and inventive step under Articles 54 and 56 EPC 1973.
– Outcome: The decision was set aside and the case remitted with an order to grant a patent on the specified amended documents.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: First USA Bank, N.A.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC 1973 Art. 54, 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Novelty, inventive step (yes) – after amendment
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1784/06; 2012-9-21; Classification method/COMPTEL

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Data_Record_Classification_and_Linking
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Telecommunications
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Referral_to_Enlarged_Board_of_Appeal
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The computer-executed algorithm classifies and links data records, including telecommunications network event records for rating and billing.
– Technical effect at issue: A faster or more robust classification algorithm did not establish a further technical effect in the absence of a claimed technical use or architecture.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Computer implementation establishes threshold technical character, but an abstract data-classification algorithm has no technical purpose merely because it is programmed.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Billing-oriented classification and its mathematical structure could not support inventive step, and conventional programming involved no inventive technical contribution.
– Applicatioin field: The described applications primarily concern telecom network-event mediation and billing.
– Decisive legal issue: The appeal addressed COMVIK, inventive step and a requested referral to the Enlarged Board, which the Board declined.
– Outcome: The claimed requests failed for lack of inventive step; the appeal was dismissed.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
See points 9 to 12 of the Reasons

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Comptel Corporation
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(1)(2)(3); EPC 1973 Art. 56, 112(1)(a)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Comvik approach – interrelationship of Article 52(1)(2)(3) EPC and Article 56 EPC 1973 (yes); Referral of questions to the Enlarged Board of Appeal (no); Inventive step (no)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/08, G 0003/08, T 0072/95, T 1173/97, T 0641/00, T 0258/03, T 0154/04, T 1227/05, T 0473/08
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0265/10; 2011-7-5

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Web_Technologies
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Reliable_Site_Event_Location_and_Time_Verification
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Building_and_Construction
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Novelty #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The building-management system connects physically secured site terminals with uniquely preloaded Internet addresses to a central event database.
– Technical effect at issue: Terminal identity plus physical fixation and date/time recording verifies where and when a person reported a building event, helping prevent remote false attendance reports.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The addressable site terminals, their fixed locations and network/database event recording are technical means.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Those specifically location-binding technical measures went beyond the routine automation of an administrative building-event log and were non-obvious.
– Applicatioin field: The technical system monitors site visits and events for building and facility management.
– Decisive legal issue: Novelty and inventive step of the amended claims were central; an earlier related appeal T 0645/06 had resolved part of the novelty dispute.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted with an order to grant on the prescribed documents.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Godwin, Adrian Michael
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC 1973 Art. 54(1)(2), 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Novelty, inventive step (yes) – after amendment
CITED DECISIONS: T 0645/06
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0494/07; 2011-5-13

TECHNOLOGY: #Financial_Transaction_and_Payment_Technologies #Currency_Validator_Programming
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Device_Configuration
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Not_Finally_Determined
APPLICATION FIELD: #Vending_and_Retail_Transactions
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Patent_Eligible_Subject_Matter #Clarity_of_Claims
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed method programs a physical currency tester by storing operating data within the tester, rather than merely defining executable program instructions.
– Technical effect at issue: Performing the method changes the stored configuration of a technical apparatus; the resulting programmed tester is a technical device.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A method using a currency tester as a technical means is an invention within Article 52(1) EPC, independently of further patentability conditions.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board did not finally decide novelty or inventive step; it remitted the case for substantive further examination.
– Applicatioin field: The invention relates to configuration and use of currency-validation equipment, of a kind employed in payment and vending systems.
– Decisive legal issue: The central issues were patent-eligible subject matter and clarity; reimbursement of the appeal fee was refused.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted for further prosecution, without an order to grant.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: MEI, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(1); EPC 1973 Art. 64(2), 111(2), 84; EPC R. 67
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Method involving technical means is an invention within the meaning of Art. 52(1) EPC; Reimbursement of appeal fee (no); Clarity (yes); Remittal fo further prosecution
CITED DECISIONS: T 0410/96, T 0258/03, J 0027/94
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1227/05; 2006-12-13; Schaltkreissimulation I / INFINEON TECHNOLOGIES

TECHNOLOGY: #Simulation_CAD_and_Engineering_Design #Computer_Simulations
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Simulation_of_Circuit_Behaviour_Under_Noise
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Semiconductor_Design
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Patent_Eligible_Subject_Matter #Clarity_of_Claims
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The computer-implemented model simulates an electronic circuit exposed to 1/f noise, using mathematically generated noise sequences.
– Technical effect at issue: Functionally limited simulation predicts the physical behaviour of a specified circuit under noise, supporting virtual engineering tests before fabrication.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The simulation has a sufficiently specific technical purpose; a generic claim to the simulation of an unspecified “technical system” would not provide the required clarity.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Mathematical steps functionally directed to realistic circuit simulation contribute to technical character even without a fabrication step. The Board did not make a final grant order.
– Applicatioin field: The invention lies in the design and assessment of electronic and semiconductor circuits.
– Decisive legal issue: Technical character under Article 52 and clarity of the specified technical purpose under Article 84 were central to overturning the refusal.
– Outcome: The appealed decision was set aside and the case remitted for continuation of examination, not immediately ordered to grant.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
1. Die Simulation eines Schaltkreises, der 1/f-Rauscheinflüssen unterworfen ist, stellt einen hinreichend bestimmten technischen Zweck eines computergestützten Verfahrens dar, das auf diesen Zweck funktional beschränkt ist (Punkt 3.1 der Entscheidungsgründe).
2. Die konkreten technischen Anwendungen computergestützter Simulationsverfahren sind selbst als moderne technische Verfahren anzusehen, die einen wesentlichen Bestandteil des Fabrikationsprozesses darstellen und der materiellen Herstellung in der Regel als Zwischenschritt vorausgehen. In diesem Sinne kann derartigen Simulationsverfahren eine technische Wirkung nicht abgesprochen werden, nur weil sie noch nicht das materielle Endprodukt umfassen (Punkt 3.4.2 der Entscheidungsgründe).

AI-TRANSLATED-HEADNOTE:
1. The simulation of a circuit subjected to 1/f noise influences constitutes a sufficiently specific technical purpose of a computer-implemented method functionally limited to that purpose (point 3.1 of the Reasons).
2. The specific technical applications of computer-implemented simulation methods must themselves be regarded as modern technical methods, forming a substantial part of the fabrication process and generally preceding physical manufacture as an intermediate step. Accordingly, such simulation methods cannot be denied a technical effect merely because they do not yet include the physical end product (point 3.4.2 of the Reasons).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Infineon Technologies AG
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPÜ Art. 52(1)(2)(3), 56, 84
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Computergestütztes Verfahren mit mathematischen Schritten zur Simulation des Verhaltens eines Schaltkreises unter dem Einfluss von 1/f-Rauschen – Technizität (bejaht); Unbestimmter technischer Zweck – ausreichend für Deutlichkeit (verneint)
AI-TRANSLATED-KEYWORDS: Computer-implemented method involving mathematical steps for simulating the behaviour of a circuit under the influence of 1/f noise – technical character (yes); Undefined technical purpose – sufficient for clarity (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0453/91, T 0931/95, T 1173/97, T 0049/99, T 0641/00, T 0914/02, T 0258/03, T 0424/03, T 0930/05, BGH X ZB 11/98-Logikverifikation
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0928/03; 2006-6-2; Video game/KONAMI

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Graphical_User_Interfaces
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Gaming_and_Entertainment
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The game GUI uses graphical guide marks to signal controllable characters, potential pass recipients and directions toward off-screen points of interest.
– Technical effect at issue: Maintaining visibility of an indicator and preserving an enlarged view while pointing to an off-screen target support objective display functionality and user interaction.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The device and display method employ technical display means; not every aspect of a graphical game interface is solely aesthetic or mental.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board separated non-technical game-rule/aesthetic elements from display functionality. The off-screen edge indicator solved a technical display conflict in a non-obvious way.
– Applicatioin field: The application is an interactive video-game display system.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step, with the necessary separation of technical display features from game rules under COMVIK, was decisive.
– Outcome: The rejection was set aside and the case remitted with an order to grant on the allowed claims, description and drawings to be adapted.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
I. Making a possibly concealed indicator clearly visible on a display screen to the user of an interactive video game does not exclusively address a human mental process but contributes an objective technical function to the display. The functional quality is not cancelled by the fact that the visualised information will also enter into a decision of the user interacting with the video game displayed on the screen (point 4.1.1 of the reasons).
II. Applying the approach of T 641/00-Two identities/COMVIK (i.e. treating non-technical aspects as constraints in the formulation of the technical problem) in a fair manner must bear in mind its purpose: on the one hand, the approach is to make sure that non-technical aspects do not support a finding of inventiveness; on the other hand, actual contributions to the technical character by any feature of an invention must be taken into account when assessing inventive step (point 5.3.3 of the reasons).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: KONAMI CO., LTD.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(1)(2)(3), 54, 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Visualisation of a possibly concealed graphic indicator in an interactive video game – exclusively addressing a mental process (no); Shape of graphic indicator – merely aesthetic creation (yes); Specific implementation of game rule requirements – technical contribution (yes); Inventive step (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0333/95, T 0244/00, T 0641/00, T 0643/00, T 0258/03, T 0049/04, T 0125/04
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0641/00; 2002-9-26; Two identities/COMVIK

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Mobile_Communications
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Telecommunications
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The patent concerns a GSM subscriber identity module with selectively active identities allowing different users or accounting treatment of business and private calls.
– Technical effect at issue: The commercial cost-allocation requirement did not provide a technical effect sufficient to support inventiveness beyond the already known GSM/SIM implementation.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed GSM method as a whole has technical character by employing mobile-network apparatus and operations.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Only features contributing to technical character may support inventive step. The business requirement may form part of the technical problem as a given constraint, but the technical implementation was obvious.
– Applicatioin field: The invention is in GSM mobile telecommunications and subscriber administration.
– Decisive legal issue: The decision established the COMVIK approach to inventive step for claims combining technical and non-technical features.
– Outcome: The proprietor’s appeal was dismissed; revocation for lack of inventive step was not overturned.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
1. An invention consisting of a mixture of technical and non-technical features and having technical character as a whole is to be assessed with respect to the requirement of inventive step by taking account of all those features which contribute to said technical character whereas features making no such contribution cannot support the presence of inventive step.
2. Although the technical problem to be solved should not be formulated to contain pointers to the solution or partially anticipate it, merely because some feature appears in the claim does not automatically exclude it from appearing in the formulation of the problem. In particular where the claim refers to an aim to be achieved in a non-technical field, this aim may legitimately appear in the formulation of the problem as part of the framework of the technical problem that is to be solved, in particular as a constraint that has to be met.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: COMVIK GSM AB
OPPOSING-PARTY: DeTeMobil Deutsche Telekom MobilNet GmbH; GIESECKE & DEVRIENT GmbH
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(1)-(3), 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step (no); Problem-and-solution approach: treatment of non-technical aspects
CITED DECISIONS: T 0026/81, T 0026/86, T 0072/95, T 0470/95, T 0931/95, T 0027/97, T 0157/97, T 0158/97, T 0176/97, T 1053/98
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1072/11; 2019-6-18
Matching unit comprising two computer entities directly connected to a shared memory storing pre-calculated values/NASDAQ

TECHNOLOGY: #Software_and_Computer_Architecture #Parallel_Processing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Reduced_Latency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Financial_Markets_and_Trading
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Additional_Prior_Art_Search #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The application concerns an automated exchange with two cooperating processor entities and a directly connected shared memory for pre-computed matching data. Its distinctive architecture is a computer-implementation issue, not an innovation in trading rules.
– Technical effect at issue: Pre-calculating matching values in the second entity and making them available to the first through shared memory addresses real-time constraints and latency in processing orders (Reasons 2.5–2.8).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Processors and memory are technical means; the Board expressly found the mixed-claim subject-matter to have technical character (Reasons 2.1).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The financial matching concept is a non-technical requirement. However, the specifically claimed processor placement, pre-computation and shared-memory access are technical distinguishing features not disclosed by D1; D1 alone did not render them obvious. A final inventive-step assessment required further prior-art searching.
– Applicatioin field: The system handles combinations of securities orders in electronic financial markets.
– Decisive legal issue: Because the claimed hardware arrangement was not merely notorious general knowledge, the absence of a proper search for the amended subject-matter prevented a conclusive Article 56 EPC assessment (Reasons 3.1–3.3).
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside, and the application remitted for an additional search and further prosecution; the Board did not order grant.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Nasdaq Technology AB
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 111(1), 153(6); EPC R. 63; PCT Art. 17(2)(a), Rule 13ter.1(c), Rule 39
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Declaration of non-establishment of the International Search Report; No Supplementary European Search Report; Examination procedure – amendments relating to unsearched subject-matter; Inventive step – mixture of technical and non-technical features – common general knowledge – distinguishing features not notorious; Appeal decision – remittal to the department of first instance (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: T 2299/10, T 1411/08, T 1434/06, T 0258/03, T 0641/00, T 0042/90, T 0019/87
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1201/10; 2019-5-20
Personalised interactive automated marketing/JEAN-LUC ROCHET

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Mobile_Communications
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Digital_Commerce_and_Content_Distribution
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Added_Subject_Matter #Inventive_Step #Correction_of_Obvious_Errors_Under_Rule_139_EPC
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Added_Matter_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A mobile telephone sends an alphanumeric product code via an SMS gateway to a marketing portal, which associates the code with product information accessible through a personalised webpage.
– Technical effect at issue: The alleged advantages of a unique product code, compact database representation and convenient access to promotional information did not establish a technical effect of the distinguishing business concept; corresponding implementation was known from D2.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed mobile-phone, gateway, database and web-server environment contains technical means. This does not make the commercial product-identification concept technical for inventive-step purposes.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board characterised product codes for marketing as a business idea and held that claim 1 lacked inventive step over D2 and common general knowledge (Reasons 5.3–5.18).
– Applicatioin field: The claimed service distributes product and advertising information to consumers through a mobile-assisted electronic marketing portal.
– Decisive legal issue: The added step of sending an SMS to the end-user’s mobile phone was not directly and unambiguously disclosed. The proposed registration-free access interpretation was unsupported; a Rule 139 EPC correction of “number and name” to “number” also failed the obvious-error test.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed: the claims contained added subject-matter, the main request lacked inventive step, and the requested correction was refused.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Rochet, Jean-Luc; S.A. POLYGONE INTERNATIONAL
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 123(2); EPC R. 139
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – use of code to identify a product (no – not technical); Correction of error – immediately evident that nothing else could have been intended (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, G 0011/91
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1408/09; 2017-9-7
Group identifier / SQUARE ENIX

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Distributed_Computing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Reliable_Serverless_Group_Identification
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #Telecommunications
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: Group-email membership is administered by individual terminals without a group-management server. A group identifier is generated by combining information identifying the group creator with the time of group creation.
– Technical effect at issue: The combination supplies a system-wide unique group identifier without server participation, addressing a technical identification problem in a distributed communication system.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed communication terminals and serverless group-identification scheme form a technical network context.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Although unique group identification solves a technical problem, prior-art UUIDs already combined a user or node identifier with a timestamp. The skilled person would have considered D7; the claim was obvious.
– Applicatioin field: Serverless management of groups for electronic mail or mobile communications.
– Decisive legal issue: For the problem-solution approach, the closest prior art need not itself mention the objective technical problem. The Board required evidential support rather than hindsight for the proposed combination and relied on the documented UUID solution (Reasons 2.3, 2.6–2.10).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed for lack of inventive step under Article 56 EPC.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
According to the problem solution approach, the objective technical problem is formulated based on the technical effect of the difference between the claimed subject-matter and the starting point in the prior art. It is not a requirement for obviousness that the starting point address this problem. If it does, that could make the solution all the more obvious. If, on the other hand, there is a pointer away from the invention, that might be an indication in favour of inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Kabushiki Kaisha Square Enix (also trading as Square Enix Co., Ltd.)
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – uniquely identifying a group with a uid and time (no – obvious from UUID) – need for pointer to problem in closest prior art (no)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1630/11; 2017-1-13
Modelling a multiprocessor system/THE MATHWORKS

TECHNOLOGY: #Simulation_CAD_and_Engineering_Design #Computer_Simulations
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Effect_of_Simulation_Undetermined
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed graphical environment defines functional and deployment models for multiprocessor systems, including processor blocks and inter-process communication channels, and executes the resulting model.
– Technical effect at issue: The technical purpose of the simulation was insufficiently specified. Faster model development is not a technical effect, and faster execution was not supported by the application (Reasons 7.2, 9.2–9.3).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Creating and executing a graphical computer program on an electronic device was accepted as an invention under Article 52(2)–(3) EPC (Reasons 5).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Representations of processors or communication channels do not inherit the technical nature of the represented hardware. Language blocks and modelling conveniences were non-technical; integrating modelling and simulation tools was an obvious technical measure.
– Applicatioin field: General-purpose graphical modelling, programming and simulation of multiprocessor architectures.
– Decisive legal issue: The claimed simulation was not functionally limited to a sufficiently specific technical purpose. The Board distinguished T 1227/05 and rejected inventive step under Article 56 EPC 1973.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because the claimed differences supplied no non-obvious technical contribution.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: The MathWorks, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC 1973 Art. 56, 84; EPC Art. 123(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Technical purpose of simulation adequately defined – (no); Inventive step – (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0424/03, T 0049/99, T 1227/05, T 1171/06, T 0354/07, T 0042/09, T 0531/09, T 1539/09, T 1265/09, T 2270/10
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0483/11; 2015-10-13
Document summary/ARIZAN CORPORATION

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Document_Summarisation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Telecommunications
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A server produces summaries of electronic documents for navigation on mobile devices. The distinguishing algorithm infers section headings from paragraph size when no formatting cues are present.
– Technical effect at issue: Avoiding transmission of entire documents was already part of the known mobile-document system. Extending summarisation to unformatted documents by selecting short paragraphs did not itself produce an additional technical effect.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The server/network implementation gives the claimed method technical character under Article 52 EPC, as the Board explicitly acknowledged (Reasons 2.6).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Selecting likely headings by paragraph length concerns the informational content of the document and resembles a mental reading task. It does not automatically inherit technical character from the mobile network; routine programming sufficed to implement it.
– Applicatioin field: Remote access to and navigation of document contents on mobile communication devices.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive distinction was whether the new summarisation algorithm contributed technically under COMVIK. The Board held that it did not, including under the auxiliary requests.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed for lack of inventive step across the main and auxiliary requests.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
A feature does not automatically inherit the technical character of the context in which it occurs. The feature must, itself, make a contribution to the technical context or the technical aspects of the invention (technical inheritance fallacy – see points 2.7 and 2.8 of the reasons).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Arizan Corporation
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC 1973 Art. 56
CITED DECISIONS: T 0258/03, T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1358/09; 2014-11-21
Classification/BDGB ENTERPRISE SOFTWARE

TECHNOLOGY: #Artificial_Intelligence_and_Machine_Learning #Classification
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A mathematical text-classification method represents documents as vectors and uses separating hyperplanes, maximum margins and confidence values to assign classes.
– Technical effect at issue: Faster, more objective or reproducible classification was alleged, but the algorithm was directed to semantic classification of documents rather than to technical computer operation. No qualifying technical effect was established.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claim recites computerised steps and digitally represented documents, thereby including technical means; the mere computer implementation does not make the classification mathematics a technical contribution.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): A mathematical algorithm used for non-technical document classification can contribute only when serving a technical purpose or reflecting technical considerations of the computer’s internal functioning. Neither was shown, and implementation on a general-purpose computer was obvious (Reasons 5.2–5.8).
– Applicatioin field: General-purpose classification and retrieval of documents according to their textual content.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was decisive. Although the Board expressed doubts about sufficiency across non-linearly separable classes, it deliberately left Article 83 EPC undecided (Reasons 4.4).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because the claimed computer implementation lacked inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: BDGB Enterprise Software Sàrl
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0003/08, T 0258/03, T 0154/04, T 1784/06, T 1954/08, T 1316/09
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0963/09; 2014-6-5
Selective auditing/ORACLE

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Databases
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Selective_Row_Level_Database_Auditing
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A relational database server modifies an incoming query with monitoring logic to record audited accesses only to rows that satisfy both the query conditions and an independent auditing condition.
– Technical effect at issue: The implementation enables selective row-level audit logging even when an audited field is absent from the query result. The Board did not decide whether the motivation for selective auditing was itself technical (Reasons 7.6–7.9).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Query execution, modification and row-level audit-record generation are concrete operations of a technical database server.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The particular integration of monitoring logic into the processed query was not disclosed by D1–D3 and, on the evidence available, was not merely an obvious implementation option. Inventive step was recognised for the independent claims.
– Applicatioin field: General-purpose relational database management and database access auditing.
– Decisive legal issue: The invention met Articles 83, 84, 123(2) and 56 EPC. In particular, the row-level query-rewriting implementation was inventive over the cited database auditing references.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted with a binding order to grant a patent on the specified claims, description and drawings.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
See points 2 to 2.6 of the reasons

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Oracle International Corporation
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 111(1)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Remittal to the department of first instance without substantive examination – (no); Inventive step – main request (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0010/93
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0042/09; 2014-3-10
Logical hierarchical data model/BOEING

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Data_Structures
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Lower_Memory_Usage
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Alleged_Technical_Contribution_Not_Established_Across_Claim_Scope
APPLICATION FIELD: #Manufacturing_and_Production_Planning
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A hierarchical abstract product data model represents common components and alternatives within product families; CAD/CAM and computer storage were cited as its context.
– Technical effect at issue: Reduced memory usage was alleged for lightweight references instead of duplicate component records. The abstract claim was not limited to a particular physical in-memory data structure, and any memory saving did not make the information model technical (Reasons 2.5.8).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The reference to memory and unspecified computer-assisted design/manufacturing provides technical context but does not establish a technical purpose for the claimed modelling features.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The abstract model could equally be drawn on paper. No concrete technical CAD/CAM problem was solved by its structure; an implementation using references rather than copying components would in any event have been obvious.
– Applicatioin field: Product-family configuration and assembly data for design and manufacturing planning.
– Decisive legal issue: The main request and first auxiliary request lacked inventive step; the second auxiliary request was not admitted under Rule 137(3) EPC and Article 12(4) RPBA in view of unresolved added-matter and inventive-step objections.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed. Neither admitted request was allowable, and auxiliary request II was excluded from the proceedings.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: The Boeing Company
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; EPC R. 137(3); RPBA Art. 12(4)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main request (no) – auxiliary request I (no); Admissibility – auxiliary request II (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0049/99, T 0258/03, T 1227/05, T 1841/08, T 1954/08
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0309/10; 2013-6-19
Archival and retrieval/MULTEX

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Indexing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Financial_Markets_and_Trading
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Added_Subject_Matter
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Added_Matter_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A document repository normalises securities-related symbols, maps them through master symbols to parent identifiers, and uses those identifiers for archiving and retrieval.
– Technical effect at issue: Improved accuracy and ease of finding documents were attributed to the choice of catalogue/index entries, a non-technical information-management scheme analogous to a librarian’s index rather than a demonstrated technical retrieval improvement.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed repository has a storage device, network interface and processor, so technical means are present even though the underlying indexing scheme is non-technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Normalising symbols, choosing identifiers and using defaults specify an administrative indexing method. Implementing it with conventional storage, processing and networking features was obvious (Reasons 9–19, 27–30).
– Applicatioin field: Archiving and retrieving documents about companies and securities across inconsistent financial-market naming conventions.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step defeated the main, first and third requests. The second auxiliary request additionally introduced an unsupported association between a symbol segment and a parent identifier contrary to Article 123(2) EPC.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because the substantive requests lacked inventive step and the second auxiliary request added subject-matter.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Multex.Com, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC 1973 Art. 56; EPC Art. 123(2)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 0654/10
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1316/09; 2012-12-18

TECHNOLOGY: #Artificial_Intelligence_and_Machine_Learning #Classification
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The method combines query-based classification and example-based similarity matching of incoming electronic messages to identify stored messages and response-related business objects.
– Technical effect at issue: Better categorisation and faster or more relevant response suggestions were alleged, but no credible effect was established across the claims and no reason was given why improvements in informational content were technical (Reasons 2–4).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The application is directed to electronic-message processing and a computer-based system; the Board nevertheless did not positively decide a separate Article 52 EPC issue and disposed of the claims under inventive step.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Text classification per se and combining rule-based and example-based classifiers are not technical purposes. The claimed advantages concern content assessment and business responses, not the functioning of a computer.
– Applicatioin field: Automated handling of correspondence and suggesting responses to incoming business communications.
– Decisive legal issue: All claim requests failed inventive step under Article 56 EPC 1973 because their alleged categorisation effects could not establish a technical solution to a technical problem.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed; none of the main or auxiliary requests justified changing the refusal.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: SAP AG
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC 1973 Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: “Inventive step – no (all requests)”
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 273/26; 2026-9-7; Medical intervention control/CEREBRIA

TECHNOLOGY: #Statistical_Modelling_and_Data_Analytics #Medical_Measurement_Data_Analysis
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Healthcare_and_Medical
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed system analyses patient-specific cardiovascular measurements and waveforms (including FFR, iFR and CFR) to inform possible medical interventions.
– Technical effect at issue: The additional measurements and waveform processing are not linked by the claim to any defined operation of the analyser, so the asserted improvement in medical intervention analysis is not established.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The system includes technical sensing, database and processing equipment; nevertheless, a physician-facing recommendation is not inherently a technical intervention.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The differences do not credibly cause the asserted technical improvement, and neither the main request nor the amended analyser and waveform claims establish an inventive technical contribution.
– Applicatioin field: The claimed use concerns clinical measurements, patient risk evaluation and the planning of medical intervention.
– Decisive legal issue: Under Article 56 EPC, the decisive issue is whether the distinguishing measurement and data-processing features solve an objective technical problem.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because the main and both auxiliary requests lacked inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Cerebria Limited
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1910/20
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1237/24; 2026-7-30; Additive manufacturing quality dataset/SIEMENS ENERGY GLOBAL

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Data_Storage
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Additive_Manufacturing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The method constructs and displays a quality-data set for additively manufactured layers, including the deletion of data indicating inadequate structural quality.
– Technical effect at issue: Deleting adverse-quality data merely removes information; neither a credible faster defect analysis nor a technical improvement in the manufacturing process follows from the claim.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed acquisition and processing of manufacturing data is implemented technically, while the selected deletion rule does not by itself confer an additional technical effect.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The distinction over the prior art was an arbitrary reduction of information content; the alleged technical benefits of the data presentation were not achieved by the claimed steps.
– Applicatioin field: The subject matter relates to additive-manufacturing layer inspection and quality-control information.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC was decisive; later auxiliary requests were also refused admission under Article 13(2) RPBA.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed; the main request failed for lack of inventive step and the late-filed auxiliary requests were not admitted.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Siemens Energy Global GmbH & Co. KG
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – deleting data on insufficient structural quality of an additively manufactured layer (no – arbitrary reduction of information content with no technical effect); Admittance under Article 13(2) RPBA (no – development of the appellant’s business is not an exceptional circumstance)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0643/00, T 0928/03
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1261/24; 2026-5-21

TECHNOLOGY: #Automation_Control_and_Embedded_Systems #Energy_Management
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Physical_Process_Control
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Manufacturing_and_Production_Planning
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Novelty #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Maintain_Patent

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claims concern the determination of machine input parameters for energy-efficient control of an industrial stretch blow moulder.
– Technical effect at issue: The alleged optimisation concerns operating parameters, energy consumption and operating costs of a real production machine; for the granted claims, fixed energy prices undermined the asserted improvement over D1.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The controlled industrial moulding machine and its sensor-based operating parameters are technical subject matter.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The granted main request was obvious despite novelty; the more limited second auxiliary request was found to involve an inventive step.
– Applicatioin field: The invention concerns industrial plastics processing and automated operation of blow-moulding equipment.
– Decisive legal issue: The board distinguished novelty from inventive step, and examined whether the alleged operating improvement was achieved across the scope of the granted claim.
– Outcome: The impugned decision was set aside and the case remitted with an order to maintain the patent in amended form on auxiliary request 2.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: AGR INTERNATIONAL, INC.
OPPOSING-PARTY: Krones AG
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 100(a), 54, 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Grounds for opposition – lack of patentability (yes); Novelty – main request (yes); Inventive step – main request (no) – auxiliary request 2 (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/24
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1745/23; 2026-3-6; Electrically heated smoking system/PHILIP MORRIS

TECHNOLOGY: #Automation_Control_and_Embedded_Systems #Embedded_Software
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Consumer_Electronics_and_Appliances
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Patent_Revoked

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention is an electrically heated smoking device which is enabled through communication with an Internet-connected host after registration.
– Technical effect at issue: Requiring registration before use was an administrative condition, not a demonstrated technical safety or security improvement.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The physical device and its communication interface establish technical character, but not all limitations contribute to inventive step.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Implementing the registration requirement through the known communication link was obvious; describing the condition as a security feature did not make it technical.
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns software-enabled consumer electronic smoking equipment.
– Decisive legal issue: The issue was inventive step under Article 56 EPC, using the COMVIK approach to separate an administrative enabling rule from its technical implementation.
– Outcome: The appealed decision was set aside and the patent revoked; the main request and auxiliary requests lacked inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Philip Morris Products S.A.
OPPOSING-PARTY: JT International S.A.; British-American Tobacco (Investments) Limited
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 54(2), 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – enabling an electrically heated smoking system only after registration (no – obvious implementation of non-technical requirement)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 2358/19
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1189/23; 2025-10-24; Storage cabinet/SATO

TECHNOLOGY: #Automation_Control_and_Embedded_Systems #Sensor_Systems
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Smart_Storage_and_Inventory_Control
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The storage cabinet uses RFID readers and recorded item information to check whether specified items have been taken out.
– Technical effect at issue: A judgment that items satisfying an inventory condition have been retrieved is a non-technical inventory rule; the claim does not prevent improper retrieval or achieve the alleged security benefit.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The RFID readers, memory and cabinet are technical, but the cognitive meaning of the item condition and the associated judgment is not.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Automating the stipulated inventory check using known RFID cabinet functionality did not establish a non-obvious technical contribution.
– Applicatioin field: The system addresses automated storage-cabinet inventory and item retrieval.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step turned on whether the content-based retrieval condition contributed a technical effect under COMVIK.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed for lack of inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: SATO Corporation
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step (no) – judging whether an item that meets an item condition has been retrieved (no technical effect)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1908/23; 2025-9-17; Personalisiertes Phishing-Dokument/IT-SEAL

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Secure_Computing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Cybersecurity
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The method generates personalised simulated phishing documents using person attributes, relevance scores and database-held matching attributes.
– Technical effect at issue: The alleged higher quality of phishing documents depends on their cognitive content; the technical advantages of the chosen database and selection strategy were not substantiated.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The computer-based document-generation method uses technical means, whereas the design of a personalised phishing-training strategy remains non-technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The board treated the phishing-training strategy as a non-technical requirement and found its computer and database implementation obvious under COMVIK.
– Applicatioin field: The context is simulated phishing and cybersecurity awareness training.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive legal issue was inventive step under Article 56 EPC and the treatment of a training strategy as a constraint in the objective technical problem.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed; the invention did not satisfy the inventive-step requirement.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: IT-Seal GmbH
OPPOSING-PARTY: Dr. Schön, Neymeyr & Partner Patentanwälte mbB
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPÜ Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Erfinderische Tätigkeit – (nein): naheliegende technische Implementierung einer Phishing-Schulungsstrategie
AI-TRANSLATED-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no): obvious technical implementation of a phishing-training strategy
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 799/24; 2025-8-21; Optimisation of vehicle body joint position/JFE STEEL CORPORATION

TECHNOLOGY: #Simulation_CAD_and_Engineering_Design #Physical_Modelling
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Structural_Stiffness_Through_Weld_Placement
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Automotive_Body_Design_and_Welding
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A vehicle-body and chassis model is analysed under load conditions to choose additional weld locations for an automotive body.
– Technical effect at issue: The selected weld points are to be added to a real body to improve stiffness during driving; the board accepted this implicit further technical use and an adequately realistic model.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Although the analysis is computer-based, its specified connection to structural modification of the physical vehicle supports technical character.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The optimisation and selection of additional weld locations were held to produce a technical effect across the claimed scope and to involve an inventive step over D1.
– Applicatioin field: The invention concerns structural engineering and welding-point layout in automotive body design.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step required applying G 1/19 to physical simulations and identifying a sufficiently specified further technical use of the analysis results.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted with an order to grant on the main request, with an adapted description.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
In the board’s view, the formulation in claim 1 of the main request that additional welded point(s) is/are “to be added” to the automotive body to improve its stiffness during driving at least implicitly specifies a further technical use (reasons, point 4.4).
The board considers that it is implicit from claim 1 that the additional welded points of which the locations are determined will be added to the automotive body (reasons, points 37 and 43). The technical effect is therefore considered to be achieved by the distinguishing features over the whole scope claimed.
The appellant considered the objective technical problem as being how “to design an automotive body in which the stiffness of the automotive body during driving is improved” (reasons, point 25).
One distinguishing features of claim 1 of the main request having regard to the disclosure of document D1 specifies that the load applied has a different magnitude and direction at each joining portion (reasons, points 32.1 and 23).
In the board’s view, since the use of the analysis results is defined in the claim as being “for automotive body designing”, leaving it open which further steps, technical or not, are performed with the analysis results, a potential further selection of a particular automotive body might also be based on the visual characteristics or appearance of the automotive body. However, the board is of the opinion that the selection of the automotive body is, in addition, also restricted to the selected additional welded points to be added to the automotive body (reasons, point 34.1).
The board notes that the optimisation analysis on the welding candidates applies at least one of the load, of which magnitude and direction are different at each joining portion. An additional welded point or an additional welded location that satisfies the optimization analysis conditions, including maximising absorbed energy, is selected (reasons, point 36).
The analysis results used in the automotive body designing are, for example, “automotive body displacement amount”. The possible use by the user of the displayed analysis results might be a cognitive exercise such as selecting the automotive body corresponding to the lowest displacement amount (see Figures 19A to 19D and 20A to 20D of the application as filed and decision G 1/19, point 138), but the board considers that the step of selecting the additional welded points contributes to the technical character of the invention (reasons, point 44).
The board further notes that the additional welded points of which the locations are determined or selected are “to be added to the automotive body” (“to improve the stiffness of the automotive body during driving”). In the board’s view this wording at least implicitly specifies a further technical use (see decision G 1/19, points 124 and 137) (reasons, point 37).
The board considers that, even if the automotive body was a “prototype” and the additional welded points were added to this “prototype”, this “prototype” would still be a physical object having at least some of the features of an automotive body (reasons, point 45).
The board notes that the decision of the Enlarged Board of Appeal G 1/19, point 111 requires a simulation to be “accurate enough” or a simulation that reflects “reality” “accurately enough”. In the present case, the automotive model constituted by the automotive body frame model and the chassis model together with the welded points at the joining portion(s) is considered to reflect an automotive body (as “reality”) “accurately enough” (reasons, point 46).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: JFE Steel Corporation
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main request – (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 813/23; 2025-7-15

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Human_Computer_Interaction
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Transportation_and_Travel
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The collision-warning controller changes the intensity or repetition of a motorcycle rider alert depending on measured bank angle.
– Technical effect at issue: The asserted reduction of rider distraction was not accepted as an additional technical effect: the differences concerned the weighting of competing collision and loss-of-control risks.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The collision-warning system and motorcycle inclination measurement are technical, but the distinguishing warning-choice rule was treated as non-technical risk assessment.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Since the identified differences did not contribute technically, they could not support inventive step; the later auxiliary request was not admitted.
– Applicatioin field: The application is for rider warnings and collision avoidance in motorcycles.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step and the admission of an auxiliary request after summons (Article 13(2) RPBA) determined the case.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because the main request lacked inventive step and no exceptional circumstances justified admitting the auxiliary request.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Robert Bosch GmbH
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 12(4), 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Main request – amendment to case – complexity of amendment (no) – admitted (yes); Main request – inventive step – (no); Auxiliary request – amendment after summons – cogent reasons for exceptional circumstances (no) – taken into account (no)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 521/23; 2025-7-7; Access-control method for a hearing instrument/SONOVA

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Access_Control
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Healthcare_and_Medical
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Patent_Revoked

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The hearing-instrument system governs service access through hierarchies of security levels and authentication data.
– Technical effect at issue: The suggested simplification, resource savings and enhanced security were not credibly established across the scope; the level hierarchy represented an administrative access policy.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A hearing instrument implementing authentication has technical character, but the policy specifying which privileges are granted does not necessarily yield a technical effect.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The access-policy implementation and further authentication variants were obvious; the fifth auxiliary request was not admitted.
– Applicatioin field: The system manages access to services of a medical hearing device.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive assessment was Article 56 EPC under COMVIK, together with admission of a further auxiliary request under Article 12(4) RPBA.
– Outcome: The appealed decision was set aside and the patent revoked for lack of an allowable request.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Sonova AG
OPPOSING-PARTY: Oticon A/S
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 100(a); RPBA 2020 Art. 12(4)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main request, auxiliary requests 1 to 4 (no): obvious implementation of an administrative policy; Admittance of claim request filed on appeal – auxiliary request 5 (no): no reasons provided for late filing
CITED DECISIONS: T 0939/92, T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 55/23; 2025-6-27; Displaying payment information/INGENICO

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Secure_Computing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Data_Communication
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Electronic_Payment_Acceptance_Terminals
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The payment acceptance device uses one firmware-level proxy to verify signed payment data and route payment and other application data to separate screen zones.
– Technical effect at issue: The board did not accept a proven security improvement or simpler implementation over D5, but identified a distinct technical proxy-routing architecture.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A firmware-based signature-checking and display-routing arrangement is a technical configuration of the payment device.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Even as an alternative technical implementation, the common firmware proxy was not suggested by D5 or the other cited documents, and was held inventive.
– Applicatioin field: The invention concerns electronic payment terminals displaying payment information alongside other content.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC hinged on the technical distinctions over D5, the meaning of firmware, and whether the alternative architecture was obvious.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted with an order to grant a patent on the allowed claims.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Ingenico Belgium
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – routing payment information and other information to different zones of the screen via a single proxy implemented in firmware (yes)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1465/23; 2025-6-24; Isolated islands of cryptography/GN HEARING

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Cryptography
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Alleged_Technical_Contribution_Not_Established_Across_Claim_Scope
APPLICATION FIELD: #Healthcare_and_Medical
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Referral_to_Enlarged_Board_of_Appeal
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Patent_Revoked

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The hearing device exchanges session identifiers and keys to authenticate client devices and terminate unsuccessful sessions.
– Technical effect at issue: A hierarchy of cryptographic security and enhanced protection were not credibly obtained over the entire claimed scope; ordinary verification can be non-cryptographic.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The hearing instrument, session communications and authentication hardware are technical, but a technical effect from the distinguishing features must be credible.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Arbitrary or non-functional variations without a credibly achieved technical effect cannot support inventive step; the board rejected an artificial alternative-problem formulation.
– Applicatioin field: The dispute concerns cryptographic access to wireless hearing-device communications.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step and claim-wide proof of technical effect were central; remittal and referral questions were rejected without a referral to the Enlarged Board.
– Outcome: The decision was set aside and the patent revoked; the request for a referral to the Enlarged Board was refused.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
If there is no technical effect that is credibly derivable from the wording of a claim on the basis of its distinguishing features, it is usually unnecessary to – artificially – formulate an (unsolved) objective technical problem, such as finding an “alternative way to achieve a (non-existent) technical effect”.
In such cases, the distinguishing features simply constitute arbitrary or non-functional modifications of the available prior art which cannot involve an inventive step within the meaning of Article 56 EPC (see points 2.7 and 3.3.3 of the Reasons).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: GN Hearing A/S
OPPOSING-PARTY: Oticon A/S
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 100(a), 111(1), 112(1)(a); RPBA 2020 Art. 11
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Claim construction – description and drawings “consulted” and “referred to” for defining the skilled reader of a claim; Inventive step – main and auxiliary requests (no): no credible technical effect over the whole scope claimed; concept of “substantially over the whole scope claimed” not followed; distinguishing features relate to arbitrary and non-functional modifications; reference made to UPC_CFI_1/2023, Central Division Munich; Remittal – (no): no “special reasons”; Referral to the Enlarged Board of Appeal – (no): questions on the problem-solution approach and the general applicability of G 1/19 and G 2/21 can be answered on the basis of the EPC and the existing jurisprudence
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19, G 0002/21, G 0001/24, T 0022/82, T 0939/92, T 0072/95, T 0176/97, T 1188/00, T 1294/16, T 0814/20, T 1924/20, T 1344/21, T 1737/21, T 2004/21, T 0746/22, T 1628/22, T 0287/23, T 0449/23, T 1580/23, T 1999/23
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 409/24; 2025-4-9; Multi-user project handling/ZURICH INSURANCE COMPANY

TECHNOLOGY: #Software_and_Computer_Architecture #Workflow_Management_Systems
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Alleged_Technical_Contribution_Not_Established_Across_Claim_Scope
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The multi-user digital workbench coordinates document stores, access rights and updates between project-handling modules.
– Technical effect at issue: An asserted improvement in data consistency was not ensured over the full claim scope; the changed access policy was a non-technical requirement.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Distributed document storage and module communication are technical features, while user privileges and project-management rules are not necessarily technical contributions.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The technical implementation was obvious or did not guarantee the alleged consistency effect; auxiliary requests A1 to A5 were not admitted.
– Applicatioin field: The workbench is intended for collaborative administrative and project-management workflows.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step of the main request and procedural admission under Article 12(4) and (6) RPBA of the auxiliary requests were decisive.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because the only admitted request was not allowable and the auxiliary requests were excluded.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Zurich Insurance Company Ltd.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 12(6), 12(4)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – mixture of technical and non-technical features – main request (no); Amended claims filed with the statement of grounds of appeal – first to fifth auxiliary requests – not admitted
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19, T 0154/04, T 1561/07, T 1195/09, T 0398/10, T 2238/12, T 1073/15, T 1847/18
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2367/22; 2023-9-12; Travel process prediction/THE AQUA ENTERPRISE COMPANY

TECHNOLOGY: #Navigation_and_Positioning_Technologies #Travel_Time_Prediction
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Transportation_and_Travel
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The system statistically predicts passage and waiting times at travel checkpoints from historical movements, transport data and contextual information.
– Technical effect at issue: Travel-time prediction and explanatory advice were not shown to control or improve a technical system; a suggested downstream benefit depended on unclaimed human actions.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The computer executing the analysis is technical, but the statistical travel-planning predictions and cognitive advice do not themselves produce a technical effect.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The regression and testing requirements were treated as a non-technical specification implemented on a conventional computer, without inventive technical contribution.
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns airport passage predictions and transport-related journey planning.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under COMVIK was decisive, along with the treatment of multiple auxiliary and late-filed requests.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed for lack of an allowable request.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: The Aqua Enterprise Company
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 12(6), 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – predicting travel time (no – not technical)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1148/18, T 1670/07, T 1798/13
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 49/99; 2002-3-5; Information modelling/INTERNATIONAL COMPUTERS

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Data_Structures
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Patent_Eligible_Subject_Matter #Inventive_Step #Clarity_of_Claims
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Clarity_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The method builds an abstract object-oriented information model of a physical system and implements it using relational database tables.
– Technical effect at issue: The abstract modelling rules did not solve a defined technical problem; their database implementation was conventional, with further uncertainty in the claim wording.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Information modelling as an intellectual activity is non-technical as such, although the included computerised relational database implementation confers technical character on the claimed method as a whole.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Only the technical implementation could support inventive step, and the board considered its relational table structure obvious in view of the cited systems-analysis textbook.
– Applicatioin field: The broad claims encompass generic information and database modelling rather than being restricted to control of a specific physical process.
– Decisive legal issue: The decision considered Article 52 EPC, inventive step under Article 56 EPC, and clarity under Article 84 EPC.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because the requests failed on inventive-step and clarity grounds.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
Information modelling is an intellectual activity and should be treated like any other human activity in a non-technical field, which is, as such, not an invention for the purposes of Article 52(1) EPC. Only the purposive use of information modelling in the context of a solution to a technical problem may contribute to the technical character of an invention.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: International Computers Limited
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(1)(2), 56, 84 R. 64(b)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: “Admissibility of appeal (yes)”; “Information modelling – technical character (no)”; “Inventive step (no)”; “Claims – clarity (no)”
CITED DECISIONS: G 0002/88, T 1129/97
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1613/22; 2025-12-12; Secure payment/GRE-LAB

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Authentication
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Enhanced_Security
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #Mobile_Payments_and_Contactless_Transactions
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention concerns biometric authentication for cashless payments, with a centrally stored facial image shown to the merchant and an additional PIN check for higher-value transactions (Reasons 1 and 3).
– Technical effect at issue: Additional identity verification is a security-related aim. However, the combination of stored biometric information and the displayed facial image was obvious in view of D1 and D3; the EUR 30 threshold was non-technical (Reasons 7-10 and 19.1).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed payment terminal, server and biometric-authentication operations provide technical means. This is not an exclusion of the whole claim as such under Article 52 EPC.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The board treated the further facial-image verification as an obvious security measure in light of D3. Preventing unauthorised disclosure of personal images was treated as a non-technical requirement; implementing its display after biometric/PIN checks was obvious (Reasons 19.3-19.6).
– Applicatioin field: The claimed system is used for cashless payments at merchant terminals rather than merely general-purpose identity management.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was decisive: the principal claims were obvious from D1 combined with D3, and none of the auxiliary amendments changed that conclusion (Reasons 10-20).
– Outcome: All requests failed under Article 56 EPC and the appeal was dismissed (Reason 21 and Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Gre-Lab S.r.l. Unipersonale
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (all requests – no)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1851/22; 2025-12-12; Shipping documentation/AUCTANE

TECHNOLOGY: #Software_and_Computer_Architecture #Workflow_Management_Systems
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Logistics_and_Terminal_Operations
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The software processes shipping-documentation workflows using default configurations, postponed checks, exception mitigation, a documentation queue and spawned generation subprocesses (Reasons 1-6).
– Technical effect at issue: The alleged avoidance of failures and faster documentation handling did not establish a technical effect. The generated documentation was a dataset without claimed technical use; the checks concerned administrative conditions (Reasons 5, 7 and 13-14).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Use of a generic computer and execution of a software module confer technical character on the claim as a whole, although this alone does not establish inventiveness.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The algorithmic nature of the steps, or their likely conception by a programmer, did not make them technically contributory. The only technical implementation was conventional loading and execution of software (Reasons 9-16).
– Applicatioin field: The application automates shipping administration and document generation.
– Decisive legal issue: The board applied the COMVIK approach to the administrative workflow, finding only an obvious implementation on generic computer means (Reasons 7 and 10-16).
– Outcome: The third auxiliary request lacked inventive step and the broader main and other auxiliary requests likewise failed; the appeal was dismissed (Reasons 16-18 and Order).

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
The presence of algorithmic steps conceived by a computer programmer, rather than by a business person, is not sufficient to confer technicality on the claimed subject-matter since computer programs are not inventions and are excluded as such from patentability under Article 52(2)(c) and (3) EPC. These steps have a technical character only in so far as they involve technical considerations, for example, concerning the implementing machine or a controlled technical device or process, and may contribute to the assessment of inventive step only if they solve a technical problem by providing a technical effect. (See point 10 of the reasons)

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Auctane, LLC.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52; EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 12(4)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no – obvious implementation of a non-technical process on generic computer means)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1596/22; 2025-12-9; Energy optimisation with Capacity Market Program/JOHNSON CONTROLS

TECHNOLOGY: #Automation_Control_and_Embedded_Systems #Energy_Management
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Alleged_Technical_Contribution_Not_Established_Across_Claim_Scope
APPLICATION FIELD: #Energy_and_Environment
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The subject matter determines resource allocation for building equipment under a capacity-market programme, taking dispatch probability and contractual capacity-reduction commitments into account (Reasons 1.1-1.3).
– Technical effect at issue: Actual control of building energy use is technical, but the distinguishing objective function and market-specific constraints optimise financial returns and contractual compliance; no additional technical effect over D1 was established (Reasons 2.5-2.14).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The board expressly acknowledged technical character of the claimed invention as a whole because building equipment is controlled (Reason 2.9).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The specific optimisation was not shown to make a technical contribution: its broadly formulated objective included profit maximisation, and dispatch probability was not technically calculated or applied in the claim. Implementing these commercial constraints in D1 was obvious (Reasons 2.7, 2.11 and 2.13).
– Applicatioin field: The setting is building energy management and participation in demand-response/capacity-market programmes.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive merits issue was inventive step under COMVIK. Auxiliary requests 5 to 9 and 7A were also not admitted under the RPBA; remittal was refused (Reasons 3-6).
– Outcome: The admitted requests lacked inventive step; later auxiliary requests were not admitted, and the appeal was dismissed (Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Johnson Controls Tyco IP Holdings LLP
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; EPC Art. 111(1); RPBA 2020 Art. 11; RPBA 2020 Art. 12(4); RPBA 2020 Art. 12(6); RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – optimising resource allocation in a facility participating in a Capacity Market Program (no – not technical); Late-filed requests – admitted (no); Remittal to the department of first instance (no)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0010/93, T 0641/00, T 0154/04, T 0677/09, T 2626/18
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2030/22; 2025-11-27

TECHNOLOGY: #Automation_Control_and_Embedded_Systems #Process_Control
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Physical_Process_Control #Enhanced_Security
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Gaming_and_Entertainment
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claim concerns control of physical gaming machines from remote player terminals, using separate control and video servers and automatic blocking of remote activation when a camera no longer captures the machine display (Reasons 1 and 2.3).
– Technical effect at issue: The board recognised more efficient transmission through separate server functions and improved security and quicker local/remote switching through camera-based recognition and command blocking (Reasons 2.4.1-2.4.2 and 2.5.10).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed system processes real camera signals and controls physical gaming machines; its technical character is clear.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Feature X provided a non-obvious technical solution: using detection of the physical display in camera images to prevent remote activation when local use is indicated. D1 suggested no such approach; normal alternatives involved buttons or detectors (Reasons 2.5.1-2.5.10).
– Applicatioin field: The invention concerns operation of physical gaming machines with concurrent remote access.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step over D1 was central; the board also upheld sufficiency, clarity and the basis for the amendments (Reasons 2.7 and 3).
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside, and the case remitted with an order to grant a patent in the specified version (Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Marcoype, S.L.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(1); EPC Art. 56; EPC Art. 83; EPC Art. 84; EPC Art. 111(1); EPC Art. 123(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (yes) – after amendment – non-obvious solution; Amendments – allowable (yes)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2078/22; 2025-11-19; Blockchain storing supply-chain data/STOLLMAN AND MATEEV

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Blockchain
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Packaging_and_Supply_Chain_Traceability
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests #Added_Subject_Matter
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention logs custody transfers of goods, quantities and related reports on a cryptographically signed blockchain (Reasons 2.1-2.4).
– Technical effect at issue: The security of known blockchain and signature mechanisms was acknowledged, but the claimed distinguishing business content and reports did not improve blockchain security or otherwise provide a new technical effect (Reasons 3.4-3.8).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Blockchain infrastructure, applications, signatures and servers are technical means; the recorded supply-chain business facts are not inherently technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Differences over the known cryptocurrency blockchain were non-technical business rules or obvious implementations. Recording damage with a sensor was also an obvious way to implement the given business requirement (Reasons 3.5-4).
– Applicatioin field: The context is product custody, supply-chain traceability and related administrative reporting.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step defeated auxiliary requests. The late main request was not admitted under Article 13(2) RPBA because it introduced new Article 123(2) EPC objections; clarity of some auxiliary amendments was also discussed (Reasons 3-5).
– Outcome: The auxiliary requests lacked inventive step, the late main request was not admitted and the appeal was dismissed (Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Stollman, Jeff; Mateev, Martin
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; EPC Art. 84; EPC Art. 123(2); RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – blockchain logging of supply-chain custody transfers (no – not technical)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2353/22; 2024-10-10; Lineage metadata/AB INITIO

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Data_Structures
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Processing_Efficiency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claims define a RAM-resident, pointer-linked data structure representing data-lineage nodes and edges, traversed in accordance with a query-specific walk plan (Reasons 3.1-3.4).
– Technical effect at issue: The claimed data structures and in-memory lineage generation can improve data processing efficiency. The board distinguished technical memory access from the non-technical informational content of lineage diagrams (Reasons 5.3, 5.4.3 and 5.8).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed data-processing apparatus and RAM storage have technical character; the graph meaning and its presentation do not by themselves have a technical effect (Reasons 5.3-5.4).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): A pointer used purposively to retrieve data in memory is technically contributory even if pointers are commonplace. The combination with a walk plan governing traversal and collection was not shown to be obvious from the cited art (Reasons 5.4.3 and 5.10-5.11).
– Applicatioin field: The technology concerns general-purpose data lineage, memory structures and retrieval from data repositories.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under the COMVIK approach was decisive, notably the treatment of memory pointers, storage mechanisms and query traversal as technical implementation features.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and remittal ordered with instructions to grant a patent on the accepted claims, subject to description adaptation (Reason 6 and Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: AB Initio Technology LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – mixture of technical and non-technical features – after amendment – (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19, T 0115/85, T 0641/00, T 0619/02, T 1351/04, T 0756/06, T 1670/07, T 0697/17, T 0731/17, T 2626/18, T 3176/19, T 1272/20
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1741/22; 2024-7-26; New medical data/ROCHE

TECHNOLOGY: #Statistical_Modelling_and_Data_Analytics #Medical_Measurement_Data_Analysis
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Healthcare_and_Medical
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Clarity_of_Claims #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Clarity_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The software derives minimum/maximum glucose values and graphical profiles from glucose monitoring measurements already acquired from a patient (Reasons 1 and 2.3). The new technology subtag Medical_Measurement_Data_Analysis is proposed for this type of post-acquisition medical-data analysis.
– Technical effect at issue: The board rejected the asserted technical effect of deriving and displaying additional medical information: further mathematical or cognitive processing of previously measured physiological data lacks the physical interaction inherent in a technical measurement (Reasons 2.3.1-2.3.7).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The technical character of a computer-based measurement-processing system as a whole is distinct from any technical contribution by the subsequently calculated minimum/maximum values.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The distinguishing calculation and display of additional glucose statistics did not provide a technical contribution. The board expressly departed from T 2681/16 and criticised the example in EPO Guidelines G-II, 3.3 on automated medical diagnosis (Reasons 2.3.5-2.3.7).
– Applicatioin field: The use context is physiological glucose monitoring for medical assessment.
– Decisive legal issue: Higher-ranked claims lacked clarity, including the relationship between measurement periods and sample times; later requests also lacked inventive step because the additional derived data were not technically contributory (Reasons 1-5).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed: the main and first nine auxiliary requests failed for lack of clarity and later auxiliary requests for lack of inventive step (Order).

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
The mere generation of further data from measurement data already collected from the human body is not a technical effect (T 2681/16 and the Guidelines for Examination not followed). See Reasons 2.3 of the decision.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Roche Diabetes Care GmbH; F. Hoffmann-La Roche AG
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 84; EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 20(1); RPBA 2020 Art. 20(2); Guidelines for examination, Part G, Chapter II, 3.3
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Claims – clarity (no); Inventive step – (no): no credible technical effect produced by deriving additional data from medical measurements
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/04, G 0001/19, T 2681/16, T 1091/17, T 1910/20, T 0335/21
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2319/22; 2024-7-9; Displaying numbers to a user/BISSANTZ

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Information_Presentation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Alleged_Technical_Contribution_Not_Established_Across_Claim_Scope
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The software displays numbers with visual emphasis determined by their values, including font size and numerical units, similar to a data-cloud visualisation (Reasons 1 and 2.1).
– Technical effect at issue: Drawing attention to certain displayed numbers or reducing cognitive burden did not establish a technical effect. The claims did not tie the information to technical control or objectively specified human-machine interaction (Reasons 2.5-2.6 and 4).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A computer system displaying numerical data is technical as a whole, but presentation of numbers as such is not sufficient for inventive step.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The claimed variation from data-cloud prior art was essentially replacing symbols with the underlying numbers. No technical application or effect over the full claim scope was established; claims merely labelling the data technical did not remedy this (Reasons 2.4-2.7 and 4.1).
– Applicatioin field: The claims are directed to generally applicable numeric information visualisation, not a specified machine-control sector.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC was decisive for all requests, including those adding number input, database origins and formatting rules.
– Outcome: All claim requests lacked inventive step; the appeal was dismissed (Reasons 4-5 and Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Bissantz, Nicolas, Dr.rer.Pol.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – all requests (no)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19, T 0935/97, T 1173/97, T 0643/00, T 0154/04, T 1227/05, T 1235/07, T 1741/08
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2288/22; 2024-7-2; Lock screen/FIRSTFACE

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Information_Presentation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Biometric_Authentication
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention concerns a mobile terminal which displays a lock screen after activation and performs camera-based user authentication (Reasons 1 and 2).
– Technical effect at issue: The only relevant distinguishing features were display of a lock screen or an alarm message. Such information presentation did not credibly assist in a technical task, and subjective convenience or speed did not establish a technical effect (Reasons 2.2 and 3).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The mobile device, camera and authentication operation are technical, but not every aspect of their user interface makes an inventive technical contribution.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The displayed lock screen and alarm were informational features without a demonstrated technical effect. Moreover, displaying a lock screen after pressing a button was notoriously known (Reasons 2.2.1-2.2.4).
– Applicatioin field: The claimed interface is used for biometric unlocking and authentication of a mobile terminal.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was decisive for both the main request and the auxiliary request; the auxiliary display message did not change the result.
– Outcome: Both requests failed under Article 56 EPC; the appeal was dismissed (Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Firstface Co., Ltd
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main and auxiliary requests (no): distinguishing feature relates to mere “presentation of information”
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 0336/14
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2055/22; 2024-4-26; Displaying locations for aircraft landing/HONEYWELL

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Information_Presentation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Alleged_Technical_Contribution_Not_Established_Across_Claim_Scope
APPLICATION FIELD: #Avionics_and_Flight_Operations
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: An avionics display shows predicted aircraft landing-location cues in three dimensions for different landing-gear/flap configurations after a loss of engine thrust (Reasons 1 and 2).
– Technical effect at issue: Safe-landing guidance was alleged, but the claim did not define how the locations were determined from technical aircraft conditions, so the displayed cues did not credibly provide the asserted guided technical human-machine interaction (Reasons 2.6-2.7).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The underlying avionics display and aircraft are technical means; whether the particular displayed cues contribute technically depends on their claimed generation and operative use.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Because location cues could be arbitrary estimates or simulation-derived values and were not tied to actual operating measurements, a technical contribution was not established across the claim. Conventional 3D map presentation was obvious (Reasons 2.7-2.9).
– Applicatioin field: The new application-field tag Avionics_and_Flight_Operations is proposed: the case concerns in-flight landing guidance rather than aircraft maintenance.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step over D6 was decisive. The alleged flight-safety effect was not derivable from the broad claim wording.
– Outcome: The claim lacked inventive step under Article 56 EPC and the appeal was dismissed (Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Honeywell International Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no): distinguishing features relate to mere “presentation of information”
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 0528/07, T 0336/14
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1327/22; 2025-11-19; Selecting a payment method/CURVE UK

TECHNOLOGY: #Financial_Transaction_and_Payment_Technologies #Payment_Method_Reselection_and_Refunds
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Mobile_Payments_and_Contactless_Transactions
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Added_Subject_Matter
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claim concerns post-transaction reselection of a payment method through a consolidated payment device and a server, followed by cancellation and refund of the original payment.
– Technical effect at issue: The proposed ability to charge a different payment method and refund the first one was treated as a financial arrangement, not a further technical effect (Reasons 1.4-1.6).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A payment device and server provide technical means, so the claimed subject-matter is assessed as a computer-implemented mixed invention rather than an excluded business method as such.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The distinguishing financial settlement rule can be given to the skilled person as a non-technical requirement; its implementation on the known system was obvious and lacked specified technical measures (Reasons 1.4-1.7).
– Applicatioin field: The consolidated payment device may be a card or mobile phone, and the invention concerns electronic payment transactions and subsequent settlement choices.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC was decisive. The Board also found that the amended wording concerning charging and refunding was implicitly disclosed, so Article 123(2) EPC was satisfied (Reasons 2.2-2.4).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because neither the main request nor the first auxiliary request provided an inventive technical contribution.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Curve UK Limited
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 123(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – selecting a second payment method after funds have been deducted from a first payment method and refunding the amount to the first payment method – (no – not technical)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0754/22; 2025-11-4; Allocating time-slots to trucks/BEN-ALEXANDER

TECHNOLOGY: #Software_and_Computer_Architecture #Workflow_Management_Systems
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Logistics_and_Terminal_Operations
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention allocates truck service time-slots at a shipping terminal, dynamically changes reservations and links entry permission to a terminal barrier.
– Technical effect at issue: Reduced queues, improved allocation of terminal resources and any reduction in emissions were found to stem from the scheduling scheme rather than from the claimed technical implementation; the known barrier actuation adds no new effect (Reasons 2.1-2.2).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The reservation computer, truck identification equipment and physical barrier are technical features, but this does not make the underlying appointment policy technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The distinguishing booking and scheduling rules were administrative constraints under COMVIK. Implementing them using the data sources and gate control of D5 was within ordinary programming knowledge (Reasons 2.1.2-2.1.4).
– Applicatioin field: The subject matter is truck flow, container-terminal capacity and admission control in freight logistics.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive question was inventive step under Article 56 EPC. The Board also saw no basis for a referral to the Enlarged Board because no formulated question was filed (Reasons 2.7).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed; the claimed scheduling and gate-control arrangement was obvious over D5 and common general knowledge.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Ben-Alexander, Eran; Porat, Lilia; Aboudy, Efraim
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no) – mixture of technical and non-technical features – common general knowledge – obvious solution
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19, T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1360/22; 2025-10-6; Santé d’hélicoptères/SAFRAN

TECHNOLOGY: #Statistical_Modelling_and_Data_Analytics #Clustering_and_Predictive_Modelling
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Alleged_Technical_Contribution_Not_Established_Across_Claim_Scope
APPLICATION FIELD: #Aircraft_Maintenance_and_Health_Monitoring
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: Recorded helicopter flight data and maintenance histories are partitioned into mission types and used to construct statistical component-ageing models for maintenance scheduling.
– Technical effect at issue: Component condition assessment and maintenance scheduling can be technical aims, but the Board found no credible improvement in ageing-estimation accuracy or maintenance effectiveness from the broadly defined mission clustering and severity models (Reasons 12-15.2).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed use of flight sensors and a monitoring system gives the invention a technical setting; abstract statistical partitioning does not automatically acquire technical character from that setting.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Clustering and statistical modelling, without concrete sensor parameters, clustering criteria or a proven functional link to improved physical assessment, did not contribute to inventive step; use of historical maintenance data was also obvious (Reasons 14-17).
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns helicopter fleet condition monitoring and predictive maintenance of aircraft components.
– Decisive legal issue: Article 56 EPC was decisive, applying COMVIK to distinguish technical aircraft-condition assessment from unsubstantiated statistical modelling.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because both the main request and the auxiliary request lacked inventive step over D1.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Safran; Safran Helicopter Engines
LEGAL PROVISIONS: CBE Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Activité inventive – toutes les requêtes (non)
AI-TRANSLATED-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – all requests (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 1635/19
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0710/22; 2025-6-26; Risk management of sports-associated businesses/CRYSTAL WORLD

TECHNOLOGY: #Statistical_Modelling_and_Data_Analytics #Risk_Index_Modelling
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Insurance_and_Risk_Management
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The system derives a sports risk index from economic and sporting variables, with a database, processing components and a hierarchical user-selection interface.
– Technical effect at issue: Alleged savings in bandwidth or processing effort from choosing only selected activities, and resilience to missing data, were not linked to a claimed technical implementation; the calculated risk values were cognitive/business information (Reasons 2.5-2.10).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The processing, storage, communication and terminal components establish the technical character of the claimed system under Article 52 EPC, as expressly accepted by the Board (Reasons 2.1-2.3).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The SRI calculations and selected inputs form a non-technical risk-management specification. Ordinary computer implementation added no inventive technical contribution, and the user interface was already known from D1 (Reasons 2.4-2.11).
– Applicatioin field: The model supports economic risk management for businesses associated with sports activities.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC was decisive; the Board also rejected the allegation of a substantial procedural violation arising from the earlier examination (Reasons 1.1-1.2).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed for the main and auxiliary requests because the business-risk model did not provide an inventive technical solution.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Crystal World Holdings, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no) – main request and auxiliary request – mixture of technical and non-technical features
CITED DECISIONS: T 1194/97, T 0641/00, T 0258/03, T 1670/07, T 1928/14
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0588/22; 2025-5-28; Access decision evaluation for building automation and control systems/SIGNIFY HOLDING

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Access_Control
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Reduced_Latency #Enhanced_Security
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Building_and_Construction
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Added_Subject_Matter #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Maintain_Patent

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A building automation and control system first obtains an access decision and device-specific policy centrally, then stores that policy at the accessed device to decide later requests locally.
– Technical effect at issue: The hybrid centralised/distributed access-control arrangement reduces the latency of repeated decisions while retaining scalable security administration in a network of building devices (Reasons 4.2-4.7 and 10.2.10).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Authentication and authorisation of physical building devices, and communication with a central policy evaluation apparatus, are technical operations.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board found the hybrid policy delegation and local evaluation non-obvious from D1 or D2 in the claimed building-automation setting; the remaining independent claims of auxiliary request 5 involved an inventive step (Reasons 10.2.10-10.3.4).
– Applicatioin field: The field is control and access management for building automation devices, including locks and lighting equipment.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive issues were inventive step and added subject-matter; auxiliary request 5 was admitted following the Board’s preliminary opinion, and an evident numbering mistake was corrected under Rule 139 EPC (Reasons 2-3 and 11.2).
– Outcome: The decision was set aside and the case remitted with an order to maintain the patent in the amended version of auxiliary request 5, not as granted.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Signify Holding B.V.
OPPOSING-PARTY: Molnia, David
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 123(2), 56; RPBA Art. 13(2); EPC R. 139
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Amendments – added subject-matter (no); Inventive step – (no) – (yes); Amendment to appeal case – taken into account (yes); Correction of error in document(s) – (yes)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1207/22; 2025-2-13; Adapting the complexity of content based on the content consumption rate/SNAP

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Information_Presentation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Not_Finally_Determined
APPLICATION FIELD: #Social_Networking
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Additional_Prior_Art_Search
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The system determines how quickly a user consumes media and chooses content of corresponding complexity; a later auxiliary request treats ephemeral and static content differently when calculating the rate.
– Technical effect at issue: Matching content complexity to user consumption speed produced no acknowledged technical effect; neither data relevance nor asserted transmission savings established a reduction in network traffic (Reasons 1.5-1.7).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The system uses networked computing and media-presentation hardware, giving the claims technical character notwithstanding the non-technical content-selection aim.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The main and first auxiliary requests lacked inventive step, but the Board could not establish the obviousness of the particular static/ephemeral-content calculation in the third auxiliary request without relevant prior art (Reasons 1.8, 2 and 3.1-3.3).
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns personalised consumption and presentation of digital content in a social-media environment.
– Decisive legal issue: Article 56 EPC was assessed, while uncertainty about whether the ephemeral-content feature had been searched provided special reasons for remittal under Article 111(1) EPC and Article 11 RPBA (Reasons 3.3-3.4).
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the application remitted for further prosecution including a search based on the third auxiliary request; no order to grant was made.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Snap Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 111(1); RPBA 2020 Art. 11
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – providing content of different complexity based on content consumption rate (no – obvious implementation of non-technical requirement); Remittal to the department of first instance (yes – uncertain whether search covered feature considered to be non-technical)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 0643/00, T 1351/04, T 1869/08, T 0306/10, T 1463/11, T 2539/12, T 2314/16, T 3176/19
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0660/22; 2025-1-20; Cell analysis/NIKON

TECHNOLOGY: #Media_and_Signal_Processing #Image_Processing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Biotechnology_and_Cell_Analysis
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Sufficiency_of_Disclosure
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Insufficient_Disclosure_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: Cell images are segmented to extract characteristic quantities, whose time-series correlations form a graphical model of possible biological relationships; a further request covers iterative cell manufacture.
– Technical effect at issue: Computing correlations does not constitute an indirect physical measurement without determination of a specified physical quantity through an established factual relationship; the research model has no proven technical use (Reasons 12-15).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Image acquisition and image-processing apparatus are technical, but this does not make all subsequently computed correlations technical measurements under G 1/19.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The generic correlation model of the main and initial auxiliary requests gave no technical contribution supporting inventive step. The manufacturing-purpose amendment introduced a technical aim but lacked enabling instructions across the claim scope (Reasons 15 and 18-22).
– Applicatioin field: The claimed subject matter concerns microscopy-based biological cell research and the production of cells with desired characteristics.
– Decisive legal issue: The Board distinguished Article 56 EPC (absence of a technical contribution in the research tool) from Article 83 EPC (insufficient disclosure of how to obtain cells meeting arbitrary predetermined criteria in auxiliary request B).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed: the main and earlier auxiliary requests failed on inventive step, while the cell-manufacturing auxiliary request failed on sufficiency of disclosure. The Board declined remittal.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: The University of Tokyo; Nikon Corporation
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 83; RPBA 2020 Art. 11
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – technicality – measurements (no); Sufficiency of disclosure – over the whole breadth (no); Remittal – special reasons for remittal (no)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1042/22; 2024-2-29; Coupling of list items/SONY

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Touch_and_Gesture_Control
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A touch-panel device displays animations during a pinch gesture for the on-screen coupling or uncoupling of list items.
– Technical effect at issue: Visual feedback and subjective ease of use were not shown to assist a technical task or yield a tangible technical effect beyond GUI design (Reasons 1.3-1.5).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The display, touch panel and gesture detection are technical components, but the abstract task of rearranging list items is not thereby a technical task.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The differing animations and gesture-driven presentation of list items could not support inventive step because they were not linked to technical control of the display device (Reasons 1.3-1.6).
– Applicatioin field: The invention relates to a general-purpose graphical user interface for manipulating displayed information.
– Decisive legal issue: Article 56 EPC and admission under Article 12(4) RPBA were decisive. The second and third auxiliary requests were not admitted because no adequate reason for first filing them on appeal was given (Reasons 3.1-3.3).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed after rejection of the main and first auxiliary requests for lack of inventive step and non-admission of the later requests.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Sony Group Corporation
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 12(4)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main and 1st auxiliary request (no): “coupling of list items” on a screen is not a technical task; Admittance of claim amendments filed on appeal – 2nd and 3rd auxiliary requests (no): no reasons for late-filing provided
CITED DECISIONS: T 1802/13, T 0336/14, T 1681/18, T 1762/18
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2202/21; 2024-2-27; Managing content subscription/ROVI

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Authentication
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Alleged_Technical_Contribution_Not_Established_Across_Claim_Scope
APPLICATION FIELD: #Digital_Commerce_and_Content_Distribution
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Patent_Revoked

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The patent concerns subscription-account creation and validation using authentication keys exchanged among content provider and aggregator servers.
– Technical effect at issue: The alleged security and reliability improvements depended on secure provision and handling of keys not required by the claim; delegating account administration to a third party did not itself improve security (Reasons 1.1.7-1.1.11).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Authentication keys and servers have technical aspects, but the claimed allocation of subscription-management tasks also embodies commercial and administrative requirements.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Under COMVIK, third-party subscription aggregation was a non-technical requirement; even assuming a security contribution from comparison with a list of valid credentials, it was an obvious alternative to a keyed hash (Reasons 1.1.9-1.1.12).
– Applicatioin field: The application relates to paid content subscriptions and cross-service account activation.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC and substantiation/admission of auxiliary requests under Article 12(3) and (4) RPBA were decisive.
– Outcome: The opponent’s appeal succeeded: the decision was set aside and the patent revoked; auxiliary requests were not admitted as insufficiently substantiated fresh cases.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Rovi Guides, Inc.
OPPOSING-PARTY: RTL Deutschland GmbH
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 12(3), 12(4)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main request (no): differences concern administrative (non-technical) aspects; Admittance of claim requests filed with the appeal – 1st and 2nd auxiliary requests (no): not sufficiently substantiated + “fresh case”
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19, T 0641/00, T 0108/20
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1803/21; 2023-12-21; Grouping of multiple objects/HUAWEI

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Information_Presentation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Consumer_Electronics_and_Appliances
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention groups displayed objects according to a threshold count and a selected sorting criterion, including occupied storage size, and displays group identifiers on a terminal.
– Technical effect at issue: Alleged screen-space optimisation and reduced processing burden were not credibly established: the claim specifies no display geometry and the threshold and grouping choices follow subjective user preferences (Reasons 1.1.3-1.1.6).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The terminal device and operating-system view control are technical means, while the information arrangement displayed on their screen need not solve a technical task.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The distinguishing grouping and threshold rules were held to be obvious information presentation without a credible contribution to a technical task or guided human-machine interaction (Reasons 1.1.6 and 1.2).
– Applicatioin field: The field is display and object-list organisation on consumer terminal devices.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC was decisive; the Board compared the claimed grouping operation with prior-art hierarchical display of data items.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because the sole request lacked inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 12(8)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Decision in written proceedings – (yes): cancellation of hearing following appellant’s announcement of non-attendance; Inventive step – (no): obvious implementation of a certain type of presentation of information
CITED DECISIONS: T 1802/13, T 0336/14
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0558/21; 2025-12-15; Calcul cryptographique sur courbe elliptique/IDEMIA

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Cryptography
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Enhanced_Security
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Cybersecurity
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Maintain_Patent

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: Elliptic-curve cryptography is the technical setting. The claimed electronic component converts a secret parameter into a point on an elliptic curve for subsequent cryptographic use.
– Technical effect at issue: The Board recognised the combined technical effect of efficient point generation and protecting the secret parameter against timing-based attacks (reasons 40.4–40.7). Security, rather than abstract point calculation alone, is crucial.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A mathematical calculation as such is not technical merely because cryptographic uses are conceivable. Here, the express secret parameter and claimed cryptographic context establish technical character (reasons 27–29 and 40).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The calculation steps cannot be disregarded en bloc under COMVIK because they contribute to an established technical effect. The Board did not decide whether every mathematical detail independently contributes (reasons 40.7 and 41).
– Applicatioin field: The claimed method addresses cryptographic protection of secrets in electronic systems.
– Decisive legal issue: The central question is which mathematical claim features contribute to technical character when assessing inventive step, with ancillary issues of claim interpretation, amendments and procedural rights.
– Outcome: The appealed decision was set aside and the case remitted with an order to maintain the patent on auxiliary request 8, claims 1–4, with the description adapted.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
1. Sur la pertinence de l’appartenance d’une invention à un « domaine technique » pour son caractère technique et pour l’identification des caractéristiques qui y contribuent, cf. points 29 et 42.
2. Sur la contribution technique d’une méthode mathématique de génération d’un point sur une courbe elliptique utilisé dans une application cryptographique, cf. point 40.
3. Sur la détermination des caractéristiques d’une invention qui contribuent à son caractère technique dans le cadre de l’approche COMVIK, cf. point 41.

AI-TRANSLATED-HEADNOTE:
1. On the relevance of an invention belonging to a “technical field” for its technical character and for identifying the features contributing to that character, see points 29 and 42.
2. On the technical contribution of a mathematical method for generating a point on an elliptic curve used in a cryptographic application, see point 40.
3. On determining the features of an invention that contribute to its technical character under the COMVIK approach, see point 41.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Idemia Identity & Security France
OPPOSING-PARTY: Bundesdruckerei GmbH; GIESECKE & DEVRIENT GmbH
LEGAL PROVISIONS: CBE Art. 52(1), 52(2), 52(3), 54, 56, 83, 84, 101(3)b), 113(1), 116, 123(2), 123(3); CBE R. 80; RPCR 2020 Art. 11, 13(2), 15a(1)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Procédure orale – requête de tenue de la procédure orale par visioconférence (refusée); Vice substantiel de procédure – violation du droit d’être entendu (non); Modifications – admises (oui); Interprétation de la revendication 1 – sous-étape mentionnée dans la revendication n’est pas limitative; Exclusion de la brevetabilité – (non); Activité inventive – effet technique (oui) – non-évidence au regard de l’état de la technique documenté pas contestée en recours
AI-TRANSLATED-KEYWORDS: Oral proceedings – request to hold oral proceedings by videoconference (refused); Substantial procedural violation – violation of the right to be heard (no); Amendments – admitted (yes); Interpretation of claim 1 – substep mentioned in the claim is not limiting; Exclusion from patentability – (no); Inventive step – technical effect (yes) – non-obviousness over the documented prior art not contested on appeal
CITED DECISIONS: G 0003/14, G 0001/19, T 0072/95, T 0027/97, T 0641/00, T 0052/02, T 0619/02, T 0914/02, T 0258/03, T 0154/04, T 0471/05, T 0930/05, T 0756/06, T 1326/06, T 1358/09, T 2230/10, T 0556/14, T 0697/17, T 1924/17, T 0761/20, T 0540/21
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0374/21; 2024-10-11; User interface for option trading/INTERACTIVE BROKERS

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Graphical_User_Interfaces
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Financial_Markets_and_Trading
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed option-trading tool uses a graphical interface to adjust and display market-implied and customised probability distributions of asset prices.
– Technical effect at issue: The Board found no technical effect beyond ordinary display, input and implementation of non-technical trading requirements; pixel-scaled bar manipulation did not change that conclusion (reasons 1.5–5.2).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Computer execution and ordinary input/display facilities confer technical character on the claim as a whole, but trading decisions and price data do not thereby become technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The claimed GUI serves the non-technical task of customising asset-price probabilities; no interaction with the computer that solves a further technical problem was established.
– Applicatioin field: Options trading and financial market analysis are the concrete application.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under COMVIK turns on whether interactive presentation of financial information contributes to a technical solution.
– Outcome: The main request and all four auxiliary requests failed for lack of inventive step; the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Interactive Brokers Llc
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – customising probability distribution of prices (no – no technical effect)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 1185/13, T 1802/13, T 0336/14
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0367/21; 2024-6-6; Electronic payment system/RICCI

TECHNOLOGY: #Financial_Transaction_and_Payment_Technologies #Real_Time_Interbank_Payments
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Mobile_Payments_and_Contactless_Transactions
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The system uses payer and payee mobile terminals, their banks and an interbank network for immediate payment and confirmation. New technology subtag: #Real_Time_Interbank_Payments (no existing subtag covers SEPA-based bank transfers).
– Technical effect at issue: Claimed SEPA compliance, real-time settlement and fund availability were treated as commercial or administrative requirements; the alternative receipt notification was an obvious technical option, not a proven security improvement (reasons 9–18).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The networked mobile/payment implementation supplies technical character, irrespective of the non-technical nature of the payment scheme.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The differences from D2 were either non-technical constraints to be implemented or obvious choices using conventional networks, so no non-obvious technical contribution was shown.
– Applicatioin field: Mobile payments between bank accounts, including the exchange of payment confirmation, are the application.
– Decisive legal issue: The Board accepted novelty over D1 because the claimed banks were on separate devices, but the decisive reason for refusal was obviousness over D2 (reasons 2–6 and 22–24).
– Outcome: All requests were rejected for lack of inventive step and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Ricci, Francesco
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 54, 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – transferring funds in real time using SEPA (no – not technical)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 1670/07
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0905/21; 2024-5-27; Providing targeted fulfilment with respect to a wireless device protection program/ASSURANT, INC.

TECHNOLOGY: #Software_and_Computer_Architecture #Workflow_Management_Systems
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Insurance_and_Risk_Management
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The application concerns a computer-implemented decision/workflow engine using a predictive, weighted model to process insurance and warranty fulfilment claims for wireless devices.
– Technical effect at issue: Faster claim fulfilment reflected contractual business priorities, while any reduced processing from pre-calculated options was an inevitable bonus effect, not a demonstrated technical solution (reasons 2.4–3.7).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claim uses a processor, memory and client devices; its overall technical character is not in dispute.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The selection, weighting and precomputation of claim-fulfilment options remained business-related requirements implemented by ordinary computing means.
– Applicatioin field: Insurance, warranties and handling of protection-plan claims are central to the invention.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive issue was inventive step under COMVIK, particularly whether reduced business processing time can supply a further technical effect.
– Outcome: The main and two auxiliary requests lacked inventive step; the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Assurant, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – processing user claims associated with a wireless device protection program (no – no technical effect)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1148/18
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1384/21; 2024-3-20; Predictive search/GOOGLE LLC

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Graphical_User_Interfaces
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Photography_and_Geolocation
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Clarity_of_Claims
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A mobile-device GUI proactively offers interactive search functions selected by matching the device location against whitelisted locations.
– Technical effect at issue: The automatically location-adapted GUI changes the search functionality actually available to the user, thereby facilitating interaction and selection of the applicable search type (reasons 5.5–5.6).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): An actionable GUI element that invokes a search is a technical feature, rather than a mere passive presentation of information.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The claimed location-sensitive selection and presentation of interactive search controls had technical significance and were not suggested by D1–D4 (reasons 5.6–5.9).
– Applicatioin field: The search functions are geolocation-dependent, including examples such as visual/QR-code searches and navigation.
– Decisive legal issue: Both inventive step and claim clarity were addressed in the amended main request; the Board found the inventive step established and the earlier objections overcome.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted for further prosecution, in particular to consider consequential adaptations of claims and description; no grant was ordered.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Google LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 84
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (yes) – after amendment; Claims – clarity after amendment (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: T 2028/11
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1425/21; 2024-2-7; Distilled Machine Learning Models/Google

TECHNOLOGY: #Artificial_Intelligence_and_Machine_Learning #Model_Training
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Lower_Memory_Usage
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Alleged_Technical_Contribution_Not_Established_Across_Claim_Scope
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention trains a smaller distilled machine-learning model on the soft outputs of a larger model, with a temperature-dependent softmax formulation.
– Technical effect at issue: Reduced memory usage was the asserted technical effect at issue; however, a sufficiently good trade-off between model size and predictive accuracy was not established across the broad claim (reasons 17–20.2).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed model-training process is computer implemented. That does not establish the specific further technical effect relied upon for inventive step.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board did not accept the asserted size/accuracy trade-off as an effect achieved throughout the scope; the claimed training features therefore did not support inventive step on that case.
– Applicatioin field: The claims address machine learning generally without restricting classification to a specific downstream field.
– Decisive legal issue: The decision rests on Article 56 EPC. Article 83 EPC was discussed as a hypothetical additional problem under the applicant’s narrower claim interpretation, expressly not as a ground of decision (reasons 21–25).
– Outcome: The main and auxiliary requests were rejected for lack of inventive step; the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Google LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 83
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no) – effect not made credible within the whole scope of claim
CITED DECISIONS: T 0702/20, T 0748/19
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0576/21; 2023-11-21; Managing pre-computed search results/AMADEUS

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Cache_Refresh_Optimisation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Processing_Efficiency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Transportation_and_Travel
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention controls the refresh of cached pre-computed search results using validity trends, instantaneous validity rates and correlations between result groups. New technology subtag: #Cache_Refresh_Optimisation.
– Technical effect at issue: More reliable invalidity estimates improve the trade-off between computation spent refreshing cached results and the real validity of the cached data, which the Board accepted as a technical caching effect (reasons 5.7–5.10).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The invention operates database/search caching infrastructure; its technical character is established.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The correlation-based update scheduling credibly improves management of constrained computation resources; neither D1 nor D2 suggested the amended distinguishing features (reasons 5.10–5.11).
– Applicatioin field: The disclosed application examples concern pre-computed priced travel recommendations, although the caching mechanism is more general.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step of the amended independent claims was decisive; the amended main request was admitted during oral proceedings under Article 13(2) RPBA.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted for further prosecution to check dependent claims and the description, not with a grant order.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Amadeus S.A.S.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (yes) – after amendment
CITED DECISIONS: T 0117/10, T 0729/21
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0415/21; 2023-11-14; Translations of text in images/GOOGLE LLC

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Information_Presentation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Machine_Translation_and_Language_Services
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The application recognises text within images, translates it and chooses a GUI layout for selectively showing translations based on image text arrangements.
– Technical effect at issue: Avoiding visual clutter and reducing cognitive burden are not technical effects in this claim; the alleged display-area constraint was not reflected in the distinguishing features (reasons 2.7–2.9).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): An activatable user-interface element is technical, but the design of information presentation and the cognitive content remain non-technical per se.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The selectable GUI control and mapping between presentation contexts and interfaces were conventional/obvious; the additional layout choices did not solve a technical display problem.
– Applicatioin field: The displayed information is a language translation of text identified in captured images.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was the decisive substantive issue. The Board also considered, and rejected, the allegation of a violation of the right to be heard under Article 113(1) EPC.
– Outcome: All requests lacked inventive step, and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Google LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 113(1)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no) – mixture of technical and non-technical features; Disputed common general knowledge; Right to be heard – violation (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0939/92, T 0190/03, T 0928/03, T 0154/04, T 1242/04, T 1143/06, T 1741/08, T 2467/09, T 2045/10, T 1526/11, T 2028/11, T 2035/11, T 1273/20
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0767/21; 2023-10-10; Blockchain generation method/NIPPON

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Blockchain
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Cryptocurrency_and_Digital_Ledgers
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention concerns a blockchain consensus protocol alternating proof of stake with the number of counterparties a participant has transacted with.
– Technical effect at issue: Although alternating incentives makes mining monopolisation harder, the Board characterised the effect as economic/social deterrence and ledger-content accuracy, not improved technical blockchain security (reasons 3.7–3.16).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed computer-implemented blockchain system is technical overall; however, the content of the consensus policy is not thereby technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The non-technical eligibility policy can be given to the skilled person as a requirement; its computer implementation was straightforward. The Board expressly did not rule out technical contributions by other blockchain protocols.
– Applicatioin field: The field is cryptocurrency consensus and transaction ledgers. New application field tag: #Cryptocurrency_and_Digital_Ledgers (the supplied payment tags concern other payment contexts).
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under COMVIK was decisive; the third auxiliary request also had clarity issues, but was evaluated under Article 56 notwithstanding them.
– Outcome: Both remaining auxiliary requests lacked inventive step; the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Nippon Telegraph and Telephone Corporation
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 84; RPBA Art. 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – a blockchain consensus protocol that alternates between two parameters: proof of stake and the number of counterparties a miner has transacted with (no – not technical)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 1358/09, T 0630/11, T 2330/13, T 0550/14, T 2314/16
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1573/21; 2023-8-30; DETERMINING VIRTUAL MACHINE DRIFTING / Huawei

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Cloud_Infrastructure
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Processing_Efficiency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention detects virtual-machine migration between hosts and obtains a VM identifier by intercepting or receiving an Address Resolution Protocol (ARP) packet.
– Technical effect at issue: Using an ARP packet provides an efficient technical way to obtain the unique VM identifier; the Board relied on this effect rather than a contested separate migration-detection effect (reasons 3.4–3.6).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed host/server protocol processing and virtual-machine management are technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Prior art D1 did not point to ARP packets as the source of the unique identifier; the claimed solution was not obvious without hindsight (reasons 3.7–3.8).
– Applicatioin field: The practical field is virtual-machine infrastructure and general-purpose server computing.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC was the sole deciding legal issue.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and remittal was ordered with an instruction to grant a patent based on the main request, subject to adapted description and drawings.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (yes) – non-obvious solution
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0133/21; 2024-7-2; Interactive seat map/STUBHUB

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Web_Technologies
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Cross_Browser_Compatible_Interactive_Map_Rendering
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Not_Finally_Determined
APPLICATION FIELD: #Event_Ticketing_and_Attendance
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Additional_Prior_Art_Search #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention concerns an online ticket marketplace with an interactive venue seat map. A client-side overlay is constructed using a raster base map, an HTML coded image map and, as explained in the description, JavaScript Canvas.
– Technical effect at issue: Browser-compatible implementation without reliance on vector-graphics plug-ins was the asserted technical advantage. The main request was too broad to establish it; the more specific HTML/raster-based implementation in auxiliary request 1 was considered technical and not obvious on the cited documents, but required further searching.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The computer/network implementation provides technical character, whereas the seat-availability information conveyed to users is not technical per se.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board recognised technical considerations in the concrete choice of map-rendering technology. It found the main request non-inventive, but regarded the first auxiliary request as not obvious over the available citations; its ultimate inventiveness remained open pending an additional search.
– Applicatioin field: The service is an online marketplace presenting tickets and seating availability for events.
– Decisive legal issue: The central issue was the correct COMVIK treatment of an HTML image-map and client-side overlay implementation; admission of the first auxiliary request and the need for a further prior-art search were also addressed.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted for further prosecution, expressly including a search. The Board did not order grant.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: STUBHUB, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 111(1), 123(2); EPC R. 137(3); RPBA 2020 Art. 11
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – technical considerations – building overlay on top of a base map using HTML image map (yes); Remittal to the deparment of first instance – special reasons (yes – further search required)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 1463/11
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0156/21; 2024-5-14; Changing a software code executed by a production system/SAP

TECHNOLOGY: #Software_and_Computer_Architecture #Programming
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Enhanced_Security
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Not_Finally_Determined
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Additional_Prior_Art_Search
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The application combines continuous integration, source-code management, testing and a change-management computer system for controlled deployment of executable code to a production computer system.
– Technical effect at issue: The appellant alleged improved security and avoidance of bottlenecks through distributed checks and workflow stages. The Board required an examination of the individual technical implementation features and their effects rather than treating the entire process as an administrative workflow.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claim concerns a distributed computer system and a computer-implemented process; exclusion as a business method as such was not the reason for refusal.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board held that the examining division had not properly applied the problem-solution/COMVIK approach: it combined documents when choosing the starting point and inadequately considered specific continuous-integration features. No final finding of inventive step or a proven security benefit was made.
– Applicatioin field: The subject matter is software development, code change control and deployment in IT production environments.
– Decisive legal issue: A properly grounded inventive-step analysis, starting from one piece of prior art, and a search specifically covering continuous integration were required.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted for further examination and additional search; no grant was ordered.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: SAP SE
LEGAL PROVISIONS: RPBA 2020 Art. 11; EPC Art. 56, 111(1)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Remittal – (yes) – special reasons for remittal
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 0787/18, T 0072/20, T 0098/21
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1644/20; 2024-4-11; Event recognition/APPLE

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Touch_and_Gesture_Control
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction #Improved_Processing_Efficiency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Consumer_Electronics_and_Appliances
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Added_Subject_Matter
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claims concern input-event recognition in a hierarchical graphical user interface, using multiple recognisers to process sub-events concurrently for actively involved views.
– Technical effect at issue: The Board accepted a new UI capability: views can recognise user input sequences containing sub-events outside those views. Concurrent event processing also provides flexibility in resolving overlapping-view conflicts and may accelerate recognition in particular situations; no general speed-up was assumed.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The invention is a technical user-interface event-handling mechanism, not merely a rule for displaying information.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Unlike the cited database interface, the claimed event-handling structure allows multiple objects to recognise and process sub-events concurrently. The Board found inventive step over D1 for the first auxiliary request.
– Applicatioin field: The described implementation concerns touch-sensitive graphical interfaces on electronic devices.
– Decisive legal issue: Added-matter objections were overcome and inventive step over D1 was recognised; other cited documents still needed assessment.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted. D2 to D4 had not yet been assessed for inventive step, so there was no order to grant.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Apple Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 123(2), 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Amendments – added subject-matter (no); Inventive step – (yes)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0279/21; 2024-1-30; State-transition-controlled processing of objects/SWISS RE

TECHNOLOGY: #Software_and_Computer_Architecture #Workflow_Management_Systems
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention implements a state-transition workflow system in which task-execution rules and operating tags govern the states of process objects.
– Technical effect at issue: The asserted flexibility of workflows, use of operating tags and avoidance of a folder-based representation did not establish a technical effect beyond straightforward computer implementation.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed system uses computer-based execution modules and hence is technical as a whole; the business-process rules are not thereby rendered technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Applying COMVIK and discussing G 1/19, the Board rejected the proposition that every implementation detail lacking a one-to-one correspondence with a business-process step must be technical. It is the actual effect and technical nature of the implementation that matter; the claimed features did not support inventive step.
– Applicatioin field: The claims relate to administration of workflow tasks and their state transitions.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive question was whether workflow control rules and state labels contributed to a technical solution under Article 56 EPC.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because claim 1 lacked inventive step.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
The appellant considered that … when [G 1/19] , e.g. at reasons, point 51, states that any technical effect going beyond the implementation of the process on a computer may be considered for inventive step, it means anything beyond a 1:1 mapping between the implementation and a step of the business method being implemented. In other words, any subject-matter that does not “map” to a step in the business method is technical.
The Board agrees that the “implementation” of a business method implies some sort of mapping between non-technical steps of the business method and their technical realisation. Decision G 1/19 has something to say about this mapping, at least in the forward direction, at point 51, when it rephrases the requirement for technical effect as “technical effect going beyond the simulation’s straightforward or unspecified implementation on a standard computer system”. Thus, even a 1:1 mapping might be inventive if it is not “straight-forward” (e.g. not standard programming or routine modification of the technical means used), or “unspecified” (e.g. not simply as “means for [carrying out the step]”).
But, looking for a mapping from “implementation” to the step of a business method in the reverse direction does not make sense as the steps of the non-technical activity do not have to be specified explicitly. They would include any steps that the business person would come up with in a non-technical workflow. The way this is handled is by considering the mapping of the implementation to the effect of the step and to examine whether the effect has any technical character, or whether it would be covered by what the business person would consider as part of the non-technical process. This is, in other words, the standard COMVIK approach where one looks at the effect of a feature in order to pose a technical problem, which might simply be the implementation of the feature, for which the above-mentioned mapping in the forward direction meant in G 1/19 applies. (See Reasons 2.18)

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Swiss Reinsurance Company Ltd.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – workflow rules controlling tasks and tags labelling the states of the tasks (no – not technical)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19, T 0894/10
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1757/20; 2024-1-25; Tracking containers/OWENS-BROCKWAY GLASS CONTAINER

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Data_Storage
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Packaging_and_Supply_Chain_Traceability
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Substantial_Procedural_Violation
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention tracks reusable containers throughout their distribution chain using unique identifiers and collects information about filling and subsequent use.
– Technical effect at issue: The alleged possibility of using collected information to redesign containers did not provide an active technical effect: the claim neither defined how a container was technically redesigned nor required a manufacturing-control step. Human assessment of data interrupted the asserted chain to a possible later technical result.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Tracking hardware and databases are technical means, but the information and administrative purpose of collecting it did not automatically establish a further technical effect.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board found the main and first auxiliary requests obvious over D1 in view of common general knowledge. Nevertheless, an improperly reasoned exercise of discretion regarding later auxiliary requests was a substantial procedural violation.
– Applicatioin field: The subject matter concerns container identification, supply-chain monitoring and feedback for packaging design.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was rejected for the main and first auxiliary requests. The decisive procedural point concerned the admission of amendments under Rule 137(3) EPC: the examining division changed objections and failed to justify its discretion adequately.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted for further prosecution; reimbursement of the appeal fee was ordered because of the procedural violation. The Board did not recognise an inventive step for the main request.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Owens-Brockway Glass Container Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; EPC R. 137(3)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – gather the necessary data relating to the filling of a container with the purpose of being able to modify a design of the containers (no – no technical effect); Substantial procedural violation – discretionary decision of the examining division on amendments (yes – not fully reasoned)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1234/17, T 1741/08, T 0641/00, T 1389/08, T 1045/18, T 0309/09
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1806/20; 2023-11-17; Rain-sensitive parcels/IVECO

TECHNOLOGY: #Navigation_and_Positioning_Technologies #Route_Planning_and_Guidance
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Transportation_and_Travel
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The application combines satellite navigation, destination weather forecasts, RFID information and route changes for the delivery of rain-sensitive parcels.
– Technical effect at issue: Avoiding rain exposure was a logistical requirement rather than a technical contribution of the claimed route-calculation system. The parcel-specific water-sensitivity information was cognitive rather than functional technical data in the sense discussed in T 1194/97.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The apparatus contains technical navigation and communication components; the claimed rules for postponing deliveries are non-technical logistics instructions.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board held that storing the parcel information, consulting rain forecasts, issuing warnings and recalculating routes would have been obvious once the business requirement was given to the skilled person.
– Applicatioin field: The claimed system belongs to parcel delivery, vehicle navigation and logistics.
– Decisive legal issue: The central issue was the technical significance of weather-dependent delivery scheduling and associated data under the COMVIK approach.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed for lack of inventive step across the requests considered.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
Decision T 1194/97 established at point 3.3 of the reasons that data was functional if its loss impaired the technical operation of a system in which it was used.
…It is self-evident that if a piece, either technical or non-technical, of any invention is taken out, it would not work as designed. In the Board’s view, what T 1194/97 is saying is rather that the loss of functional data would make the system inoperable at the technical level. In contrast, if cognitive data is lost, the system would still work but possibly produce results that would be unintended for non-technical reasons.
(See point 3.8 of the reasons)

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Iveco S.p.A.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – delaying the delivery of rain-sensitive parcels until it stops raining (no – not technical)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1194/97, T 0641/00, T 0424/03, T 0154/04, T 2035/11
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1903/20; 2023-10-30; Rare-word processing/GOOGLE

TECHNOLOGY: #Artificial_Intelligence_and_Machine_Learning #Natural_Language_Processing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Machine_Translation_and_Language_Services
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention is a neural-machine-translation architecture for handling rare or unknown words or tokens in source-to-target language translation.
– Technical effect at issue: Any improvement in the linguistic output of the translation system was not recognised as a technical effect. The asserted algorithmic refinements were expressed at a high level and did not improve the functioning of the computer itself.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The computer system has technical character; this does not imply that linguistic translation rules and their high-level algorithms contribute to inventiveness.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Relying on G 3/08 and distinguishing arguments based on T 1177/97, the Board held that merely devising an algorithm for automated translation is not enough to show technical considerations beyond programming a conventional computer.
– Applicatioin field: The practical field is machine translation and automated processing of natural language.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was assessed under the COMVIK distinction between technical computer implementation and non-technical linguistic functionality.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed for lack of inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Google LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0003/08, T 1177/97, T 0598/14, T 2825/19
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0183/21; 2023-9-29; Controlling the performance of a recommender system/BRITISH TELECOMMUNICATIONS

TECHNOLOGY: #Artificial_Intelligence_and_Machine_Learning #Model_Training
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Reduced_Data_Transfer #Reduced_Data_Storage_Requirements
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Digital_Commerce_and_Content_Distribution
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Clarity_of_Claims
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention adaptively controls the type and amount of training data fed through a communications network to a recommender system, based on measured recommendation performance and a target level.
– Technical effect at issue: The Board expressly recognised lower network-bandwidth consumption and smaller storage requirements within the communications system as technical effects. The controlled training-data volume achieves these effects on average across substantially the whole claim scope.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A client/recommender communications system supplies the technical context; the Board specifically connected the adaptive training-control mechanism to network and storage resource usage.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The distinguishing feedback-control steps were not derivable from the prior art cited; the Board found the independent claims inventive, also noting the clarity of the corresponding control-parameter claim.
– Applicatioin field: The recommender can serve product selection and video-on-demand catalogue recommendations; the broader application is digital content distribution and commerce.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step in view of D1 and claim clarity under Article 84 EPC were examined; dependent claims had not been assessed.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the application remitted for further prosecution because dependent claims remained unexamined; there was no immediate order to grant.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: British Telecommunications public limited company
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 111(1), 84
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (yes); Appeal decision – remittal to the department of first instance (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1869/08, T 0306/10, G 0001/19
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1768/20; 2023-7-3; Characterization of standard cells/RACYICS

TECHNOLOGY: #Simulation_CAD_and_Engineering_Design #Chip_Design
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Semiconductor_Design
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A computer-based design tool simulates standard cells under process, voltage, temperature and body-bias conditions and stores the resulting characterisation in a library file for subsequent chip design.
– Technical effect at issue: Calculated physical/design data did not establish a further technical effect under G 1/19. The claim did not use the model to control manufacturing; the stored library data required further human decisions and processing before possible fabrication.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The Board regarded the claim as computer-implemented rather than a mental act as such, but its simulation output was merely calculated information absent an implied technical use.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The distinguishing algorithmic/design steps lacked a further technical contribution; storing the data in a conventional library file was routine. The Board construed the exceptional-case language in G 1/19 narrowly, requiring a result whose intended use produces a technical effect without further human intervention.
– Applicatioin field: The invention concerns electronic design automation and semiconductor standard-cell characterisation.
– Decisive legal issue: The key question was inventive step for computer-implemented simulation/design under G 1/19; the Board also considered admission of revised requests under the RPBA.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because all requests lacked inventive step.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
see reasons 4.7 for exceptional cases in the sense of points 98 and 128 of G 1/19

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Racyics GmbH
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 12(4), 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Amendment after summons – exceptional circumstances – main request (yes); Amended claims filed with the statement of grounds of appeal – first and second auxiliary requests – admitted; Inventive step – all requests (no)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19, T 0641/00, T 0914/02, T 0154/04, T 1227/05
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1756/20; 2022-12-12; Proximity touch/SONY

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Touch_and_Gesture_Control
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Consumer_Electronics_and_Appliances
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention provides a touch-screen display with proximity detection and controlled presentation of thumbnail images.
– Technical effect at issue: A proximity-touch gesture is accepted only if the finger or stylus remains within a set distance for a specified duration. This prevents accidental activation, reduces unnecessary display operations and associated power use, and avoids UI interference while the user approaches the screen.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed interaction between proximity sensing, a timer and display control has an identifiable technical effect on physical user input and device operation.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): D1 did not disclose or suggest the time-and-distance condition for first recognising the proximity gesture. The Board found claim 1 inventive over D1.
– Applicatioin field: The invention concerns interactive displays on mobile terminals and other consumer electronics.
– Decisive legal issue: The deciding issue was inventive step of the proximity-triggered display-control feature under Article 56 EPC.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted with the express order to grant a patent in the specified version.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Sony Group Corporation
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (yes)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0992/20; 2025-11-19; Textes aléatoires/SHORT EDITION

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Information_Presentation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Interactive_Text_Printing_and_Kiosks
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention concerns an interactive printing kiosk which selects a literary text in response to the user pressing an interface zone. Its distinguishing feature is the unpredictable selection of printed content, not an improved printing mechanism.
– Technical effect at issue: The random choice of literary content, repeated selection of different texts, and incremental numbering address subjective user appeal or administrative queue management. The Board found no objective technical effect attributable to these differences.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claim is directed to a tangible kiosk comprising an interface, printer and electronic controller, so technical character is established for the claim as a whole; this does not make the distinguishing selection rules technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The random-content selection criteria and serial numbering are non-technical requirements under COMVIK. Their implementation on the known kiosk of D1 did not require inventive technical measures; no claimed QR-code or effective queue-control mechanism altered that assessment.
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns the interactive, on-demand printing of literary texts at a physical kiosk, for which a new, more specific application-field tag has been added.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC was decisive for the main and first auxiliary requests. A further auxiliary request filed during oral proceedings was not admitted under Article 13(2) RPBA 2020 because no exceptional circumstances were shown.
– Outcome: The Board dismissed the appeal; neither admitted request involved an inventive step and the late-filed further request was excluded.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Short Edition
LEGAL PROVISIONS: CBE Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Activité inventive – (non)
AI-TRANSLATED-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0002/83, T 0225/84, T 0456/90, T 0641/00, T 0633/07, T 1025/08, T 0306/10, T 2469/12
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1392/20; 2025-7-15; User device configured to function as PoS terminal/HILLOA

TECHNOLOGY: #Financial_Transaction_and_Payment_Technologies #Currency_Conversion_and_Payment_Terminals
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Data_Communication
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Mobile_Payments_and_Contactless_Transactions
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed payment architecture remotely configures a user device, including a secure element, to operate as the merchant’s point-of-sale terminal and to process a card transaction.
– Technical effect at issue: Merchant-specific PoS provisioning and direct communication between the user device and payment service host provide an alternative transaction architecture. The Board expressly did not accept an additional security advantage over D4, which already protected card data from the merchant.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed secure payment device, host, configuration and message routing constitute technical system features.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board recognised the host/device provisioning and direct processing arrangement as a specific technical solution, not merely business rules to be implemented. The prior art did not render the alternative architecture obvious.
– Applicatioin field: The subject matter is online payment processing using a user device as a merchant’s PoS terminal.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was the substantive issue. The amended request was admitted under Article 13(2) RPBA 2020 owing to exceptional circumstances arising from unclear first-instance reasoning and objections addressed at oral proceedings.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted with an order to grant on the amended claims, with the description and drawings to be adapted.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: HILLOA LIMITED
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – configuring a user device to act as a merchant’s PoS terminal (yes – non-obvious alternative)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1463/11, T 1749/14
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1199/20; 2024-7-11; Medical information service/ACTX

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Data_Structures
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Healthcare_and_Medical
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed cloud-like medical information service organises biomedical and genomic information into a conceptual data structure and retrieves information responsive to queries.
– Technical effect at issue: The asserted medical purpose was not established across the claim’s breadth, which also covered administrative medical information. Generic changes in storage consumption or query-processing speed did not establish a technical effect of the claimed conceptual data model.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed computer system and virtual servers supply technical character to the claim as a whole; the cognitive organisation of biomedical information does not automatically inherit that character.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Unlike functional search indexes or executable data structures, the relationships between biomedical data types provided no demonstrated technical functionality. Their implementation constituted obvious automation of non-technical information modelling requirements.
– Applicatioin field: The application involves biomedical/genomic information retrieval in a medical-information service.
– Decisive legal issue: Article 56 EPC was decisive for the admitted requests. Under Article 12(6) RPBA 2020 the Board also declined to admit requests the examining division had legitimately refused to admit.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because the admitted claims lacked inventive step and the remaining auxiliary requests were not admitted.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: ACTX, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 12(6)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – data structure defining different types of biomedical data and their relationships (no – non-technical organisation of cognitive data)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0049/99, T 1153/02, T 1351/04, T 1159/15, T 1227/05, T 1954/08
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1637/20; 2024-5-7; Displaying inventory instructions on electronic price labels/MariElla

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Information_Presentation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Retail_Inventory_and_Electronic_Shelf_Labelling
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: An electronic shelf-label system displays stocktaking instructions by changing display colours or switching indication lights on and off.
– Technical effect at issue: The displayed inventory prompts conveyed administrative instructions, and their visual form was a subjective presentation choice. The claimed display and optional static directions did not technically ensure reliable inventory counting or navigation.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Electronic labels, a base station and a computer system are technical means, although the inventory content displayed on them is not a technical contribution.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Using known electronic price labels to convey stocktaking tasks was a business requirement that the skilled person would implement with conventional data links, LEDs and display functions. The first auxiliary request likewise relied on generic devices and non-technical directions.
– Applicatioin field: The application specifically concerns retail inventory management through electronic shelf labels; a dedicated application-field tag has been added.
– Decisive legal issue: The main and auxiliary requests were assessed for inventive step under Article 56 EPC, in particular through the COMVIK distinction between inventory instructions and technical implementation.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because neither the main request nor the first auxiliary request involved an inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: MariElla Labels Oy
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – use of electronic price labels for displaying inventory instructions (no – non-technical)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 1670/07
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1203/20; 2024-1-25

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Databases
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Parcel_Locker_and_Delivery_Systems
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Clarity_of_Claims #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Clarity_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed post/parcel locker system uses a database to track compartment reservations and availability, and receives location-based reservation requests. Known sensors could detect whether a parcel was deposited.
– Technical effect at issue: Time-limited reservation rules and conditional release of lockers implement an administrative scheme; the alleged greater efficiency was not substantiated by the claims. Automatic location determination from an IP address was a known, obvious alternative to manual location entry.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A locker system with sensors, terminal and reservation database has technical character as a whole, irrespective of the non-technical reservation policies.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board treated reservation duration and status rules as non-technical constraints, which known equipment could implement without invention. The auxiliary request’s IP-based positioning was likewise an obvious technical implementation choice.
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns reservation and utilisation of parcel lockers, not package labelling or traceability; a specific application-field tag has been added.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step failed for the main, first and fourth auxiliary requests; the third auxiliary request lacked clarity under Article 84 EPC. A late second auxiliary request specifying a light-beam sensor was not admitted under Articles 13(1) and 13(2) RPBA 2020.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed. The unsuccessful requests failed for lack of inventive step or clarity, with a further auxiliary request not admitted.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Integer.pl S.A.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 84; RPBA 2020 Art. 13(1), 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main, first and fourth auxiliary requests (no) – obvious implementation of non-technical scheme; Claims – clarity – third auxiliary request (no); Late-filed auxiliary request – admitted (no) – no exceptional circumstances and against procedural economy
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1587/20; 2023-12-6; Ledger protocol to incentivise commerce/LOYYAL HOLDINGS

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Blockchain
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The system awards digital tokens for commercial or user behaviour and records incentive events and token transactions in a distributed public ledger.
– Technical effect at issue: Incentivising conduct and documenting rewards were business purposes. The alleged ability to recover physical-product history was not derivable from the claim, which did not define the necessary stored product-history data.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The servers, networked terminals, digital wallet and distributed ledger give the system technical character as a computer-implemented invention.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The rewards logic and ledger-record rules were non-technical as such. Technical implementation through conventional terminals and an existing distributed ledger was obvious; the Board explicitly confirmed this COMVIK distinction.
– Applicatioin field: The claimed incentive and loyalty programme operates in commercial administration and reward transactions.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive issue was inventive step under Article 56 EPC. Clarity concerns were noted but were not the ground on which the Board disposed of the appeal.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed for lack of inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Loyyal Holdings Incorporated
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – rewarding a user’s desired behaviour and recording the rewards on a public ledger (no – not technical)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0336/07, T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1395/20; 2023-11-7; Personal indicator/LANNG

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Graphical_User_Interfaces
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Financial_Markets_and_Trading
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Added_Subject_Matter #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Added_Matter_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A multidimensional criteria grid is used to define and back-test personal indicators, disclosed as trading strategies for buying and selling financial instruments.
– Technical effect at issue: The criteria grid facilitates selection of non-technical trading criteria and timeframes. The Board found no assistance with a technical task or other technical effect beyond ordinary graphical interface design.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed computer implementation and user interface make the overall subject matter technical, but the selection of trading rules does not constitute a technical task.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Trading criteria and back-testing are financial decisions. Their representation and selection in a conventional criteria grid could not supply an inventive technical contribution; the cited image-search interface case was distinguished.
– Applicatioin field: The specific activity is stock-market trading and strategy back-testing, motivating a dedicated financial-trading application-field tag.
– Decisive legal issue: The Board confirmed lack of inventive step and an unallowable generalisation under Article 123(2) EPC. It also upheld non-admission of an auxiliary request and could not consider a further ambiguously defined request.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed. In particular, the main request lacked inventive step and contained added matter; auxiliary requests did not overcome the deficiencies or were inadmissible.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Lanng, Soren
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 123(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – criteria grid for entering criteria in a user interface – assisting the user in performing a technical task (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0643/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1468/20; 2023-7-6; Extracting flight data/SKYSCANNER

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Web_Technologies
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Reduced_Data_Transfer
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #Transportation_and_Travel
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A browser-executed script scrapes flight prices from rendered web pages, while servers aggregate, store and serve the collected transport price data.
– Technical effect at issue: Moving price extraction to the browser can reduce transmissions between merchant and browser, as the Board acknowledged. However, that advantage was one familiar trade-off of where to perform extraction; a price-confidence threshold based on independent IP addresses represented a non-technical business rule.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Client-side scripts, IP-based data collection and server/database operations are technical implementation features of the claim.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The web-scraping implementation and pattern matching were known alternatives within the skilled web programmer’s repertoire and therefore obvious. The business rule of accepting only prices observed from sufficiently many users made no independent technical contribution.
– Applicatioin field: The application deals with aggregation of flight and other scheduled transport pricing for travel searches.
– Decisive legal issue: The Board rejected the main and all auxiliary requests for lack of inventive step under Article 56 EPC, including requests directed to pattern matching, delayed script loading and publication of trusted prices.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed for lack of inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Skyscanner Limited
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – extracting price data from a web page using a linked script that includes pattern matching instructions (no – obvious) – disregarding prices which were not offered to a sufficient number of different users (no – not technical) – using IP addresses to distinguish those users’ devices (no – obvious)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1589/20; 2022-11-23; Selection of content with tap/hold/release gesture /EBAY

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Touch_and_Gesture_Control
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Digital_Commerce_and_Content_Distribution
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed mobile touchscreen interface successively displays selectable content while the user holds a touch position and fixes a selection when the hold is released.
– Technical effect at issue: The combined tap/hold/release interaction and sequential display allow content to be selected more quickly and easily, particularly on a small screen, without remembering a distinct gesture for each item.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The Board expressly held that the defined gesture and display response amount to technical human-machine interaction assisting the user in the technical task of selecting display content.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The interface features b) and c) were technical and not suggested by D1 or D5; they supported inventive step. Stored shipping-address information, by contrast, was merely administrative.
– Applicatioin field: The embodiment is a mobile content-selection interface used in a digital commerce/payment environment.
– Decisive legal issue: The Board’s decisive analysis concerned inventive step over the cited gesture-based payment and interface prior art, under Article 56 EPC.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted with an order to grant a patent on the specified claims, description and drawings.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: eBay Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (yes)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1108/20; 2022-10-11; Closed-circuit e-commerce entity for services and products/Elbex Video

TECHNOLOGY: #Software_and_Computer_Architecture #Computer_Performance
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Processing_Efficiency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Digital_Commerce_and_Content_Distribution
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed closed-circuit e-commerce architecture supports networked kiosks and ordering through an interface equipped with its own CPU and memory.
– Technical effect at issue: Locating additional processing and storage at the kiosk interface reduces the processing burden on the central server and enables support for many kiosks without overwhelming it.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claim contains concrete network, server, CPU and memory arrangements, rather than merely the commercial purpose of controlled ordering.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board recognised the extra CPU and file-storing memory in the interface as distinguishing technical features solving the objective problem of scaling kiosk support. No cited prior art suggested this solution; inventive step was acknowledged.
– Applicatioin field: The architecture is used to offer goods and services through closed-circuit electronic commerce terminals.
– Decisive legal issue: The inventive-step analysis under Article 56 EPC, including the extra interface processing resources, was decisive; the Board also found the claims novel and supported.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted with an order to grant on claims 1 to 24 filed on 7 September 2022 and the originally published description and drawings.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Elbex Video Ltd.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – after amendment
CITED DECISIONS: T 0011/82
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0035/20; 2024-5-17; Double press to pay/APPLE

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Human_Computer_Interaction
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Mobile_Payments_and_Contactless_Transactions
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention concerns a smartphone payment interface combining a timed double press of a physical home button with its integrated fingerprint sensor to activate NFC payment directly from the lock screen (Reasons 1-2).
– Technical effect at issue: The relevant effect is a technically implemented simplification of fingerprint-authenticated payment. The Board did not accept enhanced security as an additional inventive technical effect (Reasons 13-15).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claim uses a smartphone, an input mechanism with a fingerprint sensor and short-range payment radio; technical character was not in doubt.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The combined double-press and fingerprint-sensing interaction required technical considerations beyond a mere user requirement or input-to-function mapping and was held non-obvious (Reasons 8-19).
– Applicatioin field: Contactless mobile payments authenticated biometrically are the concrete application; the existing fields do not precisely capture that transaction setting.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC turned on the boundary between non-technical user requirements and a technically devised input arrangement.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted with an order to grant on the basis of the first auxiliary request (Order).

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
The term “user requirement” is often used when assessing the technicality of features of user interfaces. The Board understands the term to refer to needs and preferences defined by the end user of a system, who does not possess any technical understanding of the system. Under the Comvik approach (T 641/00 – Two identities/COMVIK), such user requirements may appear in the formulation of the technical problem as they do not make any technical contribution. It was confirmed in T 1463/11 – Universal merchant platform/CardinalCommerce that non-technical (user) requirements cannot normally specify any technical matter or be based on technical considerations. That is not to say that they cannot refer to the underlying technical system at all. Just like the technically skilled person, the user starts from the technical system of the prior art; user requirements do not appear in a vacuum. Thus, if the user uses software on a computer, he may formulate non-technical requirements relating to this software (see e.g. T 2019/12 – Angabe einer Order/Lacqua). Analogously, if, as in the present case, the system is a mobile phone, the user may formulate requirements relating to the use of the phone, as long as they do not involve technical considerations or require technical understanding. (See point 8 of the reasons)

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Apple Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – double press on button with integrated fingerprint sensor to pay with phone – (yes – not a mere user requirement)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 1188/04, T 1463/11, T 2019/12
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 3124/19; 2023-12-12; Automatic association of medical elements/CAREFUSION

TECHNOLOGY: #Navigation_and_Positioning_Technologies #Real_Time_Location_Systems
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Reliable_RFID_Based_Medication_Selection
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Healthcare_and_Medical
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Added_Subject_Matter #Patent_Eligible_Subject_Matter
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A real-time locating system associates patients, medical devices and medications, with selection on the medical device where multiple medications are detected in the same physical space (Reasons 1, 5.2-5.3).
– Technical effect at issue: The claimed interface enables the caregiver to select the correct medication among multiple RFID-detected items, preserving the medication-administration checks in that situation (Reasons 5.4-5.5).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed RTLS, processor, medical device and user interface form a technical medical system; computer implementation is not merely incidental.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The relevant selection arrangement solved a technical problem not addressed or suggested by the closest prior art D2, and inventive step was acknowledged. The claim was also amended to remedy an intermediate generalisation (Reasons 4, 5).
– Applicatioin field: The system is specifically directed to safe hospital medication administration and medical-device operation.
– Decisive legal issue: The Board examined inventive step, added subject-matter under Article 123(2) EPC, and the therapeutic-method exclusion under Article 53(c) EPC; the selection step was held not to constitute a method of therapy (Reasons 4-6).
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted with an order to grant the amended claims (Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Carefusion 303 Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(1), 53(c), 56, 97(1), 111(1), 123(2); RPBA 2020 Art. 13(1), 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Exceptions to patentability – method for treatment by therapy (no); Amendment to appeal case – amendment overcomes issues raised (yes); Amendments – intermediate generalisation – after amendment (no); Inventive step – after amendment – (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/07
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2718/19; 2023-9-1

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Data_Structures
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Education_and_E_Learning
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed knowledge units, knowledge chains, curriculum data and learner-achievement data form a computer-based pedagogical scheme (Reasons 2.3-2.4).
– Technical effect at issue: Beyond routine database storage and automation, the claim did not establish any further technical effect or particular technical solution (Reasons 2.5-2.6).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Technical character of the overall claimed computer system was expressly not questioned (Reasons 2.1).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The differentiating didactic rules are non-technical and could be implemented routinely on a conventional computer with a database; the knowledge-chain structure was not a technical contribution (Reasons 2.4-2.8).
– Applicatioin field: The claimed service is e-learning and personalised education, not a technical teaching system merely by being labelled Edutech.
– Decisive legal issue: Article 56 EPC and the COMVIK assessment of pedagogical mental acts versus technical implementation were decisive.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because claim 1 lacked an inventive step (Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Knowre Korea Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 12(8)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no) – mixture of technical and non-technical features
CITED DECISIONS: T 0336/14
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0926/20; 2023-3-21; Mobile location-based task assignment/AR CHECK

TECHNOLOGY: #Navigation_and_Positioning_Technologies #Location_Based_Services
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Reduced_Data_Transfer
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The service assigns jobs based on the mobile user location, the user profile, and location-related task profiles, using standard mobile devices and a server (Reasons 4-5).
– Technical effect at issue: Reduced network traffic from sequential task offers was alleged, but the Board characterised any such saving as a bonus effect inherent to administrative task assignment rather than a technical solution (Reasons 7-10).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Conventional server/mobile-device infrastructure provides technical character, while location-and-time-based administrative rules do not.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Profile-based staff assignment, acceptance and further instruction were managerial requirements; their allocation to familiar devices and software was routine (Reasons 5-6, 11-13).
– Applicatioin field: The real-world use is workforce and task administration through a mobile location-based service.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step hinged on the lack of a distinct technical contribution under the COMVIK approach.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed for lack of inventive step (Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: AR Check GmbH & Co. KG
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – assigning tasks based on user location and profiles (no – non-technical)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 1082/13
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2852/19; 2023-1-26

TECHNOLOGY: #Navigation_and_Positioning_Technologies #Location_Based_Services
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Reduced_Data_Transfer
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Event_Ticketing_and_Attendance
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed system monitors GPS locations and variable-radius areas before an event to prompt non-arriving ticket holders and enable resale of unused seats (Reasons 3-4.4).
– Technical effect at issue: The Board acknowledged technical effects such as network-traffic reduction and optimisation of seating occupancy in the known GPS-based system, but found no additional technical effect from the claimed differences over D1; increased resale profit was non-technical (Reasons 4.5.1-4.5.5).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Location monitoring by GPS and mobile communication make the system technical overall.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Adjusting the area radius as event time approaches was obvious from continuous arrival-time monitoring, while prompting cancellation and reselling seats followed commercial requirements (Reasons 4.6-4.8).
– Applicatioin field: The concrete field is managing event attendance and ticket resale.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC was assessed by distinguishing technical GPS monitoring from business rules for ticket redistribution.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed for lack of inventive step (Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Stubhub Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(2)(c), 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 15(3)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Patentable invention – technical and non-technical features – method for doing business; Inventive step – (no) – problem and solution approach – mixture of technical and non-technical features; Oral proceedings cancelled after withdrawal of request for oral proceedings, decision according to the state of the file
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, G 0001/19, T 0279/05, T 0775/90, T 1175/02, T 0438/06, G 0003/08
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0702/20; 2022-11-7; Sparsely connected neural network/MITSUBISHI

TECHNOLOGY: #Artificial_Intelligence_and_Machine_Learning #Neural_Networks
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Lower_Memory_Usage
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention fixes sparse neural-network connections using an error-correcting-code check matrix, without restriction to a particular technical training task (Reasons 1, 12, 17-18).
– Technical effect at issue: Lower computational and storage requirements were asserted, but a sparse and a fully connected network do not necessarily perform the same task; the comparison did not establish a relevant technical effect (Reasons 13-14).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The computer-implemented apparatus passes the any-hardware threshold under Article 52 EPC; the mathematical network structure considered in isolation is non-technical (Reasons 12-13, 19.1).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Without a specified technical application, an adaptation of computer functioning, or a demonstrated comparable performance effect, the sparse network architecture supplied no contribution supporting inventive step (Reasons 14-21).
– Applicatioin field: The claims concern general-purpose machine-learning computation and unspecified classification or regression tasks.
– Decisive legal issue: The core issue was inventive step for an abstract neural-network architecture, applying the requirement for a technical problem under COMVIK.
– Outcome: The main and auxiliary requests failed for lack of inventive step; the appeal was dismissed (Reasons 19, 22; Order).

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
A neural network defines a class of mathematical functions which, as such, is excluded matter. As for other “non-technical” matter, it can therefore only be considered for the assessment of inventive step when used to solve a technical problem, e.g. when trained with specific data for a specific technical task.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Mitsubishi Electric Corporation
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Amendment after summons – taken into account (yes); Inventive step – (no)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19, T 0641/00, T 0154/04, T 1326/06, T 1294/16, T 1924/17
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0800/20; 2022-10-10; Restricted voucher redemption/MICROTRONIC

TECHNOLOGY: #Financial_Transaction_and_Payment_Technologies #Voucher_Validation_and_Redemption
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Enhanced_Security
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #Vending_and_Retail_Transactions
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Clarity_of_Claims
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Clarity_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A vending machine reads a prepaid voucher containing product identifiers and a particular vending-machine identifier and checks these against locally stored data (Reasons 1-2.5).
– Technical effect at issue: Security improvement was asserted, but the Board expressly left that alleged effect undecided; the technical character of local storage, identifier transfer and comparison was recognised on other grounds (Reasons 2.8-2.10).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A vending machine, voucher reading and local processing provide a technical implementation of a non-technical voucher-redemption restriction.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The restriction to a particular machine and its identifier is an administrative requirement; choices about distributing storage, communication and comparison are technical but obvious for the skilled person (Reasons 2.6-2.12).
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns prepaid vouchers redeemed for physical goods at vending machines.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was decisive across requests; lack of clarity also affected some auxiliary claims (Reasons 2-5).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed; the claims of the relevant requests lacked inventive step and certain auxiliary claims also lacked clarity (Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Microtronic AG
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 84
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – restricting a voucher to one vending machine and setting its validity time (no – business method) – encoding the vending machine identifier and the validity time on the voucher (no – obvious implementation)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 1463/11
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2520/19; 2022-2-2

TECHNOLOGY: #Navigation_and_Positioning_Technologies #Geo_Fencing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Reduced_Notification_Overload
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Added_Subject_Matter
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A mobile device varies recognition of geo-fence crossings depending on how many running applications use geo-fences, delaying recognition closer to the area centre under high load (Reasons 4.3-4.4).
– Technical effect at issue: The technical effect is preventing overload by reducing or spreading geo-fence notifications, even if the problem is encountered only in certain configurations (Reasons 4.5-4.9).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed adaptive processing of geofences changes device operation and is technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The claimed load-sensitive recognition arrangement solved a mobile-device processing problem not suggested by cited prior art (Reasons 4.6-4.10).
– Applicatioin field: This is a general mobile-device geofencing and notification-processing application rather than a specific photographic service.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was the principal issue; the amended claim also overcame the objections under Article 123(2) EPC (Reasons 2-4).
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted with an order to grant (Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: eBay, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 123(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (yes); Amendments – added subject-matter (no)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 3131/19; 2021-4-7; Body movement dependent user interface/PHILIPS

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Touch_and_Gesture_Control
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Consumer_Electronics_and_Appliances
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Added_Subject_Matter #Clarity_of_Claims #Novelty #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A sensor observes a user body part and assigns different control functions to a perceptible user-interface part depending on its approach/displacement rate (Reasons 2, 4.2).
– Technical effect at issue: The technical effect is a flexible control interface in which the same user input element invokes different system-control functions based on sensed body motion (Reasons 4.2-4.3).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Sensors and device-control functionality establish an interaction with the physical environment and technical character.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The claimed context-dependent functionality was not taught or suggested by the cited gesture/motion systems, and novelty and inventive step were recognised (Reasons 4.1-4.3).
– Applicatioin field: The examples include a home-entertainment/media system and a coffee machine, hence consumer devices and appliances.
– Decisive legal issue: The Board accepted the amendments and clarity and then found novelty and inventive step (Reasons 2-4).
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted with an order to grant after adaptation of description and figures (Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Koninklijke Philips N.V.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 54, 56, 84, 123(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Amendments – allowable (yes); Claims – clarity – main request (yes); Novelty – main request (yes); Inventive step – main request (yes)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2825/19; 2021-3-19; Natural language to machine language translator/RAVENFLOW

TECHNOLOGY: #Artificial_Intelligence_and_Machine_Learning #Natural_Language_Processing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Patent_Eligible_Subject_Matter
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A natural-language input is transformed into an internal formal language and then into executable expressions such as SQL for external operational environments; the claim does not require machine learning (Reasons 5.3-5.4).
– Technical effect at issue: The Board identified no further technical effect or hardware-specific consideration beyond abstract translation and programming algorithms (Reasons 5.3.3-5.5).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Use of a conventional computer provides technical character to the claim as a whole, although abstract algorithm design does not contribute to it.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Under the Board’s reading of G 3/08, mere programming, reusability or translating natural language into commands does not constitute further technical considerations; implementation was routine over D4 (Reasons 5.3-5.8).
– Applicatioin field: The claimed natural-language programming interface is generic, not tied to a particular technical sector.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step depended on the technical contribution of computer-program features and the distinction between abstract algorithmic and further technical considerations.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed for lack of inventive step (Order).

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
Assessment of technicality of programs for computers: “further technical considerations” in the sense of opinion G 3/08

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Ravenflow, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0003/08, G 0001/19, G 0003/19, T 0236/91, T 0769/92, T 1173/97, T 1177/97, T 0641/00, T 0154/04, T 1539/09, T 0598/14
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0928/19; 2024-3-14; Load distribution/NOKIA

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Distributed_Computing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Adaptive_Load_Redistribution_After_Server_Changes
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Additional_Prior_Art_Search
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claims concern hash-range partitioning and coordinated redistribution of lookup entries among active front-end servers in a distributed database architecture.
– Technical effect at issue: Recalculation and dissemination of a partitioning table redistribute routing workload when the population of active servers changes (Reasons 1-2.1 and 7).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed cooperation of master, front-end and back-end servers is a technical implementation of distributed database operation; the Board also accepted the amendments addressing essential features (Reasons 4-7.1).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board considered the claimed architecture non-obvious over D1: reaching it would require several unsupported architectural choices rather than a merely possible modification (Reasons 13-18). This is not a final finding against all prior art.
– Applicatioin field: The invention concerns load distribution and request routing in distributed database systems.
– Decisive legal issue: The key issue was inventive step over D1, including the could-would distinction; a possible more pertinent search was expressly left open (Reasons 16-19.1).
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the application remitted for further prosecution, possibly including an additional search; no patent grant was ordered.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Nokia Solutions and Networks Oy
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 111(1); RPBA 2020 Art. 13
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – non-obvious modification; Appeal decision – remittal to the department of first instance (yes)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1483/19; 2023-2-27; card transaction terminal / GOLDMINE WORLD

TECHNOLOGY: #Financial_Transaction_and_Payment_Technologies #Currency_Conversion_and_Payment_Terminals
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed payment terminal uses merchant/customer language interfaces and a currency module to present converted prices in a customer-selected currency.
– Technical effect at issue: The alleged savings in bandwidth and memory were not supported by the application; presenting prices in another currency did not establish a further technical effect (Reasons 19-22).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The physical payment terminal with a processor, memory, reader and displays has technical character, although that does not make its business rules technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Currency selection, price conversion and periodic exchange-rate updates were business requirements or arithmetic operations; their implementation using the existing terminal and server connections was straightforward under COMVIK (Reasons 5-12 and 15-23).
– Applicatioin field: The application relates to point-of-sale payment transactions and currency presentation to customers and merchants.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive question was whether the currency module and further claimed updates made the terminal inventive; all requests failed under Article 56 EPC.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because neither the main request nor any of the three auxiliary requests involved an inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Goldmine World, INC. D/B/A World Bankcard Services
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPÜ Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1049/19; 2022-12-13

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Web_Technologies
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Not_Finally_Determined
APPLICATION FIELD: #Digital_Commerce_and_Content_Distribution
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claims concern logging media impressions and combining demographic information across Internet domains using client computers and company servers.
– Technical effect at issue: For the main and first auxiliary requests, the distributed logging scheme did not produce a further technical effect beyond straightforward digital automation of a business scenario (Reasons 3.1.9-3.4.2 and 4).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Networked client and server computers are technical means and confer technical character on the claimed implementations.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The business features could be used either as constraints in the objective technical problem or as the starting scenario. The main and first auxiliary requests were obvious. Beacon instructions added by the second auxiliary request required an as-yet-unperformed assessment of any further technical effect (Reasons 3.2.2-3.6.5 and 5).
– Applicatioin field: The commercial context is audience measurement, media impression logging and demographic analysis for digital content.
– Decisive legal issue: The decision focuses on COMVIK treatment of business scenarios, the starting point for the problem-solution approach, and the unexamined technical contribution of beacon-based communication.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted for further prosecution of the second auxiliary request; patentability was not finally determined.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
If the claimed non-technical features do not interact with claimed technical features such that they produce a further technical effect, for the assessment of inventive step one may
– either include the corresponding aim to be achieved in a non-technical field in the formulation of the problem as part of the framework of the technical problem that is to be solved,
– or else take the corresponding business scenario as the starting point for the problem and solution approach (see reasons 3.2.2).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: The Nielsen Company (US), LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(1), 52(2)(c), 56, 111(1)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – mixture of technical and non-technical features – closest prior art – skilled person – main request (no) – first auxiliary request (no); Appeal decision – remittal to the department of first instance (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19, G 0003/08, T 0641/00, T 2101/12, T 1463/11, T 0288/19, T 0698/19, T 0524/19
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0225/19; 2022-10-17

TECHNOLOGY: #Automation_Control_and_Embedded_Systems #Sensor_Systems
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Simplified_Spatial_Sensor_Data_Evaluation
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #Additive_Manufacturing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Novelty #Inventive_Step #Reformatio_in_Peius #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Patent_Revoked

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The patent relates to laser-based additive manufacturing, sensor-based melt-pool observation and the association of sensor measurements with scanner coordinates.
– Technical effect at issue: Storing measured sensor values with spatial coordinates makes the measurements easier to evaluate; the particular two- or three-dimensional cognitive display was not shown to produce an additional technical effect (Reasons 13.1-15).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Laser-melt processing, sensor measurement and the coordinate assignment of physical measurements are technical. The presentation of cognitive information alone did not contribute to technical character in this case.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Although coordinate-related storage and assignment were not directly and unambiguously disclosed by E1.3, using the scanner position data for this purpose was obvious to the skilled person (Reasons 7-10 and 16-22, 31-33).
– Applicatioin field: The invention concerns additive manufacturing and quality monitoring of laser-melted three-dimensional parts.
– Decisive legal issue: Novelty was acknowledged, but inventive step was denied. Auxiliary requests VIII-X violated the prohibition of reformatio in peius; auxiliary request XI was admitted but was also obvious (Reasons 23-33).
– Outcome: The appealed interlocutory decision was set aside and the patent revoked because no allowable claim set remained (Reasons 34 and Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: CL Schutzrechtsverwaltungs GmbH; Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
OPPOSING-PARTY: 3D Systems, Inc.; SLM Solutions Group AG
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPÜ Art. 54(1), 56; VOBK Art. 12(4)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Neuheit – Hauptantrag (ja); Erfinderische Tätigkeit – Hauptantrag (nein) – Hilfsantrag XI (nein) – Mischung technischer und nichttechnischer Merkmale; Reformatio in peius – Hilfsanträge VIII, IX und X nicht zulässig; Spät eingereichter Antrag – wäre bereits im erstinstanzlichen Verfahren vorzubringen gewesen (nein)
AI-TRANSLATED-KEYWORDS: Novelty – main request (yes); Inventive step – main request (no) – auxiliary request XI (no) – mixture of technical and non-technical features; Reformatio in peius – auxiliary requests VIII, IX and X inadmissible; Late-filed request – should have been filed in first-instance proceedings (no)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0009/92, G 0001/99, T 0641/00, T 1143/06, T 1741/08, T 1802/13, T 0336/14
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0874/19; 2022-7-6; Classifying resources using a deep network/GOOGLE

TECHNOLOGY: #Artificial_Intelligence_and_Machine_Learning #Classification
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Digital_Commerce_and_Content_Distribution
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed system uses a deep neural network, feature-specific embeddings and category scores to classify online resources, including search-engine spam.
– Technical effect at issue: Neither predicted category scores nor improved representations of online resources established a further technical effect beyond execution on computers (Reasons 8-10 and 14-20).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A deep network implemented on computers has technical character because of the computer implementation, independently of whether its classification goal is technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The differences from D1 concerned mathematical category likelihoods or cognitive classifications; the alleged benefit in spam classification did not provide a technical contribution relevant to inventive step (Reasons 10, 14 and 19-20).
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns categorising digital resources and search-engine spam.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive issue was whether a classification score or feature embedding solved an objective technical problem under Article 56 EPC.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed: the main request and both auxiliary requests lacked inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Google LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main and first to second auxiliary requests (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0872/19, T 1227/05, G 0001/19
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1497/19; 2022-5-18

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Touch_and_Gesture_Control
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #Gaming_and_Entertainment
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claim concerns an electronic gambling system with a touch-screen interface and rules for randomly selecting increased payout odds.
– Technical effect at issue: The touch screen is a technical input-interface choice. The modified game rule and the aim of increasing player excitement do not produce a further technical effect (Reasons 2.2-2.3.3).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The electronic game apparatus has technical character; the Board expressly did not question the technical character of the claim as a whole (Reasons 2.3.2).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The touch screen was an obvious alternative to physical buttons, while randomly enhanced payout odds were a non-technical gaming rule whose routine automation could not establish inventive step.
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns an electronic gambling system and its user input interface.
– Decisive legal issue: The Board exceptionally admitted a request filed after summons, but rejected the claim for lack of inventive step under the COMVIK approach (Reasons 1 and 2).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed despite admission of the amended main request.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Hsu, Tien-Shu
LEGAL PROVISIONS: RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2), 13(1); EPC Art. 84, 123(2), 52(2)(c), 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Amendment after summons – exercise of discretion – taken into account (yes); Inventive step – (no) – obvious alternative – mixture of technical and non-technical features; Patentable invention – rules for playing games
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0447/19; 2022-5-11

TECHNOLOGY: #Software_and_Computer_Architecture #Memory_Management
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Processing_Efficiency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Manufacturing_and_Production_Planning
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Added_Subject_Matter
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention separates a manufacturing test application from a daemon agent that caches electronic assets and records unused assets for later application instances.
– Technical effect at issue: Moving local asset management and usage monitoring to the daemon reduces server overhead and allows cached assets to survive termination of the test application (Reasons 1.3-1.4 and 3.2-3.3).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Software processes, server communication and cache-based management of cryptographic keys and other electronic assets are technical features.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): D1 did not suggest moving key-use monitoring to a daemon, and D3 concerned LDAP caching rather than the claimed asset tracking. The claimed combination was non-obvious (Reasons 3.5-3.8).
– Applicatioin field: The technical context is distributed device manufacturing, provisioning of electronic assets and factory testing.
– Decisive legal issue: The Board accepted the original disclosure basis under Article 123(2) EPC and the inventive step of the independent claims under Article 56 EPC.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted with an express order to grant a patent on the stated application documents.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: BlackBerry Limited
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 123(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Amendments – added subject-matter (no); Inventive step – (yes)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1909/19; 2022-3-10; Confirming identity at locker bank/UPC

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Authentication
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Enhanced_Security
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Packaging_and_Supply_Chain_Traceability
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The method routes unsuccessfully delivered parcels to a locker bank and checks collection authorisation using a mobile device and location-based identity confirmation.
– Technical effect at issue: Secure identity confirmation was alleged, but the claimed location-based validation did not establish a non-obvious technical security improvement over known methods (Reasons 9-9.4).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Logistics servers, electronic lockers, communication devices and identity checks provide a technical implementation.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Selecting an alternative locker was based on business preferences; using a mobile device was obvious. Location-based authentication was known from D11 and would have been applied to the locker system of D1 (Reasons 8-10).
– Applicatioin field: The field is parcel delivery logistics and secure locker-bank collection.
– Decisive legal issue: The key issue was inventive step for non-technical delivery preferences combined with a known form of location-based identity validation. Clarity did not need to be decided (Reasons 3.2 and 10).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because both requests lacked inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: United Parcel Service Of America, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main request (no) – auxiliary request (no)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0288/19; 2022-2-17; notional business person

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Indexing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #Insurance_and_Risk_Management
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The system uses airport-closure information, flight-plan data, geographic distributions and hash-table indexing to trigger automated financial cover for aircraft fleets.
– Technical effect at issue: The insurance thresholds, triggering criteria and payout decisions implement business conditions rather than a further technical effect. Standard hash-table indexing was an obvious technical choice (Reasons 3.5-3.6).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed system uses physical sensing and networked computing means and therefore has technical character, but the business model does not thereby become technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The notional business person could specify insurance-related closure, geographic and timing parameters. The skilled programmer had to implement these constraints, and D1 with common general knowledge made the technical changes obvious (Reasons 3.6.7-3.6.11).
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns insurance risk cover and operational disruption of commercial aviation after natural disasters.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive issue was the COMVIK division of tasks between the notional business person and the technically skilled implementer, including which parameters are fixed by the business model.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because the main and auxiliary requests failed for lack of inventive step.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
The business person sets the framework of the problem to be solved by their business model (insurance conditions) and thus reduces – by setting specific boundary conditions – the degrees of freedom of the skilled computer specialist. The technically skilled person, who has to solve the objective technical problem of implementation, therefore has no latitude in selecting the corresponding (physical) parameters (reasons 3.6.10).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Swiss Reinsurance Company Ltd.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – mixture of technical and non-technical features – skilled person – reformulation of the technical problem – main request (no) – auxiliary request (no)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19, G 0003/08, T 0641/00, T 2079/10, T 1463/11, T 1463/11, T 1632/18, T 2522/16, T 0589/17
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1422/19; 2021-5-19; Content item visibility/GOOGLE

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Web_Technologies
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Indirect_Browser_Viewport_Measurement
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Digital_Commerce_and_Content_Distribution
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Clarity_of_Claims
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The method estimates advertisement visibility by determining a browser window size and subtracting historically measured average dimensions of browser interface elements.
– Technical effect at issue: The method indirectly measures a technically meaningful browser-viewport parameter despite security limitations on direct access from cross-domain iframes (Reasons 4.2-4.5).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Measuring live browser-window properties and processing them to estimate content visibility is technical even though the result is reported to an advertising sponsor.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board held that the prior art did not suggest estimating the viewport by obtaining the outer browser-window dimensions and correcting for browser elements, so the claims were inventive (Reasons 4.6-4.8).
– Applicatioin field: The context is visibility measurement for advertising and other digital content displayed in web browsers.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive points were technicality and inventive step of indirect measurement despite a commercial purpose, and clarity of a browser-brand term in a dependent claim.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted with an explicit order to grant a patent on the specified documents.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Google LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 84
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Claims – clarity (yes); Inventive step – (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19, T 0258/03
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2771/18; 2023-1-11; Content tracking/TETRA LAVAL

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Databases
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Physical_Package_Labelling_and_Traceability
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #Packaging_and_Supply_Chain_Traceability
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claims concern a database that cross-references time-stamped processing and transportation information and uses identifiers on physical packages to retrieve product history.
– Technical effect at issue: Physically labelling packages with identifiers linked to database records provides a technical way to access information about packaged contents. Alleged anti-counterfeiting and safety effects were not supported by the claim.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claim as a whole employs technical means, and the Board expressly characterised physical package labelling as a technical activity (Reasons 2.9).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The package labelling feature contributed technically, but was an obvious adaptation of the known tracking database and standard package-labelling practice (Reasons 2.8-2.10).
– Applicatioin field: The system addresses package identification and traceability during product processing and transport.
– Decisive legal issue: Article 56 EPC was decisive. The Board also declined the requested remittal because it could assess the physical labelling feature itself.
– Outcome: The main and auxiliary requests lacked inventive step; the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Tetra Laval Holdings & Finance S.A.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 111(1); RPBA 2020 Art. 11
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – labelling a package with cross-referenced information from a database (no – obvious); Remittal to the department of first instance – (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 0172/03, G 0010/93
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2745/18; 2022-11-24; Providing a digital asset to two user devices/APPLE

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Distributed_Computing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Digital_Commerce_and_Content_Distribution
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed client-server arrangement supplies a purchased digital asset to an acquisition device and another device associated with a user account.
– Technical effect at issue: Device selection, delivery preferences and queue prioritisation were assessed as commercial requirements or as lacking a credible further technical effect; the remaining implementation was obvious.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Technical character derives from the electronic devices, online repository, servers and electronic asset delivery, rather than the purchasing rules as such.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board treated the business rules as requirements for routine technical implementation. Sending an availability notification was also obvious in view of prior art, while queue prioritisation yielded no relevant further technical effect.
– Applicatioin field: The claimed scheme concerns online purchase and distribution of digital content to multiple user devices.
– Decisive legal issue: The central legal question was inventive step under Article 56 EPC, assessed using the COMVIK approach.
– Outcome: Neither the main nor the auxiliary requests was allowable; the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Apple Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA Art. 12(4)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – providing an assset bought in an online store to a purchasing user device and a further user device (no – business method; obvious implementation)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 2423/10
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2712/18; 2022-11-14; Synchronisation server/APPLE

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Network_Protocols
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Data_Communication
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Additional_Prior_Art_Search
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The system employs a synchronisation server and a messaging protocol to track notifications received and viewed by multiple user devices and remove already-viewed notifications.
– Technical effect at issue: The concrete exchange of status messages between applications, user devices and the synchronisation server constitutes technical communication beyond a business-level requirement to show each notification only once.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The system comprises networked technical devices, and the Board found that its concrete synchronisation architecture and messaging features are technical implementation choices.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Technical contribution was recognised. Those protocol and server features could not simply be attributed to a business person or dismissed as routine implementation; inventive step over pertinent written prior art remained to be examined.
– Applicatioin field: The invention concerns cross-device notification synchronisation in general-purpose networked computing.
– Decisive legal issue: The crucial issue was the proper assessment of technical features for inventive step, requiring examination against written prior art and possibly an additional search.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted for further examination of novelty and inventive step on the basis of the third auxiliary request; no patent grant was ordered.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Apple Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 123(2), 111(1); RPBA Art. 12(4); RPBA 2020 Art. 11
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Technical contribution – distinguishing features of synchronisation server (yes – no mere automation of constraints imposed by business aspects); Remittal to the department of first instance (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 1082/13
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1835/18; 2022-9-7; Integrated product configuration/SIEMENS

TECHNOLOGY: #Simulation_CAD_and_Engineering_Design #Product_Design
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Processing_Efficiency #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Manufacturing_and_Production_Planning
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The computer-implemented scheme integrates product configuration and production-planning tasks by invoking different problem-solving algorithms.
– Technical effect at issue: The asserted improvements in processing efficiency and avoidance of database redundancies or inconsistencies were speculative: no claimed technical implementation details produced these effects.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Using a computer confers technical character on the claimed method as a whole, but abstract configuration and planning constraints are not thereby technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The integration of solver tasks imposed non-technical organisational requirements, with only straightforward implementation on a general-purpose computer (Reasons 10-12).
– Applicatioin field: The described use is industrial product configuration and manufacturing/production planning.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive issue was the absence of an inventive technical contribution under Article 56 EPC, despite asserted algorithmic complexity and efficiency.
– Outcome: The claimed integration did not support inventive step, and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Siemens AG Österreich
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52, 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – product configuration and planning through the integration and execution of various problem-solving algorithms (no – straightforward implementation of non-technical features)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 0258/03, T 0424/03
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2295/18; 2022-7-20; Evaluating real estate/TECNOCASA

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Databases
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Real_Estate_and_Property_Valuation
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The method stores and processes property transaction, geographical and economic information to compute a real-estate valuation.
– Technical effect at issue: Aggregating and standardising valuation inputs did not produce a further technical effect; location information and computational complexity did not make the economic valuation technical.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The use of a networked computer and database establishes technical character for the claimed implementation as a whole.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Real-estate valuation is a non-technical business activity; conventional computing did not add a non-obvious technical contribution.
– Applicatioin field: The claimed application is the economic assessment of real-estate property values.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC was decisive, applying the distinction between technical implementation and economic rules.
– Outcome: The claimed process was an obvious computer implementation of a non-technical evaluation method and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Tecnocasa Franchising S.p.A.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – calculating the value of real estate using a computer – (no – obvious implementation of non-technical process)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1463/11, T 0914/02, T 1670/07
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2660/18; 2021-12-7; Developing rod patterns in nuclear reactors/GLOBAL NUCLEAR FUEL-AMERICAS

TECHNOLOGY: #Simulation_CAD_and_Engineering_Design #Computer_Simulations
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Energy_and_Environment
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention numerically simulates candidate fuel-rod configurations for nuclear reactors and reports violations of calculated operating constraints.
– Technical effect at issue: Unlike the parameter at issue in T 625/11, the output was not sufficiently tied to actual reactor operation, and claimed designs could have non-technical uses. No implied technical effect was established across the full claim scope under G 1/19.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Computer-based simulation provides technical means and hence technical character of the claim as a whole; a simulation output is not automatically a technical contribution.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Neither the abstract simulation result nor the design iterations supplied a non-obvious technical contribution; the requests lacked inventive step in view of the cited prior art and conventional computing.
– Applicatioin field: The claimed scheme concerns nuclear-reactor design and energy technology.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive question was inventive step, particularly whether numerical simulation outputs support a further technical effect as considered in G 1/19.
– Outcome: All requests were refused for lack of inventive step, and the appeal was dismissed.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
In case T 625/11, the board concluded that the determination, as a limit value, of the value of a first operating parameter conferred a technical character to the claim which went beyond the mere interaction between the numerical simulation algorithm and the computer system. The nature of the parameter thus identified was, in fact, “intimately linked to” the operation of a nuclear reactor, independently of whether the parameter was actually used in a nuclear reactor (T 625/11, Reasons 8.4).
The board is of the opinion that, in the case at hand, no technical effect is achieved by the method’s functionality as the method merely produces a test rod pattern (i.e. a fuel bundle configuration) design and data “indicative of limits that were violated by the proposed test rod pattern design during the simulation”.
Contrary to case T 625/11, no parameter is identified that is “intimately linked to” the operation of a nuclear reactor.
A rod pattern design appears to have non-technical uses such as for study purposes. These are “relevant uses other than the use with a technical device”, and therefore a technical effect is not achieved over substantially the whole scope of the claimed invention (G 1/19, points 94 and 95).
The data “indicative of limits that were violated by the proposed test rod pattern design during the simulation” do even not, or at least do not entirely, reflect the physical behaviour of a real system underlying the simulation (see G 1/19, point 128). The board notes that, due to the breadth of the wording of claim 1 of the main request, the obtained rod pattern design might violate any number of limits by an almost unlimited amount.
Hence, this is not an “exceptional case” in which calculated effects can be considered implied technical effects (see decision G 1/19, points 94, 95 and 128).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Global Nuclear Fuel-Americas, LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main, first and second auxiliary requests (no)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19, T 0625/11
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1822/18; 2021-11-24; Augmenting user-input information/ARRIS ENTERPRISES

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Information_Presentation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Gaming_and_Entertainment
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The method links a viewer’s comments to objects appearing in media content by matching the comment-derived metadata with metadata of the primary content.
– Technical effect at issue: The alleged reduction of point-and-click effort and viewer distraction was not a demonstrated technical human-machine interaction effect over the full claim scope. The Board considered the association to enhance informational content.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Technical devices and automatic metadata processing confer technical character on the overall computer-implemented method.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Linking comment metadata with depicted objects implemented a non-technical information-association rule, without a substantiated further technical effect or special hardware considerations.
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns media viewing and user commentary on film or other audiovisual material.
– Decisive legal issue: The main and first auxiliary requests failed inventive step; the second auxiliary request was not admitted under Article 12(4) RPBA 2007.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed after the substantive requests failed and the later-amended second auxiliary request was excluded.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: ARRIS Enterprises LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA Art. 12(4)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main request and first auxiliary request (no); Amended claims filed with the statement of grounds of appeal – second auxiliary request – not admitted
CITED DECISIONS: G 0003/08, G 0001/19, T 1173/97, T 1741/08, T 1834/10
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2263/18; 2021-10-11; Extraction method/FUJITSU

TECHNOLOGY: #Media_and_Signal_Processing #Audio_Processing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Gaming_and_Entertainment
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed extraction identifies types of scenes in sports footage by evaluating sound-volume changes, thresholds and time intervals.
– Technical effect at issue: The Board treated the rule relating spectator noise to scenes of interest as a non-technical heuristic. Signal-level calculations and implementation details were either known or obvious.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Using signal-processing equipment and computers establishes technical character of the claimed method as a whole.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The purported scene-classification logic was a non-technical rule imposed on conventional audio analysis; adding routine averaging did not establish inventive step.
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns analysis and extraction of scenes from sports-event video for media/entertainment use.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was lacking for the main and first auxiliary requests. No exceptional circumstances justified admission of the second auxiliary request after the summons under Article 13(2) RPBA 2020.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed; the late second auxiliary request was not admitted.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: FUJITSU LIMITED
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main request and first auxiliary request (no); Amendment after summons – exceptional circumstances – second auxiliary request (no)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0003/08, T 0641/00, T 0154/04, T 1670/07
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2084/18; 2021-6-18; Suspicious behaviour/AIC

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Information_Presentation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Enhanced_Security #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Healthcare_and_Medical
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The medication-administration confirmation apparatus displays a camera field of view narrower than the area actually captured, in order to influence a user’s behaviour.
– Technical effect at issue: The alleged security or monitoring benefit was not achieved: misleading the user about the camera view did not assist the administration-confirmation system and could undermine it.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The apparatus is technical, but the distinguishing display content is a presentation of information under Article 52(2)(d) EPC.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The changed displayed field of view generated a cognitive reaction rather than a credible further technical effect or continued guided interaction assisting a technical task.
– Applicatioin field: The arrangement is intended for remote monitoring and confirmation of medication administration.
– Decisive legal issue: The crucial question was whether the differing video presentation contributed technically for the assessment of inventive step.
– Outcome: With no technical effect of the distinguishing feature, Article 56 EPC was not satisfied and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: AIC Innovations Group, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 52(2)(d)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no); Features related to presentation of information; Obscuring the internal state of a system
CITED DECISIONS: T 0115/85, T 0833/91, T 1802/13, T 0336/14, T 0556/14, T 1091/17
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2366/18; 2021-3-16; Notification feed across multiple client devices/DROPBOX

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Data_Structures
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Reduced_Data_Transfer #Improved_Processing_Efficiency #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention consolidates notification records by comparing topic identifiers, user/object fields and timestamps before presenting a feed across client devices.
– Technical effect at issue: Claimed bandwidth savings and greater processing efficiency resulted from information-selection rules rather than technical considerations relating to the internal computer system. The claims did not establish the alleged improved synchronisation.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claims use networked computer devices and data structures, and consequently have technical character as a whole.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The claimed record-taxonomy and folding rules did not amount to a further technical contribution under the COMVIK analysis; efficiency assertions did not show hardware-related technical considerations.
– Applicatioin field: The scheme concerns general-purpose multi-device notification feeds and record management.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive issue was inventive step. The third auxiliary request was exceptionally admitted under Article 13(2) RPBA 2020, but it too failed on the merits.
– Outcome: All requests lacked inventive step, so the appeal was dismissed notwithstanding the admission of an amended request.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Dropbox, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2); EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – all requests (no); Amendment after summons – third auxiliary request – exceptional circumstances (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0003/08, T 0003/90, T 0049/99, T 0154/04, T 2330/13, T 1924/17
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1148/18; 2022-12-15; Travel process prediction/THE AQUA ENTERPRISE COMPANY

TECHNOLOGY: #Navigation_and_Positioning_Technologies #Travel_Time_Prediction
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Transportation_and_Travel
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed system statistically predicts travel-process times using passenger checkpoint and transport information. A new travel-time-prediction subgroup is needed: this is not route computation or guidance.
– Technical effect at issue: Greater prediction accuracy or faster statistical calculations did not establish a technical effect, because the predicted times supported travel scheduling rather than the operation of a technical transport system (Reasons 3-10).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claim specifies a general-purpose computer, so the system has technical character as a whole; the statistical method itself is not technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The predictive and explanatory steps are non-technical logistics/statistical requirements. Their functionally claimed implementation on conventional computing means was obvious (Reasons 4-5).
– Applicatioin field: The use case is airport and transportation-process scheduling and traveler advice.
– Decisive legal issue: Article 56 EPC was decisive; neither prediction quality nor a purported self-learning mechanism established an inventive technical contribution.
– Outcome: The main and auxiliary requests failed for lack of inventive step, and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: The Aqua Enterprise Company
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – predicting travel time of transportation (no – not technical)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0983/11, T 0977/17, T 0154/04, T 0641/00, T 1173/97, T 1954/08, T 1670/07
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0658/18; 2022-6-13; Aggregated soft card/MASTERCARD

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Mobile_Communications
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Data_Interoperability
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Additional_Prior_Art_Search #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention provisions a multi-component virtual card through a trusted service manager, issuer servers, mapping data and NFC-enabled mobile devices.
– Technical effect at issue: The provision of linked soft-card components across issuing systems and their use in a combined transaction raised technical interoperability and provisioning issues. The Board did not finally establish inventive merit.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The Board held that the server, mapping-database, application-identifier and aggregated-card features are technical rather than merely business rules (Reasons 2.10-2.12).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The examining division misapplied COMVIK by treating technical implementation features as non-technical or notorious. A technical contribution was recognised for assessment, but inventiveness could not yet be determined without a search.
– Applicatioin field: The relevant practical field is electronic payment and card-based transactions.
– Decisive legal issue: The failure to search and examine potentially distinguishing technical features required an additional prior-art search and further assessment under Article 56 EPC (Reasons 2.12-2.18).
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted for further prosecution, expressly including an additional search; no patent grant was ordered.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: MasterCard International Incorporated
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 111(1); RPBA 2020 Art. 11, 12(2), 12(8)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – mixture of technical and non-technical features; Remittal – special reasons for remittal (technical features were not considered – additional search required); primary object of appeal proceedings to review decision
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 1242/04
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1636/18; 2022-3-3; Estimating departure time/QUALCOMM

TECHNOLOGY: #Navigation_and_Positioning_Technologies #Route_Planning_and_Guidance
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Processing_Efficiency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Transportation_and_Travel
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A wireless calendar application determines whether to calculate travel and departure times and issue a departure reminder depending on current and event locations.
– Technical effect at issue: Saving calculations and energy was asserted, not accepted as an inventive technical effect: it was at most an incidental consequence of a user-preference rule; claimed network-time benefits were speculative (Reasons 2.2-2.9).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The mobile device and network-time retrieval are technical means, giving the claimed subject matter technical character as a whole.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Using network time was an obvious technical choice, and the location-threshold condition reflected non-technical preferences implemented routinely, without an additional technical contribution.
– Applicatioin field: The system is for scheduling departures and travel to calendar appointments.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC, applying COMVIK to technical and non-technical aspects, was dispositive.
– Outcome: All main and auxiliary requests failed under Article 56 EPC and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Qualcomm Incorporated
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – obtaining current time from a network (no – obvious) – estimating travel time only when a current location and an event location differ by more than a threshold (no – not technical)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0258/03, T 1227/05, T 0641/00, G 0003/08, T 1755/10, T 0520/13
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1607/18; 2021-12-21

TECHNOLOGY: #Financial_Transaction_and_Payment_Technologies #Electronic_Cash_Reconciliation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Reduced_Data_Transfer
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: An electronic retail safe counts cash deposits, reports totals electronically and supports early crediting followed by cash-collection reconciliation. A financial-transaction technology group and cash-reconciliation subgroup are more precise than the existing software/network subgroups.
– Technical effect at issue: Lower network load through smaller transmitted totals was alleged, but the Board found that this was not caused by the distinguishing credit-adjustment feature (Reasons 2.4.1-2.4.3).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claim combines technical electronic-safe and communications infrastructure with a commercial settlement process and thus has technical character as a whole.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The sole distinguishing adjustment of credit after verification was a business rule without a technical interaction going beyond routine implementation (Reasons 2.4.3 and 2.5).
– Applicatioin field: The field is retail cash handling, financial reconciliation and early crediting of cash deposits.
– Decisive legal issue: The question was inventive step under Article 56 EPC in a mixed technical/business-method claim.
– Outcome: The claimed difference was obvious as a business reconciliation step and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Brink’s Network, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(1), 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Patentable invention – technical and non-technical features – technical character of the invention – method for doing business; Inventive step – (no)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19, G 0003/08, T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1677/18; 2021-5-3; Polyhedron components 2/SAMSUNG

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Graphical_User_Interfaces
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention organises hierarchical menus as faces of separable, animated three-dimensional polyhedra in a graphical user interface.
– Technical effect at issue: The asserted improvement to continued user interaction by reducing visual clutter was not accepted: menu hierarchy, 3D animation and altered presentation did not achieve a technical effect (Reasons 2-5).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A computer-implemented graphical interface has technical character overall, although the distinguishing GUI presentation is not technical merely because it is displayed.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The different visual effects and arrangement of menus did not solve an objective technical problem and thus did not provide a relevant technical contribution.
– Applicatioin field: This is a general-purpose computer graphical user interface, not a domain-specific control interface.
– Decisive legal issue: Article 56 EPC governed the assessment of whether the GUI changes could support inventive step.
– Outcome: The main and both auxiliary requests were rejected for lack of inventive step; the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1352/18; 2021-3-23; Call routing matrix/AVAYA

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Call_Routing_and_Management
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Data_Communication
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #Telecommunications
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed cross-network service routes incoming calls using a user activity mode, destination address and communication-management directives. A specific call-routing subgroup better describes this than the existing protocol or mobile-communications subgroups.
– Technical effect at issue: The Board accepted a technical effect of more flexible incoming-call handling for multiple subscriptions and formulated a related objective technical problem (Reasons 2.1.3-2.1.4).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed routing and communication network implementation are technical; user-defined profile preferences and the use of multiple subscriptions impose administrative constraints.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The technical adaptation to multiple user addresses was nevertheless obvious over the cited call management system (Reasons 2.1.5 et seq.).
– Applicatioin field: The system is for telecommunications and routing voice calls across networks.
– Decisive legal issue: The main and first auxiliary requests failed for lack of inventive step; a late second auxiliary request was not admitted under Article 13(2) RPBA 2020 because it created a fresh case without justified exceptional circumstances.
– Outcome: No allowable request remained, so the appeal was dismissed; the late-filed request was not examined on its merits.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Avaya Integrated Cabinet Solutions Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main and first auxiliary requests (no): mixed invention (administrative rules defined by a user profile); Admittance of late-filed request – second auxiliary request (no): no exceptional circumstances and fresh case
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 1989/12
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0755/18; 2020-12-11; Semi-automatic answering/3M INNOVATIVE PROPERTIES

TECHNOLOGY: #Artificial_Intelligence_and_Machine_Learning #Model_Training
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention uses concept extraction, user feedback and supervised reinforcement to adjust a system producing medical billing codes.
– Technical effect at issue: More accurate billing codes concern administrative correctness, not a technical effect. Automatically improving the accuracy of a learned non-technical output is likewise not technical without a related technical purpose (Reasons 3.1-3.3; Catchword).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed process runs on computer components and therefore has technical character overall; the medical billing task and its accuracy criteria are non-technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The feedback, inference and reinforcement rules reflect administrative and algorithmic design choices, with no demonstrated technical contribution beyond using a general-purpose computer.
– Applicatioin field: Despite processing medical records, the claimed purpose is medical billing administration rather than medical diagnosis or treatment.
– Decisive legal issue: The dispositive issue was inventive step under Article 56 EPC using the technical/non-technical feature analysis.
– Outcome: The main and auxiliary requests all lacked an inventive step and the appeal was dismissed.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
If neither the output of a machine-learning computer program nor the output’s accuracy contribute to a technical effect, an improvement of the machine achieved automatically through supervised learning to generate a more accurate output is not in itself a technical effect

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: 3M Innovative Properties Company
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – mixture of technical and non-technical features
CITED DECISIONS: G 0003/08, T 0258/97, T 0258/03, T 0756/06, T 2230/10, T 1463/11, T 0817/16, T 0697/17, T 0886/17
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1247/18; 2020-9-4; Search-based application development framework/ORACLE INTERNATIONAL

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Indexing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Processing_Efficiency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed framework crawls transactional enterprise applications, generates and stores searchable indexes and provides query access to the indexed data.
– Technical effect at issue: More efficient searching was advanced as an effect. The Board held the index-creation, index-storage and index-access steps technical, without finally deciding whether the claimed efficiency was inventive (Reasons 5.2-5.5).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The indexing operations contribute to the invention’s technical character; the examining division was wrong to classify them as non-technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Technical contribution was recognised for the indexing features, but a proper inventive-step analysis requires a suitable prior-art starting point and complete feature assessment.
– Applicatioin field: The framework is for searching and using data in enterprise and transactional software applications.
– Decisive legal issue: The refusal lacked a sustainable Article 56 EPC assessment; the Art. 84 objection was overcome after claims were amended (Reasons 4 and 5).
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted for further prosecution; grant and inventive step were not finally determined.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Oracle International Corporation
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 84, 111(1); RPBA 2020 Art. 11
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (decision under appeal provides no suitable basis for assessing inventive step); Remittal to the department of first instance – (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0697/17, T 1924/17
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0509/18; 2020-3-3

TECHNOLOGY: #Media_and_Signal_Processing #Computer_Vision
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Determination_of_Physical_Parameters
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Not_Finally_Determined
APPLICATION FIELD: #Transportation_and_Travel
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Sufficiency_of_Disclosure
OUTCOME: #Insufficiently_Disclosed

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The camera-based driver-monitoring system determines head and eye positions and seeks to classify the driver’s alertness and trigger appropriate warnings.
– Technical effect at issue: Imaging and determining physical head/eye geometry underlie the proposed warning system, but the implementation of the essential classification was insufficiently disclosed; no inventive technical effect was assessed.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed camera, image processing and warning hardware are technical and establish technical character.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): A COMVIK or inventive-step contribution was not finally assessed because the Board decided the case under Article 83 EPC.
– Applicatioin field: The practical application is in-vehicle driver attention monitoring and safety.
– Decisive legal issue: The description did not teach how to construct the inter-point-metric matrix, derive the look-up-table classifier or compare real images to that classifier (Reasons 2).
– Outcome: All requests were insufficiently disclosed under Article 83 EPC, and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: TK Holdings Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 83
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: sufficiency of disclosure (no)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0543/18; 2019-5-9; Internet search from an instant messaging application/OATH

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Information_Presentation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Telecommunications
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The application integrates a search query and shared, inline search results into an instant-messaging user interface.
– Technical effect at issue: The appellant alleged ergonomic benefits, less eye/hand movement and reduced fatigue; the Board found these effects subjective or unsupported and thus not a proven technical human-machine interaction (Reasons 5.4-5.4.2).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The client computers and messaging application are technical means, but the distinguishing placement and content of information were treated as presentation of information as such.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The explicit search command and inline presentation features did not contribute to the solution of a technical problem and could not support inventive step.
– Applicatioin field: The primary setting is instant-messaging communications with integrated Internet searching.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC, including the effect of information presentation under Article 52(2)(d) EPC, was decisive.
– Outcome: The sole claim request lacked an inventive step and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Oath Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 0154/04, T 1296/05, T 1143/06, T 1235/07, T 0862/10, T 2261/10, T 1375/11
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2156/17; 2022-6-10
Detecting suspicious activity using video analysis / NCR Corporation

TECHNOLOGY: #Media_and_Signal_Processing #Video_Processing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Video_Analysis_Reliability #Reduced_Data_Transfer
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #Retail_and_Point_of_Sale_Surveillance
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claims concern automatic interpretation of surveillance video recorded at a point-of-sale terminal, including item tracking, frame analysis and comparison with transaction records.
– Technical effect at issue: Image adjustment for camera autogain contributes to reliable identification of moving items (Reasons, points 17-20); a further auxiliary request invoked transmission of selected video segments to reduce transferred or stored data (points 58-63).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The method uses video cameras and digital image processing and therefore has technical character; the assessment of whether a mismatch is suspicious remains subjective and non-technical (points 31-36).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board treated video processing and automation as technical, but found the claimed implementations obvious in light of general knowledge. Mere comparison of transaction lists and a suspicion score did not add a technical contribution.
– Applicatioin field: The relevant system monitors goods and transactions at retail point-of-sale terminals to flag potentially suspicious cashier activity.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was assessed for the main and auxiliary requests; several amended requests were not admitted under Article 13 RPBA 2020.
– Outcome: All admitted requests failed and the appeal was dismissed; this was not a finding that every image-processing operation lacked technical character.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: NCR Corporation
LEGAL PROVISIONS: RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2), 13(1); EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Amendment after summons – exceptional circumstances (no) – cogent reasons (no); Inventive step – (no) – common general knowledge – mixture of technical and non-technical features
CITED DECISIONS: T 0775/90, T 0732/21, T 1175/02, T 0641/00, G 0001/19, G 0003/08
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1898/17; 2021-10-5
Speech recognition / Vocollect

TECHNOLOGY: #Media_and_Signal_Processing #Speech_Recognition
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Audio_Recognition_Accuracy #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Novelty #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention uses expected spoken responses and acceptance thresholds in an automated speech-recognition system, with inventory picking as an application example.
– Technical effect at issue: Speed and accuracy of speech recognition were asserted as goals, but the distinguishing step of comparing a hypothesis with an expected response and adjusting a threshold was not shown to deliver an additional technical effect over D3 (points 19-23).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Speech recognition as a whole is technical, a point expressly accepted by the Board (point 30). That does not make every change in the mathematical threshold-setting logic technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The distinguishing mathematical operations merely specified an alternative way of using expected-response information; no further technical contribution over the prior art was established.
– Applicatioin field: The application gives warehouse inventory management and voice-guided picking as an example of the practical environment (point 4).
– Decisive legal issue: The main request was novel but failed inventive step. The Board also refused to admit late-filed auxiliary requests that raised fresh issues.
– Outcome: The main request was refused for lack of inventive step and the auxiliary requests were not admitted; the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Vocollect, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 54; RPBA 2020 Art. 13(1), 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Novelty – main request (yes); Inventive step – mixture of technical and non-technical features – main request (no); Amendment to appeal case – amendment gives rise to new objections (yes); Amendment after summons – taken into account (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, G 0001/19
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2594/17; 2021-5-20

TECHNOLOGY: #Simulation_CAD_and_Engineering_Design #Computer_Simulations
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Industrial_Training_and_Welding
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The application concerns the rendering, inspection and apparent testing of three-dimensional virtual weldments, principally in a training setting.
– Technical effect at issue: The Board did not accept a technical effect based on what the virtual-weldment images represented or on their simulated testing: those aspects were cognitive content of the display rather than constraints of a real technical process (points 3.2.3-3.2.11).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed computer-based system has technical character because it uses computer and display hardware; this alone does not give technical weight to its simulation content.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The distinguishing features amounted to implementing non-technical presentation and assessment requirements on an ordinary computer, without a demonstrated specific technical effect.
– Applicatioin field: The disclosed purpose includes virtual welding, weldment inspection and trainee assessment, rather than a simulation linked to an identified real weldment.
– Decisive legal issue: The key issue was inventive step under the COMVIK approach, informed by G 1/19; the late auxiliary request 3a was not admitted despite an exceptional-circumstances analysis.
– Outcome: The requests considered on their merits were found non-inventive, the late request 3a was not admitted, and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Lincoln Global, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 13(1), 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main request and auxiliary requests 1 – 4 (no) – obvious implementation of non-technical features; auxiliary request 3a – exceptional circumstances (yes); auxiliary request 3a – admitted (no) – raises new issues – detrimental to procedural economy
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19, T 0625/11
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2534/17; 2021-5-10
Payment module/RAKUTEN

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Cryptography
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Enhanced_Security
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The case concerns a multi-currency payment module in which electronic-value applications have separate storage areas and encryption keys.
– Technical effect at issue: Protection of application storage through encryption was a potentially technical security measure; the reference-currency conversion rules were economic arrangements, not a technical effect.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A payment module with digital storage, application execution and encryption is a technical apparatus, although the currency-exchange scheme is non-technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The currency-handling rules were treated as requirements given to the skilled person; encrypting the application storage areas using known keys was an obvious technical implementation (notably points 3.11-3.17).
– Applicatioin field: The method is used for cashless payment and conversion between different electronic currencies.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive question was inventive step of a mixed business-and-technical invention under Article 56 EPC.
– Outcome: None of the main or auxiliary requests was inventive and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Rakuten Group, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – converting electronic money via a reference currency (no – not technical) – encrypting apps’ storage areas (no – obvious)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2004/17; 2020-12-10
Zooming on touch screen/APPLE

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Touch_and_Gesture_Control
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed touch-screen interface permits over-zooming of a document during a continuous gesture and zooms back to a predefined maximum when that gesture ends.
– Technical effect at issue: The bounce-back behavior clearly informs the user that the zoom limit has been reached and provides continuous visual feedback during the gesture (point 3.3).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed response of a touch-screen display to physical gesture input has technical character.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board accepted a non-obvious contribution to user-device interaction over the cited prior art; neither D3 nor D2 suggested the claimed gesture-related over-zoom and bounce-back behavior.
– Applicatioin field: The invention concerns viewing and scaling electronic documents on a touch-screen device.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive issue was inventive step of the independent apparatus, method and program claims.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted with an order to grant a patent based on the specified claims, subject to adaptation of the description and figures.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Apple Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (yes)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0490/18; 2020-9-16
Multi-language input with accents on touch screen / Samsung

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Touch_and_Gesture_Control
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Added_Subject_Matter #Clarity_of_Claims
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Added_Matter_Clarity_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The application concerns entering letters and accents or other symbols by consecutive touches and gestures on a touch-sensitive display.
– Technical effect at issue: Gesture recognition and character-entry interaction were at issue, but the claimed variation over known input methods was an obvious modification rather than a demonstrated non-obvious interface advance.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Touch-screen sensing and control of displayed characters establish technical character.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The differences over the prior art were not inventive; other claim versions also failed because of added subject-matter or unclear limitations.
– Applicatioin field: This is a general-purpose multilingual text-entry interface for touch-screen devices.
– Decisive legal issue: The Board examined Article 56 EPC for the main request, with amendments and clarity under Articles 123(2) and 84 EPC decisive for auxiliary requests.
– Outcome: No allowable request remained and the appeal was dismissed for the combination of inventive-step, added-matter and clarity objections.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 123(2), 56, 84
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no) – obvious modification; Amendments – added subject-matter (yes); Claims – clarity – auxiliary request (no)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0161/18; 2020-5-12
Äquivalenter Aortendruck/ARC SEIBERSDORF

TECHNOLOGY: #Artificial_Intelligence_and_Machine_Learning #Neural_Networks #Model_Training
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Determination_of_Physical_Parameters #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Healthcare_and_Medical
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Sufficiency_of_Disclosure #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Insufficient_Disclosure_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The application uses an artificial neural network to derive an aortic-pressure-related quantity in a method for determining cardiac output.
– Technical effect at issue: Determination of a physiological physical parameter is a technical objective, but no specific improvement due to the claimed neural network could be established because its training was not sufficiently disclosed.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed method operates on physical physiological measurements and is technical in context; patentability still requires an enabling description and a relevant inventive contribution.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The neural network was the distinguishing feature, but absent adequate training disclosure it did not establish a particular technical effect supporting an inventive step; the Board also found the approach obvious.
– Applicatioin field: The application is in medical measurement, particularly assessment of cardiovascular parameters.
– Decisive legal issue: The Board rejected the application under Article 83 EPC for insufficient disclosure of neural-network training and also under Article 56 EPC for lack of inventive step.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed. The newly specified outcome tag records both decisive objections more precisely than the generic insufficient-disclosure tag.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
1. Die vorliegende, auf maschinellem Lernen insbesondere im Zusammenhang mit einem künstlichen neuronalen Netz beruhende Erfindung ist nicht ausreichend offenbart, da das erfindungsgemäße Training des künstlichen neuronalen Netzes mangels Offenbarung nicht ausführbar ist.
2. Da sich im vorliegenden Fall das beanspruchte Verfahren vom Stand der Technik nur durch ein künstliches neuronales Netz unterscheidet, dessen Training nicht im Detail offenbart ist, führt die Verwendung des künstlichen neuronalen Netzes nicht zu einem speziellen technischen Effekt, der erfinderische Tätigkeit begründen könnte.

AI-TRANSLATED-HEADNOTE:
1. The present invention, based on machine learning, in particular involving an artificial neural network, is not sufficiently disclosed because, in the absence of an adequate disclosure, the training of the artificial neural network according to the invention cannot be carried out.
2. Since, in the present case, the claimed method differs from the prior art only by an artificial neural network whose training is not disclosed in detail, use of the artificial neural network does not produce a specific technical effect capable of supporting an inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: ARC Seibersdorf Research GmbH
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPÜ Art. 83, 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Ausreichende Offenbarung – Ausführbarkeit (nein); Erfinderische Tätigkeit – (nein)
AI-TRANSLATED-KEYWORDS: Sufficiency of disclosure – enablement (no); Inventive step – (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0696/02
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2327/17; 2020-2-21
Authenticated encryption of audio data/BOSCH

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Cryptography
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Enhanced_Security #Reduced_Latency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #Cybersecurity
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Clarity_of_Claims #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Clarity_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The method encrypts audio using AES cipher feedback mode and adds authentication checks, including checks applied to short audio samples or chunks.
– Technical effect at issue: Checking authenticity before a large stream has been received allows earlier detection of corrupted audio and improves cryptographic security (Reasons, analysis of the main request); low latency was also an express design objective.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Cryptographic processing and authentication of an audio stream are technical operations.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The proposed combination of known encryption and message-authentication techniques was obvious from the cited teachings; recognizing a technical security objective was not sufficient for inventive step.
– Applicatioin field: The principal field is security of encrypted audio communications and streaming.
– Decisive legal issue: The main and some auxiliary requests lacked inventive step, others failed clarity, and one late-filed request was not admitted.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed; the existing combined clarity-and-inventive-step outcome tag captures the main substantive grounds.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Robert Bosch GmbH
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 84; RPBA Art. 12(4), 13(1)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main request (no) – auxiliary requests 1 and 5 (no); Claims – clarity – auxiliary requests 3 and 4 (no); Late-filed auxiliary request 2 – request identical to request not admitted in first instance proceedings
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1924/17; 2019-7-29
Data consistency management/ACCENTURE GLOBAL SERVICES

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Databases
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Processing_Efficiency #Reduced_Latency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Patent_Eligible_Subject_Matter #Additional_Prior_Art_Search
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention manages the consistency of data stored in different kinds of databases and data stores, including relational database systems.
– Technical effect at issue: The Board recognized better system throughput and shorter query response times from managing data across stores with different technical characteristics (points 21-22).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed database architecture and its implemented data-management operations have technical character; the decision also analyzes when mathematical methods are excluded as such under Article 52 EPC.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board found that features dismissed as non-technical by the Examining Division made a genuine technical contribution. It did not finally decide inventive step over a complete prior-art assessment.
– Applicatioin field: The subject matter concerns general database-backed information systems and the handling of consistency across data stores.
– Decisive legal issue: Technicality within the inventive-step assessment and the treatment of mathematical methods were central. The Board also noted that the earlier technicality analysis might have left the search incomplete (point 24).
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the application remitted for further prosecution; the decision did not order that a patent be granted.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Accenture Global Services Limited
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(2)(a), 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – mixture of technical and non-technical features – identification of technical features; Interpretation of Article 52(2)(a) and (3) EPC – mathematical methods as such; Remittal to the department of first instance – (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0003/08, T 0208/84, T 0026/86, T 0107/87, T 1173/97, T 0641/00, T 0258/03, T 0154/04, T 1242/04, T 0279/05, T 0862/05, T 1227/05, T 1569/05, T 0658/06, T 1326/06, T 1500/08, T 0963/09, T 1316/09, T 0309/10, T 0318/10, T 2230/10, T 1965/11, T 0104/12, T 0650/13, T 2330/13, T 0598/14, T 0817/16
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2630/17; 2019-5-28
Feedback on gesture input/APPLE

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Touch_and_Gesture_Control
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claims concern visual feedback during a swipe gesture used to unlock a touch-screen device, including changes in the appearance of interface elements.
– Technical effect at issue: The Board rejected the alleged improvement in user interaction as a technical effect; the changes merely animated an existing unlock gesture in an aesthetically pleasing manner (points 13-14).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The overall unlock method is implemented on a technical touch-screen device, but technical character of the device does not establish technical merit in the visual presentation details.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): No technical effect attributable to the distinguishing graphical features was established, and implementing the requested animation was straightforward.
– Applicatioin field: The claimed interface relates to unlocking and operating a general-purpose mobile computing device.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step of the GUI features under Article 56 EPC, applying COMVIK, was decisive.
– Outcome: The claimed requests lacked inventive step and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Apple Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – mixture of technical and non-technical features (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 0528/07, T 1741/08, T 0336/14
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1615/17; 2022-10-21; Linking place information based on position/RAKUTEN

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Databases
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Photography_and_Geolocation
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed server associates user-supplied facility records by geographical position and related names, stores them under a common identifier, and retrieves place information. The case concerns the organisation of cognitive data rather than an improvement in database technology.
– Technical effect at issue: The alleged correction of inaccurate facility records and improved search results did not establish a further technical effect. Neither GPS-derived coordinates nor potentially fewer subsequent queries made the grouping algorithm technical.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The server, database and mobile-terminal environment confer technical character on the claim as a whole; this does not confer technical character on every data-association rule.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Associating cognitive records under a common facility identifier was treated as a non-technical organisational requirement. Conventional computer storage and processing did not supply an inventive technical contribution.
– Applicatioin field: The system provides geographically based searches for shops, restaurants and other facilities using position information; geolocation is its operative application.
– Decisive legal issue: Article 56 EPC was decisive. The Board applied the COMVIK approach and asked whether the algorithm involved technical considerations about how position data were measured.
– Outcome: The main request and four auxiliary requests lacked inventive step, and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Rakuten Group, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – linking place information based on position (no – non-technical organisation of cognitive data)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19, T 0309/10, T 1798/13, T 1234/17
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1234/17; 2022-3-4; Customization based on physiological data/ADIDAS AG

TECHNOLOGY: #Simulation_CAD_and_Engineering_Design #Product_Design
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #Footwear_and_Sports_Equipment
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention uses acceleration-sensor time series and a model of human physiology to classify gait and select or specify a customised footwear design. The claimed output is design information, not a defined manufacturing operation.
– Technical effect at issue: Measuring acceleration is technical, but simply mapping these measurements to a gait class and then to a shoe design did not establish an additional technical effect. There were no technical details about sensor placement, measurement enhancement or manufacturing control.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed computer-controlled sensor arrangement has technical character; the Board separately assessed the technical contribution of its two mappings.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Sensor-based measurement and its computer implementation are technical, but adding known sensors was obvious. Neither the abstract gait-to-design mapping nor presenting specifications for later manufacture made an inventive technical contribution.
– Applicatioin field: The claimed customisation concerns sporting footwear and equipment, not the provision of medical treatment. A new application-field tag is used because the supplied list has no suitable footwear or sporting-goods field.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC turned on whether algorithms working with measured physical data reflected additional technical considerations.
– Outcome: Neither the main nor the auxiliary request involved an inventive step; the appeal was dismissed.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
However, the question is whether the mere idea of mapping this acceleration data to gait category is technical, involving any technical considerations or having any overall technical effect. This question arises in many inventions that involve mappings and algorithms.
In T 1798/13 (Forecasting the value of a structured financial product/SWISS REINSURANCE COMPANY LTD), points 2.7 to 2.9, the present Board essentially held that it was not enough that an algorithm makes use of a technical quantity in the form of a measured physical parameter (weather data). What matters is whether the algorithm reflects any additional technical considerations about the parameter, such as its measurement. In that case there were none. This was contrasted with T 2079/10 (Steuerung von zellulär aufgebauten Alarmsystemen/SWISSRE) where the invention was seen to lie in the improvement of the measurement technique itself, which involved technical considerations about the sensors and their positions.
Such a situation is conceivable in the present case, if the algorithm were to somehow enhance the input data using considerations of e.g. the placement of the sensors. However, the claim only specifies that the data “includes a time series of acceleration vectors” and that this data is “analyzed”. There are no further details that could constitute technical considerations about the data or the sensors.
(See points 2.11 to 2.13 of the reasons)

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Adidas AG
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – customisation of footwear based on human gait (no – no technical features) – mapping acceleration data to human gait (no – not technical)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1798/13, T 2079/10
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1313/17; 2021-11-9

TECHNOLOGY: #Automation_Control_and_Embedded_Systems #Process_Control
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Physical_Process_Control
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #Textile_Manufacturing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Patent_Revoked

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claims concern statistical processing of measurements from textile production, indexed data, parameter prediction and, in auxiliary request 2, an evaluation module that directly changes machine settings.
– Technical effect at issue: The predicted parameter information was not necessarily used to alter a physical manufacturing process. Even when machine settings were directly changed under auxiliary request 2, the claimed evaluation results were not causally linked to those changes; hence the algorithmic distinctions did not achieve the asserted process-control effect across the claim scope.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Measuring real production parameters, using a computer and changing machine settings are technical activities. The COMVIK assessment nonetheless isolates which distinguishing features actually contribute to a technical effect.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The direct machine-setting change in auxiliary request 2 was a technical distinguishing feature, but routine automation of an operator task and therefore obvious. Indexing, statistical prediction and mere display were not shown to contribute technically to the manufacturing process.
– Applicatioin field: The relevant industrial process is textile manufacture. A dedicated application-field tag is added because the supplied categories do not include industrial or textile production.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC was decisive, with an ancillary dispute over remittal under Article 111(1) EPC and admission of auxiliary request 2 under Article 13(2) RPBA 2020.
– Outcome: The Board refused to remit the case, set aside the opposition division decision and revoked the patent for lack of inventive step. The added outcome tag specifies that revocation.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Uster Technologies AG
OPPOSING-PARTY: Saurer Spinning Solutions GmbH & Co. KG
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 111(1), 100(a); RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Remittal to the department of first instance; Remittal – (no); Inventive step – mixture of technical and non-technical features
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19, J 0006/98, T 0950/10, T 0314/15, T 0641/00, T 1143/06, T 1802/13
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1488/17; 2021-10-12

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Web_Technologies
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Gaming_and_Entertainment
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: An online gaming server keeps lists of registered and ready players and matches players at the same tournament level on demand.
– Technical effect at issue: Greater player scheduling flexibility resulted from changes in tournament rules, not from a technical improvement to the network, server or processor.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A networked gaming system with processors and receivers has technical character, whereas tournament scheduling and advancement rules are rules for playing games.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Known lists, receivers and processors merely implement non-technical game rules. No non-obvious technical implementation or technical advantage was established.
– Applicatioin field: The scheme is intended for online multiplayer video game tournaments.
– Decisive legal issue: Article 56 EPC was decisive. The Board applied the COMVIK approach to game rules excluded as such under Article 52(2)(c) and (3) EPC.
– Outcome: The claimed tournament system lacked inventive step; the auxiliary request for remittal was moot, and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Worldgaming Network LP
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no); Obvious implementation of non-technical features (rules for playing games)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 0258/03
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1453/17; 2021-6-15; Real time broker quality indication/NYSE

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Network_Protocols
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Reduced_Latency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: An electronic trading system intercepts trader-broker messages, uses copies of order, execution and market data to calculate broker-execution quality, and informs traders in real time or near real time.
– Technical effect at issue: Avoiding interference with transmission and providing rapid information were asserted advantages. The claim did not specify positive technical measures reducing latency; near-real-time delivery was treated as a normal result of computer automation.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed electronic trading apparatus is technical as a system, but the financial quality calculation and its reporting are business requirements.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): A conventional message interceptor and calculation module were an obvious implementation of non-technical requirements, including the desire for prompt reporting. The COMVIK approach applies to apparatus claims.
– Applicatioin field: The information supports decisions concerning brokers and financial-market transactions, i.e. a business/administrative application.
– Decisive legal issue: The key issue was inventive step under Article 56 EPC, with the Board rejecting the alleged technical prejudice against intercepting trading communications.
– Outcome: The claims lacked inventive step and the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: NYSE Group, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – providing broker quality indications in real time (no – obvious implementation of non-technical requirement)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, G 0001/19
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1141/17; 2021-4-15; Automatic selection of a marketing script/FRASER

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Network_Protocols
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Reduced_Latency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed computer-telephony arrangement uses ANI and DNIS telephone identifiers, customer records and a modelling score to choose and display a telemarketing script during a call.
– Technical effect at issue: The applicant alleged selection in under seven tenths of a second. The Board considered this a normal, obvious effect of computerising the marketing-selection procedure; no special low-latency implementation was disclosed.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The telephone/computer system has technical character, but customer segmentation and script selection pursue a non-technical marketing objective.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Using familiar ANI/DNIS signalling and databases to implement the business requirements was obvious. No technical contribution beyond routine automation supported inventive step.
– Applicatioin field: The end use is targeted direct marketing and call-centre sales.
– Decisive legal issue: Article 56 EPC required separating the non-technical selection rules from their conventional telephony and database implementation under COMVIK.
– Outcome: The sole remaining request lacked inventive step, so the appeal was dismissed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Fraser, Eileen A.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – using ANI and DNIS to identify the caller and callee (no – obvious implementation of non-technical requirements)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1310/17; 2020-11-11; Anwendungen auf SIM-Karten/TELEKOM

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Mobile_Communications
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Telecommunications
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Patent_Revoked

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The patent concerns over-the-air provisioning and personalisation of applications on SIM cards through a SIM OTA enabler integrated with a mobile network operator.
– Technical effect at issue: An allegedly faster, more efficient and secure process was not established by assigning the server to the network operator. The distinguishing features chiefly reflected administrative choices about service-provider control and the market model.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Mobile networking, SIM cards, servers and application transmission are technical, but the distinctions over D7 were not technical in substance.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Hosting the enabler in the operator network and initiating requests from the user merely implemented administrative requirements, in an obvious manner according to the prior art.
– Applicatioin field: The subject matter is mobile telecommunications and SIM-card service provision.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Articles 52(1) and 56 EPC was decisive; the Board also held that a decision on the written record was permissible under the cited procedural rules.
– Outcome: The opponent succeeded: the appealed decision was set aside and the patent revoked. The supplied outcome list requires an additional revocation tag.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Deutsche Telekom AG
OPPOSING-PARTY: Giesecke+Devrient Mobile Security GmbH
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPÜ Art. 56, 116(1); VOBK 2020 Art. 12(8)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Erfinderische Tätigkeit – (nein): Unterschied betrifft administrative (nicht-technische) Aspekte; Entscheidung im schriftlichen Verfahren – (ja): mündliche Verhandlung nicht erforderlich
AI-TRANSLATED-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no): distinguishing features concern administrative (non-technical) aspects; Decision in written proceedings – (yes): oral proceedings not necessary
CITED DECISIONS: T 0299/86, T 0641/00, T 0060/13
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1505/17; 2020-2-17; Transposition gestures/HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Touch_and_Gesture_Control
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Clarity_of_Claims
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Clarity_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The application lets a user transpose displayed table rows and columns by providing a gesture or control track whose direction selects a transformation.
– Technical effect at issue: Gesture-based input provides a human-machine interaction mechanism, but recognising directional gestures to choose between two table transformations was a well-known and obvious interface implementation.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A display, input device and gesture detection are technical components of the claimed graphical interface.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The user preference for which table transposition to perform was non-technical; using gestures as a technical input method was an obvious alternative to on-screen control icons.
– Applicatioin field: The interface concerns general document/table editing on computing devices.
– Decisive legal issue: The main request and auxiliary request 2 failed for lack of inventive step under Article 56 EPC, while auxiliary requests 1 and 3 failed clarity requirements under Article 84 EPC.
– Outcome: No request was allowable. The appeal was dismissed on both inventive-step and clarity grounds.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 84
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main request and auxiliary request 2 (no); Claims – clarity – auxiliary requests 1 and 3 (no)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1563/17; 2019-5-7; Booting untrusted software

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Secure_Computing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Enhanced_Security
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Cybersecurity
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The device can run unsigned operating systems temporarily during manufacturing while enforcing a stricter product mode and controlling access to sensitive security data.
– Technical effect at issue: Erasing user data outside a protected security block before allowing an unsigned operating system to execute improves protection of sensitive information during insecure booting.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Secure booting, signature verification, restricted access to security data and deliberate data erasure are technical device-security functions.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Although different boot modes and several security measures were individually obvious, erasing unprotected user data before insecure booting provided a specific, non-obvious technical security contribution.
– Applicatioin field: The invention addresses cybersecurity in the manufacture and deployment of secure computing devices.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC was decisive after amendment to the fourth auxiliary request.
– Outcome: The Board set aside the refusal and remitted the application with an order to grant a patent on the fourth auxiliary-request claims, with the description to be adapted.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: BlackBerry Limited
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – after amendment (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 1325/17
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1849/17; 2019-2-12; Search engine with user feedback/PINTEREST

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Search_Engines
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Clarity_of_Claims
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Clarity_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The proposed web-search ranking system uses individual and group user feedback, feature weighting and logistic-regression relevance scores to reorder search results.
– Technical effect at issue: Faster or more efficient search and reduction of user effort were alleged, but the claims did not establish that the feedback-derived ranking reliably achieved these effects. The Board left open whether such a reliably achieved benefit could be technical.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The implemented search engine is a technical computer system, although the particular mathematical relevance model was not shown to contribute technically.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Without a credible, reproducible technical effect, the feedback and mathematical model did not count toward inventive step; the remaining conventional implementation was obvious.
– Applicatioin field: The claims concern general-purpose web search and information retrieval rather than a specific social-network feature.
– Decisive legal issue: The claims failed inventive step under Article 56 EPC 1973, and auxiliary request 2 additionally lacked clarity under Article 84 EPC 1973 as explained in the reasons.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed; the combination of lack of inventive step and a clarity objection is reflected in the outcome tag.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Pinterest, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC 1973 Art. 56, 113(1); EPC 1973 R. 68(1), 68(2); RPBA Art. 11
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Clarity – auxiliary request 2 (no); Alleged technical effect not established; Inventive step – all requests (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 0643/00, T 1205/12, T 0575/15
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0803/17; 2022-6-21

TECHNOLOGY: #Simulation_CAD_and_Engineering_Design #Physical_Modelling
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Patient_Specific_Adaptation_of_Surgical_Planning_Data
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Healthcare_and_Medical
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Admissibility_of_Opposition #Reformatio_in_Peius #Novelty #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Patent_Maintained_As_Granted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed computer-assisted surgical planning method uses a statistical shape model that incorporates both variable patient anatomy and surgical planning data; it is not characterised as an AI or neural-network invention.
– Technical effect at issue: Instantiating that model adapts surgical planning information, such as implant orientation and dimensions, to the patient’s anatomy. The Board held that the approach was inventive even if the objective problem were merely to provide an alternative model to E1 (Reasons 8.2-8.6).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed computer-implemented modelling of real anatomical structures has technical character; an exclusion under Article 52 EPC was not disputed in the appeal.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board found that E1 neither disclosed the claimed statistical shape model nor suggested incorporating planning data and associated variation information into it. Novelty and inventive step were upheld (Reasons 6 and 8). The decision did not conduct a separate COMVIK analysis.
– Applicatioin field: The system is used for patient-specific surgical planning, including planning the position and size of an orthopaedic implant.
– Decisive legal issue: Alongside novelty and inventive step, the Board examined the opponent’s identity and the admissibility of the opposition. Its published catchword addresses the prohibition of reformatio in peius and the legal effect of the appealed order (Reasons 3.5-3.9).
– Outcome: The opponent’s appeal was dismissed and the patent remained maintained as granted; the challenge did not succeed on either the procedural or substantive grounds examined.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
The yardstick for determining whether the position of an appellant is, because of its own appeal, worsened in a way which is incompatible with the principle of the prohibition of reformatio in peius is the order of the decision under appeal, in particular the order’s legal effect on the appellant.
If an opposition is considered inadmissible in the appeal proceedings, an appellant whose opposition was rejected in the decision under appeal as unallowable would not be in a worse position than if it had not appealed, as in both cases the patent would be maintained as granted. The legal reasons leading to this result, including whether the opposition is rejected as inadmissible or unallowable, do not fall within the scope of the principle of the prohibition of reformatio in peius (Reasons 3.5).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: KINGS COLLEGE LONDON; Depuy International Limited
OPPOSING-PARTY: Calibre Search Ltd.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC R. 99(2); EPC Art. 106(2), 54, 56; RPBA Art. 12(2), 12(4); RPBA 2020 Art. 12(2), 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Admissibility of appeal – appeal sufficiently substantiated (yes); Admissibility of opposition; Appeal decision – extent of examination – reformatio in peius; Late-filed evidence – submitted shortly before oral proceedings – admitted (no); Novelty – (yes); Inventive step – (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0009/92, T 0384/08, T 1437/15, T 0882/17, T 2117/18, T 0460/19
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0941/17; 2021-8-11

TECHNOLOGY: #Automation_Control_and_Embedded_Systems #Embedded_Software
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Gaming_and_Entertainment
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claims concern linked gaming machines containing clocks, databases, pseudo-random-number generators and comparators to trigger simultaneous winning events without communication with a central server.
– Technical effect at issue: Simultaneous events without a central connection were already achieved in D5. The distinguishing lottery-draw rules and their implementation were not shown to provide a further technical effect; the alleged reusable event-list advantage was not established by the claims (Reasons 3.2-3.8).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed gaming machines contain technical hardware and software, so the claim as a whole is technical. The objection concerned inventive step rather than exclusion under Article 52 EPC.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Choosing a manipulated lottery draw was a non-technical game-design decision, and implementing that choice by known components was obvious to a programmer skilled in gaming devices (Reasons 3.4-3.7).
– Applicatioin field: The machines are intended for gaming and lottery-style entertainment.
– Decisive legal issue: All three claim requests failed the inventive-step test under Article 56 EPC; the auxiliary features were either already disclosed or obvious.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because neither the main request nor either auxiliary request involved an inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Novomatic AG
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – all requests (no)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0568/17; 2020-7-28
Database transactions/OPEN TEXT SOFTWARE

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Databases
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Processing_Efficiency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Novelty #Inventive_Step #Additional_Prior_Art_Search
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention addresses ACID database transactions using an ordered succession of data stores, transaction-specific updates, querying and merging of stored versions.
– Technical effect at issue: The proposed organisation is directed to transaction processing in a database, with efficiency as a technical aim. The Board did not make a final quantitative finding about processing efficiency; it held that D1 did not disclose the claimed transaction mechanism (Reasons 2-3).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Atomic transaction handling and data-store management are concrete computer-system functions. Their technical character was not treated as an Article 52 exclusion issue.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The distinctive database mechanism was novel over D1 and was not rendered obvious by D1, which concerned inverted-index construction rather than transaction support. Inventive step over any other relevant art remained open.
– Applicatioin field: The invention concerns general-purpose transactional database management.
– Decisive legal issue: The Board overturned the novelty reasoning and rejected D1 as an appropriate inventive-step starting point. A potentially incomplete search justified remittal for further examination (Reasons 3-4).
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the application remitted. No order to grant was made; the Examining Division must assess other prior art and whether more searching is needed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Open Text Software GmbH
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 54(1), 54(2), 56, 111(1); RPBA 2020 Art. 11
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Novelty – main request (yes); Inventive step – not rendered obvious by document D1; Remittal to the department of first instance – (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0005/91, G 0001/05, T 0071/99, T 0400/02, T 1033/16, T 2496/17
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1091/17; 2020-6-4
Clinical statistics/PHILIPS

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Information_Presentation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Healthcare_and_Medical
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The software retrieves medically similar images and cases, calculates statistics from associated clinical information and presents them to guide iterative case searches.
– Technical effect at issue: Although faster or more reliable retrieval was alleged, the Board found no credible technical effect from presenting clinical statistics with retrieved cases. Their influence depends on semantic or cognitive interpretation rather than an objective physiological interaction (Reasons 1.7-1.11).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Computer-based retrieval of medical images has technical character as a whole; the contested contribution concerns an information presentation within that system.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Both what is presented and how it is presented can fall within Article 52(2)(d) EPC. The claimed display did not credibly assist a technical task through a continued and guided human-machine interaction, and auxiliary matching features were obvious or ineffective.
– Applicatioin field: The claimed workflow supports clinicians searching databases of medical images and associated cases.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was decisive: the Board found that the distinguishing display of clinical statistics did not contribute a technical effect and the additional limitations did not establish inventiveness.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because the main and all auxiliary requests lacked an inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Koninklijke Philips N.V.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(2)(d), 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no) – mixture of technical and non-technical features; Features relating to presentation of information; Presentation of information in diagnostic tasks
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/04, G 0003/08, T 0643/00, T 1143/06, T 1749/06, T 1235/07, T 1741/08, T 1214/09, T 1562/11, T 0651/12, T 1802/13, T 0336/14, T 0581/14, T 1442/16
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0886/17; 2020-3-6
Displaying review information in priority order/Rakuten

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Search_Engines
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The information-retrieval system searches transaction targets such as products or accommodation and ranks displayed user reviews according to their correspondence with the search condition.
– Technical effect at issue: The alleged lower processing load and targeted memory access were not purposively achieved through technical considerations. Reduced user interaction depended on subjective relevance, and even if assumed technical, reusing the search input would be obvious (Reasons 5.4.1-5.4.2).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A computer-based retrieval and display apparatus is technical as a whole; the ranking and presentation of semantically relevant information are not technical merely because a computer executes them.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Review relevance and the display priority were driven by linguistic and cognitive criteria; storing target and review data in different databases was an obvious implementation choice. No non-obvious technical contribution emerged.
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns commercial searches and evaluations of products or accommodation.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC was decisive. All amended claim sets were admitted, but their ranking, positive-term, use-condition and word-count variants lacked inventive step.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed; none of the five requests resulted in an allowable claim.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Rakuten, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA Art. 13(1), 13(3); RPBA 2020 Art. 13(1)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – all requests (no) – mixture of technical and non-technical features; Late-filed request – amendments after arrangement of oral proceedings – all requests – admitted (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0258/97, T 0641/00, T 1351/04, T 1741/08, T 2045/10, T 2230/10, T 1375/11, T 1802/13, T 0598/14, T 1187/15, T 2227/15, T 0032/16, T 0634/16, T 1442/16, T 1597/16, T 0278/17, T 0697/17
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0677/17; 2020-2-13
Augmented reality, detecting position of apparatus / Sony

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #AR_VR
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Determination_of_Physical_Parameters
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Not_Finally_Determined
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Sufficiency_of_Disclosure
OUTCOME: #Insufficiently_Disclosed

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The application concerns shared augmented-reality displays and detecting a second apparatus from camera imagery to establish its position in a spatial coordinate system.
– Technical effect at issue: The asserted technical function is deriving an apparatus’s physical position or spatial coordinates from an acquired image. The disclosure did not teach reliable detection of an unspecified other apparatus throughout the broad claimed scope (Reasons 1.1-1.13).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Image acquisition, object detection, coordinate calculation and display equipment are technical operations; the decision did not turn on Article 52 EPC.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Inventive-step contribution was not finally determined because the application failed Article 83 EPC. Neither unspecified background differencing nor cited person-detection research and neural-network training enabled recognition of arbitrary unspecified apparatuses.
– Applicatioin field: The claims cover a general augmented-reality information-processing platform for sharing spatially placed virtual content, without limiting it to a particular commercial or gaming use.
– Decisive legal issue: Sufficiency of disclosure was decisive. The Board found that both detection of the other device in a single image and specification of its coordinates lacked enabling teaching across the claim scope.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed: the main request and admitted auxiliary requests failed Article 83 EPC; two other auxiliary requests were not admitted.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Sony Corporation
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 83
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Sufficiency of disclosure – enabling disclosure (no)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1089/17; 2020-2-7
Ambiguous queries on online social networks/FACEBOOK

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Search_Engines
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Social_Networking
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The method transforms ambiguous text entered in an online social network into suggested structured queries referring to social-graph nodes or edges, then offers further queries after user selection.
– Technical effect at issue: The asserted benefit is helping users formulate meaningful searches against graph content. The Board treated the semantics of the queries and results as non-technical and identified no further technical improvement in their generation or display.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claim operates a computer-implemented online social-network database and therefore has technical character as a whole. That alone does not make social-graph semantics a technical contribution.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Manual disambiguation, suggested follow-on queries and web-page presentation were obvious in the light of D5 and routine web functionality; the claimed semantic choices did not produce a non-obvious technical solution.
– Applicatioin field: The invention is directed specifically to online social networking and social-graph search, a field not separately named in the supplied application-field list.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step over the newly introduced D5 was decisive; the Board declined remittal because it could decide the issue fairly within the appeal proceedings (Reasons 4-5 and 13).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because none of the main or five auxiliary requests involved an inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Facebook, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 111(1); RPBA 2020 Art. 11
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Remittal to the department of first instance – (no); Inventive step – all requests (no)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0003/08, T 0641/00, T 0154/04, T 2230/10
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0731/17; 2020-1-15
Object persistence/MICROSOFT TECHNOLOGY LICENSING

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Data_Storage
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Lower_Memory_Usage
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Added_Subject_Matter #Clarity_of_Claims #Sufficiency_of_Disclosure #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention concerns persistent objects in a relational database, using metadata to retrieve a field from a serialised user-defined-type object without fully reconstructing it in the Common Language Runtime.
– Technical effect at issue: Avoiding full object hydration and managed-code invocation reduces the need to allocate memory and reconstruct every field; the Board accepted that this mechanism solved a technical problem (Reasons 2.4 and 5.3).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Direct structural access to persisted database objects involves storage, parsing and runtime mechanisms, rather than a mere abstract information scheme.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board rejected the simplistic view that algorithmic operations and memory effects cannot be technical. It found the general-purpose-network inventive-step objection flawed, but did not decide inventiveness over documents D1-D4.
– Applicatioin field: The invention concerns general-purpose database and object-persistence software.
– Decisive legal issue: The amended claim complied with Articles 123(2), 84 and 83 EPC. A proper inventive-step analysis of the relevant art remained to be carried out on remittal (Reasons 3-7).
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted for further prosecution; grant was not ordered.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Microsoft Technology Licensing, LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 83, 84, 123(2); RPBA 2020 Art. 11, 12(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Amendments – added subject-matter (no); Claims – clarity (yes); Sufficiency of disclosure – (yes); Remittal to the department of first instance – (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/04, T 0641/00, T 0154/04, T 1954/08
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0697/17; 2019-10-17
SQL extensions/MICROSOFT TECHNOLOGY LICENSING

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Databases
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Processing_Efficiency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Patent_Eligible_Subject_Matter #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention concerns SQL UPDATE operations for nested relational-database columns, using a change-descriptor data structure, a parser, a query optimizer and an execution engine.
– Technical effect at issue: Efficient multi-level updates and index maintenance were the technical benefits asserted for the change descriptor. The Board considered the mechanisms relevant to a technical database operation, while leaving their full effects and inventiveness for further examination (Reasons 2.4 and 5.3).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A relational database system, even described functionally and without expressly naming a processor, necessarily uses technical means. The Board expressly rejected exclusion as subject-matter as such under Article 52(2)-(3) EPC (Reasons 3.4-3.7).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The execution algorithm and descriptor participate in physically implemented database update operations and must be assessed for inventive step. The Board recognised their technical contribution but found the first-instance obviousness analysis inadequate.
– Applicatioin field: The system relates to general-purpose relational database management.
– Decisive legal issue: Patent-eligible subject matter and the correct COMVIK/problem-solution evaluation were decisive. A generic computer was not a realistic starting point, and the cited database prior art had not been adequately analysed.
– Outcome: The appealed refusal was set aside and the case remitted for substantive examination; neither novelty nor inventive step was finally decided for all prior art.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Microsoft Technology Licensing, LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(1), 52(2), 52(3), 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Patentable invention – computer implemented invention – technical character of the invention – (yes); Inventive step – mixture of technical and non-technical features – problem and solution approach; Remittal to the department of first instance
CITED DECISIONS: G 0003/08, T 0208/84, T 0107/87, T 0119/88, T 1194/97, T 0049/99, T 0641/00, T 0258/03, T 0424/03, T 0154/04, T 0388/04, T 1242/04, T 1351/04, T 1227/05, T 1569/05, T 0756/06, T 1784/06, T 1025/08, T 1500/08, T 1954/08, T 1003/09, T 1358/09, T 1414/10, T 1902/10, T 2230/10, T 1463/11, T 1965/11, T 2035/11, T 2539/12, T 0650/13, T 2330/13, T 0336/14, T 0489/14, T 0598/14, T 0817/16, T 1924/17
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1125/17; 2019-4-2
Parallelizing computation graphs/AB INITIO

TECHNOLOGY: #Software_and_Computer_Architecture #Parallel_Processing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Clarity_of_Claims #Sufficiency_of_Disclosure #Added_Subject_Matter #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Added_Matter_Clarity_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention transforms serial computation graphs into parallelised graphs with partition, interconnection and gather elements, using determined data-flow characteristics and sometimes user-supplied metadata.
– Technical effect at issue: The alleged speed-up from parallel execution was not attributable to the claimed graph transformation alone. Without a specified parallel execution platform, the promised advantage could fail to occur (Reasons 5.2-5.4 and obiter 6.3-6.6).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Computer-aided program and graph processing can be technical in its implementation, but an equivalent mathematical representation of a computation does not itself establish a further technical effect.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): For the fifth auxiliary request, the transformation merely made information already present in the user’s graph explicit, and did not contribute to an inventive technical solution; known parallel hardware was obvious.
– Applicatioin field: The technology concerns general-purpose computation graph and parallel-program design.
– Decisive legal issue: Different requests failed for missing essential features and insufficiency (Articles 84/83), unsupported added subject matter (Article 123(2)), and lack of inventive step (Article 56).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed. The selected outcome tag summarises the expressly listed clarity, added-matter and inventive-step grounds; insufficiency was an additional ground for the main and first three auxiliary requests.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Ab Initio Technology LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC 1973 Art. 56, 83, 84; EPC Art. 123(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Claims clarity – main and auxiliary requests 1-3 (no); Sufficiency of disclosure main and auxiliary requests 1-3 (no); Amendments added subject-matter – auxiliary requests 3 and 4 (yes); Inventive step auxiliary request 5 (no)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0002/10, T 0288/84, T 0689/90, T 1173/97, T 0641/00, T 1415/07
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2681/16; 2022-3-14

TECHNOLOGY: #Media_and_Signal_Processing #Signal_Analysis
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Determination_of_Physical_Parameters
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Healthcare_and_Medical
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The case concerns processing time-series self-monitored blood-glucose readings into low- and high-glucose risk indices and an aggregated measure of glycaemic variability.
– Technical effect at issue: The Board accepted a credible contribution to monitoring glucose variability and predicting glycaemic events only when the sampling conditions were sufficiently representative. The successful fourth auxiliary request required at least 21 readings over seven days; the broader claims also covered inadequate two-reading samples.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The computer-based monitoring system possesses technical character. The mathematical risk-index calculations, viewed in isolation, do not; their contribution depends on a credible technical purpose throughout the claim scope (G 1/19).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): For the fourth auxiliary request, a statistically credible technical effect was accepted. Replacing averages by maximum low- and high-glucose risk values was not suggested by D5 or the other cited prior art.
– Applicatioin field: The monitored physiological data and risk assessment concern diabetes management.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step turned on whether the asserted technical effect was credible across the claimed scope and whether the specific two-stage aggregation was obvious. Support under Article 84 EPC was also considered.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted with an order to grant on the fourth auxiliary request, subject to adapting the description.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: UNIVERSITY OF VIRGINIA PATENT FOUNDATION
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 84; RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Amendment after summons – taken into account (yes); Claims – support in the description (yes / no); Inventive step – mixture of technical and non-technical features – technical effect credible (yes / no)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2147/16; 2021-9-7

TECHNOLOGY: #Artificial_Intelligence_and_Machine_Learning #Classification
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Processing_Efficiency #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #Telecommunications
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed spam-classification algorithm hashes e-mail metadata, clusters similar messages, weights hash sums and rates the resulting clusters. The decision does not establish that a trained machine-learning model was used.
– Technical effect at issue: Lower computer load and better use of resources were asserted. The alleged additional efficiency of the clustering algorithm was neither specifically substantiated in the disclosure nor reflected in the claims. Server-side filtering in the auxiliary request can reduce resource and network load, but was known.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Execution on mail servers is technical. The classification criteria themselves may remain non-technical, especially where the definition of unwanted mail depends on subjective user preferences.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The main-request algorithm lacked a demonstrated further technical effect beyond normal implementation. The additional server-side implementation was technical but obvious from D5 and D7.
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns filtering and delivery of electronic mail.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under COMVIK required a documented technical effect or specific technical implementation considerations rather than an unsupported assumption of algorithmic optimisation.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed: the main and auxiliary requests failed for lack of inventive step.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
The mere assumption that an algorithm is optimised for the computer hardware and may have a technical contribution is not sufficient. The implementation of an algorithm in a method for filtering spam messages must have a proved further technical effect or specific technical considerations; such further technical effect must be specifically and sufficiently documented in the disclosure of the invention and be reflected in the claim wording; the algorithm must serve a technical purpose.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Kaspersky Lab, ZAO
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no) – effect not made credible within the whole scope of claim – improvement not credible – obvious combination of known features – mixture of technical and non-technical features – problem and solution approach – obvious solution
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19, G 0003/08, T 1741/08, T 1316/09, T 0022/12, T 1849/17, T 1028/06, T 1179/14, T 1028/14, T 0340/14, T 2535/16, T 1670/07, T 1358/09, T 1784/06, T 0258/03, T 0154/04, T 0641/00, German Federal Patent Court (Bundespatentgericht) 20 W (pat) 13/09
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2386/16; 2021-4-27
MALWARE DETECTION USING FILE PREVALENCE TO INFORM AGRESSIVENESS OF BEHAVIORAL HEURISTICS/CA INC

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Secure_Computing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Enhanced_Security
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #Cybersecurity
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The method adjusts behavioural malware-scanning intensity according to the prevalence of a file; files never previously seen receive the highest scrutiny.
– Technical effect at issue: An improvement in malware detection or protection was at issue, but the assumption that singleton files deserve the most aggressive analysis did not reliably establish an improvement over D7.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Analysing, quarantining and screening files for malware are technical computer-security operations, even though the claim terminology was broadly expressed.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The security-oriented implementation has technical content, but the Board found the prevalence-dependent scanning or quarantining known or obvious from D7. The additional singleton-file rule was a heuristic lacking a reliably established improvement.
– Applicatioin field: Cybersecurity is added as an application-field tag because the existing application fields did not specifically cover malware protection.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was assessed for the main request and both auxiliary requests against D7 and common general knowledge. Clarity concerns under Article 84 EPC were also noted.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because none of the requests involved an inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: CA, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 84
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no) – main request and auxiliary requests 1 and 2
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2520/16; 2021-3-23

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Information_Presentation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Healthcare_and_Medical
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention displays and lets a user deform three-dimensional anatomical structures and safety-margin volumes for pre-operative assessment.
– Technical effect at issue: More intuitive planning and graphical interaction were alleged. The Board held that the particular anatomical meaning of the images and the surgeon’s interpretation were cognitive effects, not a demonstrated additional technical effect.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The computer rendering and display apparatus is technical, but the specific information conveyed to the surgeon does not become technical merely because it concerns anatomy.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Known interactive 2D/3D volume rendering was already disclosed in D1. No objectively linked continued or guided interaction assisting a technical task was established by the claim differences.
– Applicatioin field: The application is a medical pre-operative assessment and visualisation tool.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive issue was inventive step: whether the distinguishing cognitive content and manually interpreted visual information could contribute under Article 56 EPC.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed; neither the main request nor the auxiliary claims showed an inventive technical difference over D1.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Edda Technology, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – all requests (no)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2316/16; 2021-2-12

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Databases
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Transportation_and_Travel
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A transport-sector server and database select documents for a user, such as an aircraft pilot, based on qualifications, vehicle, place and time.
– Technical effect at issue: The filtering and updating criteria reflected administrative information requirements. No particular improvement of the underlying client-server system was established beyond normal retrieval and communication.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The method has overall technical character because it uses an interface, database, central storage and communication link; the particular transport information and selection criteria were non-technical requirements.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Implementing those requirements in an ordinary client-server database was routine programming under the COMVIK approach.
– Applicatioin field: The disclosed use case concerns task-relevant information supplied to transport personnel, particularly pilots.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was absent. In addition, several auxiliary requests were not admitted, and other requests lacked the required substantiation in the grounds of appeal.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed; the relevant substantive requests lacked inventive step and the procedural objections prevented reliance on further requests.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Aviovision
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA Art. 12(2), 12(4)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – mixture of technical and non-technical features – main request, auxiliary request 1 (no); Auxiliary requests 0A, 1A, 2A, 3A, 4A, 5A should have been presented in the examination proceedings; Statement of grounds of appeal – reasons set out clearly and concisely – auxiliary requests 0A, 1A to 5 (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0258/03, T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2314/16; 2020-9-7
Distributing rewards by assigning users to partial advertisement display areas/RAKUTEN

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Web_Technologies
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed implementation divides an HTML advertisement image into separately clickable areas and assigns each area to a participant in an affiliate reward scheme.
– Technical effect at issue: The relevant technical aspect is the concrete web-page image-map implementation and its response to user clicks, not the economic distribution of rewards. An alleged reduction in processing load was separately rejected as unverified.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The reward allocation formula and business scheme are non-technical, whereas understanding how HTML image maps and clickable areas work requires technical web-system considerations.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Allocating users to partial image-map areas was part of the technical solution rather than the business-person requirements. The Board found this solution non-obvious despite the prior availability of image maps.
– Applicatioin field: Affiliate advertising and allocation of rewards are business applications.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive question under Article 56 EPC was which claim features could enter the inventive-step assessment as technical features under COMVIK.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside, and the case was remitted to the Examining Division with an order to grant.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
The specification of the business method ended with how to determine the reward distribution ratio. The features of dividing the advertisement display area into partial areas and allocating each partial area to a user such that when the partial area is clicked on the user gets a reward, were based on technical considerations of the web page system. It was not motivated by any business considerations.
…
In order to come up with this idea, one needs to understand how a web site is built, and in particular how an image map works. Thus, this feature cannot be part of the non-technical requirements. Instead it is part of the solution that has to be evaluated for obviousness. (See point 2.10 of the reasons)

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Rakuten, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(2)(c), 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Technical effect – reduced computational load (no – technical, but no embodiment to enable verification); Inventive step – distributing rewards by assigning users to partial areas of an advertisement banner (yes – involves technical considerations of the web page system)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 0154/04, T 0258/03, T 0792/92, T 1755/10, G 0003/08, T 1463/11
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2741/16; 2019-11-28
Haptic feedback assisted text manipulation / Immersion

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Haptic_Feedback
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Clarity_of_Claims #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Clarity_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The interface gives distinct tactile responses as a finger moves over dynamically generated text on a touch screen.
– Technical effect at issue: Sliding to select and highlight text provides a technical human-machine interaction benefit, namely more efficient selection of text.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Touch sensing, haptic output and selection/highlighting constitute technical interaction with a computer interface.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The benefit was accepted as technical but the modification was obvious over D2 and known touch-selection techniques in D1.
– Applicatioin field: The invention concerns a general-purpose text-editing and touch-interface device.
– Decisive legal issue: The main request failed inventive step. Auxiliary request 1 was also unclear; late auxiliary request 2 was not admitted because it diverged and was prima facie unclear.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed. The outcome tag captures the substantive clarity and inventive-step objections; non-admission of the late request is noted separately.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Immersion Corporation
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 84; RPBA Art. 13(1), 13(3)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – obvious modification; Late-filed auxiliary requests – admitted (no) – amendments after arrangement of oral proceedings – diverging versions of claims – request clearly allowable (no)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1455/16; 2019-11-20
Image search to obtain shooting spot/RAKUTEN

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Search_Engines
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Photography_and_Geolocation
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention searches images using user-arranged subject types in a virtual frame and returns associated geographic shooting-spot information.
– Technical effect at issue: The asserted reduction of processing load by restricting image-search areas was not credible because searches yielding different results were not comparable and the alleged relation to data volume was not substantiated.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Image retrieval on a networked device is technically implemented, but the desired picture composition and shooting-location information chiefly reflect a user’s non-technical information needs.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Adding location metadata, displaying subject-selection tabs and relaxing image search requirements did not provide a non-obvious technical contribution over the prior-art image database.
– Applicatioin field: Photography and geolocation are added as a specific application-field tag because none of the original field tags directly described searching for camera shooting spots.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was decisive; in particular, the Board rejected an unsubstantiated computational-load advantage and non-technical changes in search preferences.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed after the main and all auxiliary requests failed.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Rakuten, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – all requests (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0154/04, T 1670/07, T 2035/11
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2315/16; 2019-7-5
Validiertes Verfahren/IMC

TECHNOLOGY: #Automation_Control_and_Embedded_Systems #Process_Control
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Healthcare_and_Medical
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The system monitors and documents validated reprocessing procedures for medical devices, checks measurement values and verifies release instructions.
– Technical effect at issue: No additional technical effect beyond conventional computer-assisted monitoring and documentation was established. The prescribed documentation requirements themselves were non-technical.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A computer system interacting with medical-device reprocessing equipment is technical. The Board expressly rejected treating reprocessing itself as a business method, while distinguishing technical reprocessing from non-technical documentation.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The input checks, modules, tolerance values, program selection and machine interface were all ordinary automation measures. The requirement to retain human release approval did not make the automation inventive.
– Applicatioin field: The invention concerns validated medical-device reprocessing, not a diagnostic method.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC was the decisive issue for the main request and three auxiliary requests.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because all requests lacked inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: IMC Systems GmbH
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPÜ Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Erfinderische Tätigkeit – (nein) – Bloße Automatisierung – Mischung technischer und nichttechnischer Merkmale
AI-TRANSLATED-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no) – Mere automation – Mixture of technical and non-technical features
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 0850/06, T 2488/11
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2123/16; 2019-2-5
Audio-content identification/ROVI GUIDES

TECHNOLOGY: #Media_and_Signal_Processing #Audio_Processing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Audio_Recognition_Accuracy
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Gaming_and_Entertainment
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Clarity_of_Claims #Added_Subject_Matter
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Maintain_Patent

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention recognises a song or background audio within a video programme by generating an audio signature from a segment selected with the help of closed-captioning data.
– Technical effect at issue: Using caption information to identify an audio segment with reduced interfering speech or other audio improves the likelihood of correct song recognition. Improved audio recognition accuracy is a newly added technical-effect tag because the supplied list contains no precise equivalent.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Audio capture, signature generation and content recognition are technical signal-processing operations.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board accepted a technical contribution because D1 did not point towards analysing closed-captioning data to choose relatively interference-free audio segments, and the other citations did not render it obvious.
– Applicatioin field: Identifying music or background audio in television and other audiovisual entertainment is the application field.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was the decisive substantive question; the Board also examined amendments under Article 123(2) EPC and clarity under Article 84 EPC.
– Outcome: The revocation decision was set aside, and the case was remitted with an order to maintain the patent in amended form after adaptation of the description and drawings. A new, exact outcome tag is used because an order to maintain is not an order to grant.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Rovi Guides, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 84, 123(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Amendments – added subject-matter (no); Claims – clarity (yes); Inventive step – (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0003/14
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0999/16; 2022-2-4; Wireless communication platform/IQRF

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #IoT
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Telecommunications
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Clarity_of_Claims #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Clarity_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claims concern a radio-frequency communication module with a CPU, separate program memories and interfaces, designed inter alia for home and office automation.
– Technical effect at issue: The alleged advantages of the generic wireless platform were not shown to stem from a distinguishing, non-obvious technical implementation; the board found the relevant module and software arrangements disclosed or routine.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The RF module, processor, memories and communication interfaces are technical means; patent eligibility as such was not the ground of refusal.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Although the implementation includes technical components, connecting an antenna and publishing memory addresses or loading operating-system and application code were either conventional or, for the publication itself, administrative. No inventive technical contribution was established.
– Applicatioin field: The disclosed wireless platform is intended for connected devices and automation, with telecommunications as its underlying technical domain.
– Decisive legal issue: Claim 1 was unclear under Article 84 EPC; the board also held, on its stated interpretation, that the claimed subject-matter lacked inventive step under Article 56 EPC. Requests to postpone oral proceedings were refused.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed. The board independently found lack of clarity and lack of inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: IQRF Tech s.r.o.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 84, 113(1), 116(1); EPC R. 115(2); RPBA 2020 Art. 15(2), 15(3), 15a(1)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Postponement of oral proceedings for a fourth time – (no); Clarity – (no); Inventive step – (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 1246/10, T 0447/13
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0424/16; 2021-6-29

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Human_Computer_Interaction
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Gaming_and_Entertainment
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Clarity_of_Claims #Added_Subject_Matter #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Added_Matter_Clarity_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention concerns control of a simulated aircraft by moving an on-screen indication of desired flight direction with a pointing device, together with simulated flight-control calculations.
– Technical effect at issue: The appellant invoked simplified human-machine control and visual feedback. The board treated the graphical direction selection as non-technical game design, rather than technical feedback about an internal system state. It assessed the modelling steps as potentially technical only for the sake of argument.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The video display, pointing device and computer-based modelling means confer technical character on the system, despite the non-technical aspects of the game rules and user interaction.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The interface choice was considered non-technical game content. Even on the favourable assumption that realistic trajectory modelling was technical, deriving and applying the necessary control-surface adjustments would have been routine, so no inventive technical contribution was shown.
– Applicatioin field: The claimed system is a simulated-aircraft video game, not a system for controlling a real aircraft.
– Decisive legal issue: The board rejected the inventive-step case, identified clarity deficiencies in the claims, and addressed added subject-matter and the non-admission of auxiliary requests.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed: the main and auxiliary requests were either unallowable or not admitted.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Gaijin Entertainment Corporation
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(1), 56, 84, 123(2); RPBA 2020 Art. 13(2), 15(1); RPBA Art. 12(4)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 0928/03, T 0717/05
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1294/16; 2021-3-10; Image data arrangement/OMRON

TECHNOLOGY: #Media_and_Signal_Processing #Image_Processing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests #Referral_to_Enlarged_Board_of_Appeal
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claims concern digital image comparison and template matching using arrangements of pixel colour values in data arrays.
– Technical effect at issue: The asserted faster access from using fewer indices or nested loops was not demonstrated. The number of correlation operations remained unchanged, and read-out speed depended on unspecified software and hardware architecture; no effect was established over the full claim scope.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): An image-processing device and sensor are technical subject-matter, but that alone does not render each mathematical or data-layout distinction relevant to inventive step.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The claimed array transformations failed to establish an additional technical effect in the claimed setting. The remaining processing was known or obvious; mathematically equivalent variants without a credible implementation advantage did not support inventiveness.
– Applicatioin field: The decision addresses image processing in a generally claimed computing arrangement; no narrower industrial deployment is decisive in the reasons.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was decisive for all requests. The board also admitted late-filed requests, considered the allegation of a procedural violation and rejected a proposed referral to the Enlarged Board.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed. All examined claim requests were found to lack inventive step.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
Selection of the “closest prior art”: see point 5.
RPBA 2020 Article 13(1) and (2): see points 15 to 20.
Technical effects: see points 24 to 26 and 35.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: OMRON CORPORATION
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC 1973 Art. 56, 111(1), 112(1)(a), 113(1); EPC 1973 R. 27(1)(c); RPBA 2020 Art. 13(1), 13(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Admittance of late-filed requests under Article 13(1) and (2) RPBA 2020 – (yes); Technical effect of image data arrangement (no) – in the claimed context; Technical effect of difference in mathematics – mathematical equivalents (no) – in the claimed context; Inventive step (no) – all requests; Substantial procedural violation (no); Referral to the Enlarged Board of Appeal (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0939/92, T 1539/09, T 1742/12, T 0405/14, T 0694/15, T 0816/16, T 2135/18
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2040/14; 2021-2-12; Providing prepaid gift cards to devices with or without NFC capability/MasterCard International Incorporated

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Mobile_Communications
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Data_Communication
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The system delivers prepaid card data to mobile telephones, using NFC-capability-dependent over-the-air provisioning or an SMS authorisation code.
– Technical effect at issue: The case turns on the technical architecture and communication path: a telecommunications operations server is queried to determine a recipient device’s NFC capability and selects different provisioning channels.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claims specify servers, mobile devices, NFC and SMS communication; the question was inventive step rather than subject-matter exclusion.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The board recognised an inventive technical implementation: the prior art did not suggest querying the separate telecommunications server for NFC capability or using SMS as claimed for non-NFC recipients, and in relevant respects taught away from that solution.
– Applicatioin field: The commercial purpose is delivery of prepaid payment cards; the decisive implementation relies on mobile telecommunications.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive issue was inventive step under Article 56 EPC, assessed using the COMVIK approach to separate the business goal from its technical implementation.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted with an express order to grant a patent on the identified claims, description and drawings.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: MasterCard International Incorporated
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – querying a dedicated server to determine whether a mobile device is NFC enabled (yes – no hint in prior art)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1503/12
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1159/15; 2020-4-6

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Data_Structures
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Lower_Memory_Usage #Improved_Processing_Efficiency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Additional_Prior_Art_Search #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The modelling/forecasting system employs a multidimensional storage structure with metadata and data layers, hierarchical dimensions and functional aggregation rules.
– Technical effect at issue: The board regarded the specific storage and query arrangement as affecting memory use and data-processing speed, a further technical effect. Whether it improved either metric over the prior art remained to be assessed.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The particular data structure and functional aggregation instructions were technical features, not merely a business information model implemented on a generic computer.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): A contribution to technical character was recognised and could not be treated as notorious general-purpose computing. This is not a finding of inventive step: a prior-art search and substantive assessment were still required.
– Applicatioin field: The forecast models may serve business purposes such as predicting product sales, whereas the contested technical feature concerns data storage and retrieval.
– Decisive legal issue: The absence of a prior-art search despite non-notorious technical features was decisive; an inventive-step examination could not properly be completed on the existing record.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted for further prosecution, expressly including a prior-art search. Grant was not ordered.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Accenture Global Services Limited
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(2)(c), 52(3), 56, 111(1); RPBA 2020 Art. 11, 12(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Mixture of technical and non-technical features; Features – technical (yes) – notorious (no); Prior art search should have been carried out; Remittal to the department of first instance – special reasons for remitting the case (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0425/03, T 1194/97
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0818/16; 2019-9-10; Time series search engine/SPLUNK

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Indexing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Processing_Efficiency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The time-series search engine parses machine-generated logs into timestamped events, assigns events to time buckets and uses bucket-oriented searches.
– Technical effect at issue: Faster retrieval, query pruning and avoiding sorting were invoked. However, the claim did not require time-range pruning, ordered data within buckets or parallel sub-searches, and the board found no relevant additional effect from the claimed sub-search organisation.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Timestamping, data indexing and computer-based searching are technical operations, notwithstanding non-technical requirements regarding result content or order.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Any technical indexing and query-processing measures relied upon were obvious from the prior art and common general knowledge; the alleged additional efficiencies were not established for the claimed scope.
– Applicatioin field: The claims concern generic processing and searching of heterogeneous machine log data, rather than a particular commercial end use.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC was assessed against earlier log-processing systems and ordinary database optimisation techniques.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because the sole claim request lacked inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Splunk Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0003/08, T 0641/00, T 0154/04
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1442/16; 2019-8-30; Cabrera ECG/PHILIPS

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Information_Presentation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Not_Finally_Determined
APPLICATION FIELD: #Healthcare_and_Medical
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Added_Subject_Matter #Additional_Prior_Art_Search
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The application combines measured electrocardiogram signals with multiaxis diagrams, a heart model and, in later requests, patterns and threshold-triggered alerts.
– Technical effect at issue: The board found no credible technical effect for the distinguishing arrangement of the displayed ECG information in the higher-ranking requests. The subsequently claimed alarm based on a computed pattern parameter raised different technical questions that were not finally examined.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The ECG sensors and monitoring equipment are technical; information presentation as such contributes to inventive step only where a credible technical effect is established.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The earlier display-only variants made no inventive technical contribution, but the ultimate auxiliary request included a threshold alarm and its contribution was left for further examination. The classification reflects the surviving request, not the rejected ones.
– Applicatioin field: The purpose is physiological monitoring and interpretation of electrocardiogram measurements.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step and added matter defeated earlier requests. The late amended alarm claim warranted renewed examination and potentially additional searching.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted for further prosecution on the basis of auxiliary request VIa; the board did not order grant.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Philips Intellectual Property & Standards GmbH; Koninklijke Philips N.V.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(2)(d), 56, 123(2), 111(1); RPBA Art. 13(1)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main request and auxiliary requests I, II, III and IVa (no) – mixture of technical and non-technical features; Amendments – auxiliary requests IV, V , VI and Va – added subject-matter (yes); Remittal to the department of first instance – auxiliary request VIa (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 0643/00, T 0928/03, T 0049/04, T 1143/06, T 1741/08, T 0584/10, T 0862/10, T 0407/11, T 1375/11, T 1802/13, T 0336/14, German Federal Court of Justice: BGH, 26 February 2015, X ZR 37/13, GRUR 2015, 660 – Bildstrom
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0817/16; 2019-1-10; Document scoring/GOOGLE

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Search_Engines
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Lower_Memory_Usage
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Not_Finally_Determined
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention scores documents using historical content-change data and stores reduced document signatures or term vectors instead of complete documents.
– Technical effect at issue: Memory savings from reduced representations were argued. The board did not need to decide whether use of term vectors to reduce storage was a technical contribution, because that approach would in any case have been obvious.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The computer implementation gives the method technical character, but an assigned relevance score alone is not a technical effect.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The technicality of the proposed memory-efficient representation was expressly left undecided; even assuming it to be technical, the skilled person would have chosen known term vectors without inventive skill.
– Applicatioin field: The relevant context is computer-implemented web document scoring and information retrieval.
– Decisive legal issue: All claim requests failed the inventive-step test. The speculative reduction in user search queries was also not accepted as a technical effect of the claimed scoring.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed for lack of inventive step in all requests.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Google LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – all requests (no)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0003/08, T 0121/85, T 0107/87, T 0258/97, T 1177/97, T 0258/03, T 1543/06, T 1784/06, T 1741/08, T 1214/09, T 1358/09, T 0042/10, T 0306/10, T 2230/10, T 1321/11, T 1370/11, T 1463/11, T 2035/11, T 2418/12, T 0136/13, T 0650/13, T 2330/13
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1761/14; 2018-11-27

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Authentication
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Enhanced_Security
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The payment authorisation method uses identity checking by a trusted third party to unlock a payment instrument before a remote transaction.
– Technical effect at issue: Fraud protection and transaction security motivated the proposal, but the differentiating third-party involvement and transaction categories were regarded as business or administrative choices, not a demonstrated new technical security mechanism.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claim was abstract enough to raise a subject-matter question; for deciding inventive step the board interpreted it favourably as implemented using the conventional technical means disclosed in the application.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The trusted-third-party arrangement was a non-technical business requirement. Its realisation with familiar servers, databases and networks involved no particular technical difficulty and no inventive technical contribution.
– Applicatioin field: The application addresses financial transactions and payment-card authorisation.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was assessed under Article 56 EPC 1973 using the COMVIK approach for mixed technical and non-technical features.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because the main and auxiliary claims were obvious implementations of altered business concepts.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: F. Poszat HU, L.L.C.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC 1973 Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no) – mixture of technical and non-technical features
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1817/14; 2017-7-4; Expert system/SCHINDLER

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Data_Structures
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The so-called expert system models patent claims and prior-art disclosures through an ANC matrix of elements, facts and relations, which a user can query.
– Technical effect at issue: The asserted special data model and matrix layout were not shown to make subsequent query processing technically better; the modelling represents an intellectual analysis of patent information.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Computer-supported storage, querying and display provide the minimum technical means, while the underlying comparison and structuring of patent teachings are mental or administrative activities.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The distinguishing ANC structure follows from the non-technical information model; the computer support adds only conventional database querying, not an inventive technical implementation.
– Applicatioin field: The intended use is patent administration and assessment of novelty and inventive step, rather than machine-learning inference or control of physical systems.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was decisive. The decision also discusses claim interpretation, clarity, an omitted first-instance ruling on a request and reasons for not remitting.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because all requests lacked inventive step, despite the identified deficiency in the examination decision.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Sigram Schindler Beteiligungsgesellschaft mbH
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 69, 84; EPC R. 111(2), 137(3); RPBA Art. 11
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Fundamental procedural deficiency – yes (non-admitted request not mentioned in the decision); Special reasons for not remitting the case – yes (missing reasons contained in the minutes); Relationship between Articles 69 and 84 EPC; Referral of questions to the Enlarged Board – no; Inventive step – no (all requests)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0860/93, T 0049/99, T 0641/00, T 0556/02, T 0061/03, T 0820/14
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0550/14; 2021-9-14; Catastrophe relief/SWISS RE

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Distributed_Computing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed catastrophe-relief funding system connects computers used by donors, charitable organisations, investors and catastrophe-information providers over a telecommunications network (Reasons 2.7-2.13).
– Technical effect at issue: A payout triggered by parameters such as storm size, wind speed and location is a financial rule, even though it uses real-world data. Neither the trigger definition nor periodic push/pull acquisition established a further technical effect (Reasons 2.10-2.13).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The distributed computer and telecommunications infrastructure gives the claimed subject-matter technical character, independently of the financial model it implements.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The payment roles, funding flows and parametric conditions could be specified by an insurance or business expert; placing their functions on interconnected conventional systems and collecting data routinely did not involve inventive technical considerations (Reasons 2.10-2.14).
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns insurance-related financing and administration of catastrophe relief, rather than technical control of natural disasters.
– Decisive legal issue: The pivotal issue was inventive step under Article 56 EPC and the boundary between non-technical financial constraints and technical implementation. The Catchword also provides guidance on explaining non-technicality.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed. The Board held that the claimed networked implementation of the parametric relief-payout scheme lacked inventive step.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
The appellant’s wish for the Board to define criteria that the examining division should use to prove that a feature is not technical is tantamount to defining the term technical, which the Boards have consistently declined to do. However, as stated in e.g. T 2314/16 – Distributing rewards/RAKUTEN at points 2.6 to 2.8, over the years the case law has provided guidance on the issue of technicality. Recently, the Board has tended to use the framework for discussion given in the CardinalCommerce decision (T 1463/11 – Universal merchant platform/CardinalCommerce) to help classify whether borderline features of a claim are on the technical or the non-technical side.
It is thus clear that some discussion can and ought to take place. However, rather like objections against added subject- matter, one is essentially trying to prove a negative which tends to be a rather short exercise. On the other hand, the appellant is trying to prove a positive which involves more argument. Thus an objection from the division should probably start with a prima facie assertion that the feature in question is non-technical, perhaps because it is in one of the exclusions listed in Article 52(2) EPC, or a related or analogous field. If this is uncontested then this would be enough. However the Board considers that it is then up to the appellant to provide arguments why there is a technical effect or that some technical considerations are involved. The division should consider these arguments and give reasons why they are not convincing. As mentioned above, the Board is satisfied that this happened in the present case.
One final piece of advice for examining divisions would be where possible to search for and start from a document that already discloses some of the alleged non-technical features, thus avoiding the discussion for these features (see for example, T 756/06 – Displaying a schedule/FUJITSU, point 5 or T 368/05 – Integrated account/CITIBANK, point 8).
(See points 3.3 to 3.5 of the reasons)

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Swiss Reinsurance Company Ltd.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – parametric triggering of payments (no – not technical)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0141/87, T 0099/89, T 0986/96, T 0641/00, T 0368/05, T 0756/06, T 1463/11, T 1749/14, T 2314/16
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0552/14; 2021-1-12; Queue message/TICKETMASTER

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Network_Protocols
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The method processes a request queue on a server, estimates future resource availability and sends a notification to a user terminal over a network (Reasons 1.1, 4.1).
– Technical effect at issue: A more efficient administrative queue is not a technical effect; any reduction in actual queuing depends on the user deciding whether to remain. This intervening human choice breaks the alleged causal chain (Reasons 2.1-2.4).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The Board expressly accepted that computer implementation confers technical character overall, but not that the claimed queue-organisation scheme supplies a further technical effect (Reason 2.5).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The queue policy is a non-technical requirement, and receiving requests, estimating availability and transmitting notifications in a conventional client-server system is routine implementation (Reason 4.1).
– Applicatioin field: The system manages customer requests for scarce commercial resources such as tickets to events.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was dispositive; although the Board discussed novelty and the idea of technical novelty, it expressly declined to decide that issue (Reasons 3.6, 4.1).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed for lack of inventive step, not on the unresolved question whether non-technical differences can establish novelty.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Ticketmaster
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 54(1), 54(2), 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – making queuing more efficient (no – not technical)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0002/88, G 0003/08, T 0641/00, T 0172/03, T 0049/04, T 0154/04, T 1543/06, T 1670/07, T 1143/06, T 1562/11
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0886/14; 2020-11-16; Lottery game/Al-Ziyoud, Aiman H.

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Distributed_Computing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Reduced_Latency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Gaming_and_Entertainment
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A central lottery server receives orders from remote clients, updates a progressive jackpot and forwards the updated value for presentation to players (Reasons 2.1-2.2).
– Technical effect at issue: Reduced transmission latency and avoidance of redundant updates were asserted by the applicant, but the Board rejected them as further technical effects: immediate jackpot notification was a game rule and the claim gave no specific implementation (Reasons 2.4-2.5).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A networked server-client implementation is technical, although the rules for playing the lottery are non-technical under Article 52(2)(c) and (3) EPC (Reason 2.3).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The jackpot update and notification requirements belong in the non-technical COMVIK task. Implementing them using a conventional server, remote clients, forms and messages was obvious (Reasons 2.6-2.9).
– Applicatioin field: The claimed scheme operates a progressive-jackpot lottery game.
– Decisive legal issue: Article 56 EPC was decisive: the debate concerned whether alleged real-time delivery and asymmetrical data paths went beyond implementing prescribed lottery rules.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed. The claimed latency benefit was considered and rejected, rather than established as an inventive technical effect.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Al-Ziyoud, Aiman H.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – implementing progressive jackpot lottery game (no – obvious implementation of non-technical game rules)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 0258/03, T 0172/03
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1749/14; 2020-4-3; MOBILE PERSONAL POINT-OF-SALE TERMINAL/MAXIM

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Authentication
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Enhanced_Security
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Additional_Prior_Art_Search
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A personalised customer mobile POS terminal separates merchant-side and customer-side equipment, stores dedicated encryption keys and changes how sensitive transaction information reaches a verification entity (Reasons 3-4).
– Technical effect at issue: The technical changes prevent the merchant terminal from accessing customer account data and bind the customer-side POS attachment to a particular phone. The Board recognised an improvement in the security of sensitive financial information (Reasons 3-6).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed hardware and communications protocol are technical; the modifications go beyond the abstract aim of keeping customer PIN and account information away from the merchant (Reasons 4-5).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): A real technical contribution was recognised because new devices, infrastructure and a changed transaction protocol were required, not a straightforward one-to-one implementation of a business idea. Final inventiveness against all relevant prior art remained open (Reasons 5, 8).
– Applicatioin field: The invention concerns security for customer-operated mobile point-of-sale payment transactions.
– Decisive legal issue: Technical contribution to inventive step was central, but additional prior-art search or examination could be necessary because the previous search may have omitted features treated as non-technical. Clarity/completeness of essential features was also flagged (Reasons 8-9).
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted for further prosecution; the Board did not order grant or finally find an inventive step.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
The notional business person might come up with the abstract idea of avoiding the customer having to provide PIN and account information to the merchant. The invention however requires a new infrastructure, new devices and a new protocol involving technical considerations linked to modified devices and their capabilities as well as security relevant modifications of the transfer of sensitive information using new possibilities achieved by the modifications to the previously known mobile POS infrastructure. This goes beyond what the notional business person knows and concerns technical implementation details (how to implement) which are more than a straight-forward 1:1 programming of an abstract business idea. (See point 5 of the reasons) This is in the sphere of the technical expert and subject to the assessment of inventive step (see T 1082/13).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Maxim Integrated Products, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 111(1)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – personalized mobile POS terminal – distinguishing features provide for a technical contribution – no mere automation of constraints imposed by business related aspects – structural and functional modifications of the closest prior art required; Remittal to the department of first instance – (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1463/11, T 1082/13
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1031/14; 2019-12-3; Electronic vouchers/I-MOVO

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Data_Structures
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The e-voucher scheme processes a concatenated string carrying a voucher number, terminal identifier, issuer identifier and value using existing POS transaction equipment (Reasons 1, 2.3-2.4).
– Technical effect at issue: The claimed string fields convey cognitive business information rather than functional data that change the way the machine operates. Digit length and automated string entry supplied no unexpected further technical effect (Reasons 2.4, 2.7).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Because the method uses standard POS terminals with storage, processing and communications means, the Board expressly found technical character under Article 52(1) EPC (Reason 2.1).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The voucher structure and validation sequence defined an administrative scheme, while using known POS infrastructure and ordinary programming to implement it was obvious under COMVIK (Reasons 2.3-2.7).
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns electronic voucher issuance, redemption and payment authorisation in retail commerce.
– Decisive legal issue: The dispositive issue was inventive step under Article 56 EPC, especially the claimed distinction between cognitive and functional data in transaction strings.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because no request provided a non-obvious technical contribution (Reasons 2.10, 4-5).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: I-Movo Limited
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – cash voucher string comprising a non-cash value related number, issuer id and a pos id (no – cognitive data)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1194/97, T 0641/00, T 0258/03
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0737/14; 2019-7-9; Authorisation system / SECOREN

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Access_Control
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Enhanced_Security
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The financial transaction system authorises an access terminal or agent using terminal identification, rather than merely authenticating an individual customer (Reasons 2.2-2.6, 3.3).
– Technical effect at issue: Fraud prevention and authorisation were raised as security concerns, but in the claimed pre-paid card business scenario the third party must identify a trustworthy agent. That choice followed from allocation of financial risk, not from a new technical security mechanism (Reasons 3.4, 4.1-4.3).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The access terminal, card reader and server infrastructure are technical means, even though the chosen party to be authorised is defined by the financial arrangement.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board criticised an unexplained reliance on vague business constraints, then reconstructed the actual business model. With those constraints in the COMVIK problem, terminal-based authorisation and a card reader were obvious implementations (Reasons 2.6, 4.2-4.5).
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns prepaid-card funding, trusted agents, third-party financial guarantees and transaction authorisation.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC turned on a complete and accurate formulation of non-technical business requirements in the objective technical problem.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed for lack of inventive step, notwithstanding the Board’s criticism of part of the examining division’s reasoning.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
The proper application of the COMVIK approach requires a thorough analysis of the business constraints when formulating the problem to be solved before investigating what the skilled person would have done to solve it. The failure to reflect all aspects of the business method in the problem to be solved led the examining division to argue unconvincingly that the inconvenient distinguishing feature of authorising the access terminal was an alternative whose choice was governed by unspecified business constraints (see reasons 4.2).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Secoren Limited
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – authorisation of the access terminal rather than the user – (no – part of the business scenario)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 1463/11
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1386/14; 2019-6-12; Fraud resistant biometric financial transaction / EYELOCK LLC

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Authentication
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Enhanced_Security
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Biometric_Authentication
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Clarity_of_Claims #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Clarity_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The application combines biometric matching and a liveness-related probability to authenticate financial transactions, using existing multibiometric system concepts (Reasons 19-28).
– Technical effect at issue: More reliable authentication and resistance to spoofing were the stated objectives. However, the claims did not define a technical way to measure liveness; specifying that criterion and combining probabilities did not supply a technical distinction over D8 (Reasons 21, 25-30).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Biometric sensing and computerised matching provide a technical setting, but financial authorisation criteria and purely mathematical score combination are not themselves an inventive technical contribution.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): For the fourth auxiliary request, the selected liveness criterion was non-technical and the score fusion was mathematical; no technical distinguishing feature remained. Earlier requests suffered from contradictions or ambiguity over the meaning and range of decision parameter D (Reasons 1-18, 28-31).
– Applicatioin field: The application uses biometric identity verification for fraud-resistant financial transactions.
– Decisive legal issue: Both clarity under Article 84 EPC and inventive step under Article 56 EPC were decisive for different claim requests: the main and first three auxiliaries failed clarity, and the later auxiliaries lacked inventive step.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed. The decision rested on a combination of clarity objections and lack of inventive step, rather than a uniform inventive-step ground for every request.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: EYELOCK LLC; Hoyos, Hector T.; Hanna, Keith
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC 1973 Art. 56, 84
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – mixture of technical and non-technical features; Claims – clarity (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0119/11
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1559/14; 2019-1-11; Processing search information/EBAY

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Graphical_User_Interfaces
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The search-result GUI changes the relative sizes of a results area and a browsing-options area according to the number of found items and a threshold (Reasons 3.1-3.3).
– Technical effect at issue: Adaptive presentation on a limited display was examined, but the positioning and emphasis of GUI areas were presentation-of-information choices, not a proven further technical HCI effect. Claimed thresholds were not limited to technical display parameters (Reason 3.4).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Generating and transmitting a GUI to a client machine has technical character; the Board also accepted that GUI implementation may involve genuine user-computer interaction aspects in other cases (Reason 3.4).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Counting results, applying thresholds and presenting page-navigation options involved ordinary technical implementation known for web search results. The remaining layout distinctions were non-technical or obvious, so any technical contribution was not inventive (Reasons 3.4-3.5, 7-8).
– Applicatioin field: The method is used for searching and browsing items in an electronic commerce marketplace.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive issue was inventive step under Article 56 EPC, with the analysis separating display implementation from non-technical choices about what to emphasise.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because the main and auxiliary GUI claims lacked inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: eBay Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no) – mixture of technical and non-technical features
CITED DECISIONS: T 0505/13
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0790/14; 2018-1-12; Programming language construct/MATHWORKS

TECHNOLOGY: #Software_and_Computer_Architecture #Parallel_Processing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Reduced_Data_Transfer
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed execution method uses a parallel-programming construct (SPMD) and programmer-specified input/output variables to transfer data between sequential and parallel execution contexts (Reasons 1, 2.1-2.3).
– Technical effect at issue: Reduced transfers and resource efficiency were alleged. The Board found the reduction dependent on a programmer selecting variables, while methods executing different programs could not establish the claimed like-for-like technical effect (Reasons 2.4-2.10). The tag Reduced_Data_Transfer has been added to describe this precise effect at issue, not an accepted effect.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Computer execution takes place in a technical context, but the definition, syntax and operational semantics of a programming-language construct do not by themselves contribute to technical character (Reasons 2.1-2.3).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The claimed execution merely carries out the programmer’s data-flow choices; the alleged saving was not attributable to a non-obvious technical execution mechanism (Reasons 2.8-2.11).
– Applicatioin field: The application relates to general-purpose parallel software programming and execution.
– Decisive legal issue: The Board decided inventive step under Article 56 EPC, even though the appealed examining-division decision had also cited added matter and clarity objections (Summary I; Reasons 2).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because the claimed language-construct execution method did not involve an inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: The MathWorks, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0423/11, T 1539/09
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0489/14; 2021-11-26; Pedestrian simulation/BENTLEY SYSTEMS

TECHNOLOGY: #Simulation_CAD_and_Engineering_Design #Computer_Simulations
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Building_and_Construction
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Admissibility_of_Late_Filed_Requests
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claims concern computer-implemented modelling of pedestrian movement, with variants involving building design and measured input data.
– Technical effect at issue: The simulated trajectories were calculated information with several possible, including non-technical, uses. No qualifying direct or necessarily implied technical effect was established; higher simulation accuracy alone was insufficient (Reasons 2 and 7).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A computer-implemented method employs technical means and is not excluded as such, but that threshold does not establish inventive step.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Applying G 1/19, the Board found no technical contribution from the simulation or human-controlled design revision. Even assuming technical pedestrian measurements, the measurement and simulation features did not interact to produce a combined technical effect.
– Applicatioin field: The disclosure addresses simulated pedestrian circulation in modelled environments, particularly building structures, without confining the claims to a real-world technical use.
– Decisive legal issue: Article 56 EPC governed the admitted requests; the Board separately assessed the admission of later auxiliary requests under the RPBA.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed. The main and admitted auxiliary requests lacked inventive step, while the ninth to eleventh auxiliary requests were not admitted.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
Application of decision G 1/19 to
– simulation methods (Reasons, point 2)
– design methods (Reasons, point 4)
– measurement methods (Reasons, point 7)

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Bentley Systems (UK) Limited
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56; RPBA Art. 12(4), 13(1), 13(3); RPBA 2020 Art. 25(2), 25(3)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main request, first to fifth, seventh and eighth auxiliary requests (no); Late-filed request – ninth, tenth and eleventh auxiliary requests (not admitted)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19, T 0154/04, T 1083/16, T 1892/17
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2251/13; 2021-4-13; Projection surface with built-in track pad/ORDAMO

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Touch_and_Gesture_Control
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: An interactive food-and-drink ordering arrangement combines a projected image on a tabletop or comparable surface with an integrated touch-sensitive track pad.
– Technical effect at issue: Building the track pad into the projection surface changes the physical input interface used for computer interaction; it is more than a choice of displayed ordering information.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The arrangement involves technical hardware, including a projection surface and an integrated user-input device.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board recognised a non-obvious mechanical integration of the known track pad into the tabletop. No cited prior art or established common general knowledge supplied the requisite incentive (Reasons 3.5-3.8).
– Applicatioin field: The implementation serves an interactive ordering system in a hospitality/business setting.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive issue was inventive step under Article 56 EPC; the previously raised clarity objection was no longer an obstacle.
– Outcome: The contested refusal was set aside and the case remitted with an express order to grant a patent on the specified claims, description and drawings.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Ordamo Limited
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – building track pad into projection surface (yes – non-obvious alternative)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 0190/03
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0232/14; 2020-10-6; Method and apparatus for identifying, authenticating, tracking and tracing manufactured items/INEXTO SA

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Data_Structures
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Lower_Memory_Usage
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The contested features describe ranges of consecutive identifiers for manufactured units and their representation in an identification/tracing data structure.
– Technical effect at issue: Reduced storage and bandwidth were asserted, but the ranges were primarily a business-oriented representation of production batches. Any storage saving was at most an obvious bonus effect (Reasons 2.5-2.9).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed apparatus and computer-implemented processing have technical character as a whole; the identifier-range concept was assessed separately.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Selecting first and last identifiers instead of storing each item was routine for a software programmer or database expert. Encryption and other auxiliary limitations did not rescue inventive step.
– Applicatioin field: The claimed identification and tracking of manufactured goods pertains to production-batch administration and traceability.
– Decisive legal issue: The central issue was inventive step under Article 56 EPC, with a secondary request for remittal considered under Article 111(1).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed; the Board also declined remittal to the examining division.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
The Board judges that using ranges of unit identifiers to label a number of (consecutive) unit identifiers of manufactured items is, at the level of generality at which it is claimed, on the business side of the line between technical and non-technical subject-matter (see e.g. T 144/11 – Security rating System / SATO MICHIHIRO, points 2.1, and 3.6 to 3.9). (See point 2.5 of the reasons)
The ranges of unit identifiers do have a meaning for the business person. They correspond to batches of units produced on a production line. (See point 2.6 of the reasons)
Even if the “determining of ranges of unit identifiers” achieved a technical effect, such as reducing data storage and data bandwidth requirements, it is a matter of routine design for the skilled person, a software programmer or a database expert, based on common general knowledge to store the first and the last element of a list of items, instead of the whole list. (See point 2.9 of the reasons)

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: INEXTO SA
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 111(1)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – determining ranges of unit identifiers (no – not technical and obvious) – technical effect of saving storage (no – bonus effect); Appeal decision – remittal to the department of first instance (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 0144/11, T 1463/11
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1798/13; 2020-5-25; Forecasting the value of a structured financial product/SWISS REINSURANCE COMPANY LTD

TECHNOLOGY: #Simulation_CAD_and_Engineering_Design #Physical_Modelling
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The method applies historical weather data, forecast models and an accuracy indicator when calculating the value of a weather-linked financial product.
– Technical effect at issue: The Board held that improving the model or accuracy of weather-forecast data for pricing a financial instrument did not, in this context, provide a technical effect (Reasons 2.9-2.16).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Data storage and computer implementation furnish technical means, but the mathematical/weather model and financial valuation do not by themselves provide a relevant technical contribution.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The only established technical features were conventional database storage and general-purpose computing; their implementation of the non-technical specification was obvious under COMVIK.
– Applicatioin field: The actual purpose of the claimed forecast and quality indicator was financial-product valuation, not technical control or improvement of meteorological measuring equipment.
– Decisive legal issue: The Board decided lack of inventive step under Article 56 EPC, distinguishing a physical weather system from a technical system that the skilled person can improve.
– Outcome: The sole request lacked inventive step and the appeal was dismissed.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
The “weather” is not a technical system that the skilled person can improve, or even simulate with the purpose of trying to improve it. It is a physical system that can be modelled in the sense of showing how it works. This kind of modelling is rather a discovery or a scientific theory, which are excluded under Article 52(2)(a) EPC and thus do not contribute to the technical character of the invention (see point 2.10ff.).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Swiss Reinsurance Company Ltd.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – improving a weather forecast (no – not technical)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 2079/10, T 2331/10
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0547/14; 2020-1-29; Verfahren zur Vorhersage von Schimmelpilzbildung/FRAUNHOFER

TECHNOLOGY: #Simulation_CAD_and_Engineering_Design #Physical_Modelling
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Determination_of_Physical_Parameters
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Building_and_Construction
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Patent_Eligible_Subject_Matter #Additional_Prior_Art_Search
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A biohygrothermal/isopleth-based model evaluates temperature, relative humidity and spore water content to predict mould germination or growth on building components.
– Technical effect at issue: The Board specifically identified determination of the physical water content of a spore using measured temperature and humidity as a technical effect (Reasons 3.4-3.12).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The method was not a mental act as such: its steps determine physical quantities and rely on experimental/technical means, whether or not a computer is used.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The physically relevant steps must be considered for inventive step. The Board rejected treating their particular combination as merely notorious common knowledge, but did not finally decide inventive step without a prior-art search (Reasons 4.1-4.4).
– Applicatioin field: The stated use is assessing mould formation on components and surfaces in the built environment.
– Decisive legal issue: Technical character and the necessity of a proper prior-art search were decisive; substantive novelty and inventive step required examination on remittal.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the application remitted to the examining division for a search and further examination; no grant was ordered.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft zur Förderung der angewandten Forschung e.V.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPÜ Art. 52(2)(c), 52(3), 56, 111(1); VOBK 2020 Art. 11
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Patentierbare Erfindung – “Bestimmung physikalischer Grössen zur Vorhersage von Schimmelpilzbildung” (Verfahren für gedankliche Tätigkeiten – nein); Erfinderische Tätigkeit – “Bestimmung physikalischer Grössen zur Vorhersage von Schimmelpilzbildung” (nicht-technisch oder allgemeines Fachwissen – nein) – technische und nicht-technische Merkmale – Unterschiedsmerkmale sind nicht notorisch; Zurückverweisung an die erste Instanz – (ja)
AI-TRANSLATED-KEYWORDS: Patentable invention – “Determination of physical quantities for predicting mould formation” (method for performing mental acts – no); Inventive step – “Determination of physical quantities for predicting mould formation” (non-technical or common general knowledge – no) – technical and non-technical features – distinguishing features are not notorious; Remittal to the department of first instance – (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1227/05, T 0421/06, T 0365/05
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1750/13; 2019-10-1; Scheduling opportunity previewer/Microsoft Technology Licensing, LLC

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Information_Presentation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A scheduling opportunity is shown in a mini-calendar preview within a graphical user interface.
– Technical effect at issue: The Board regarded the calendar representation and its influence on a user decision as cognitive presentation of information; it found no qualifying technical effect (Reasons 2.5-2.7).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The use of a GUI/computer meets the technical-means threshold, but the claimed presentation features are not thereby technical contributions.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The scheduling-preview instructions were implementable on conventional email and personal-information-management interfaces using ordinary programming choices; the auxiliary requests added no inventive technical solution.
– Applicatioin field: The field is electronic calendar and appointment administration.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC was decisive; remittal for an additional search was also refused.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because none of the admitted requests established inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Microsoft Technology Licensing, LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – previewing a scheduling opportunity in a mini-calendar format (no – presentation of information)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0643/00, T 0928/03, T 1575/07, T 1749/06, T 2019/12
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2318/13; 2019-9-26; Method for obtaining cash at cardless teller machines, using a payment order via SMS/Helena Activos Líquidos, S.L.

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Mobile_Communications
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Added_Subject_Matter #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Added_Matter_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: A central banking module handles cross-bank cash-payment orders and exchanges withdrawal authorisation information by SMS.
– Technical effect at issue: Any alleged interoperability or fraud-avoidance improvement followed from the business requirements; the network/server and SMS mechanisms were established technology (Reasons 3.3-3.7).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed ATM, server, network and SMS communication use technical means, but the financial-service concept is not a technical contribution in itself.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Providing the central module and its communication steps was an obvious implementation of a non-technical interbank service using known servers and mobile messaging.
– Applicatioin field: The end use is payment services, in particular cardless cash withdrawal across financial institutions.
– Decisive legal issue: The main request impermissibly added subject-matter under Article 123(2) EPC; the auxiliary request lacked inventive step under Article 56 EPC.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed, with different defects for the main and auxiliary requests: added matter and lack of inventive step, respectively.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Helena Activos Líquidos, S.L.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 123(2), 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – providing central module to process requests between different banking entities (no – part of business requirements)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1180/13; 2019-4-25; Partitioned data library III/HEWLETT PACKARD

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Data_Storage
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Data_Interoperability
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Added_Subject_Matter #Clarity_of_Claims #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Added_Matter_Clarity_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: Partitioned storage libraries map internal element addresses to external SCSI addresses that emulate established physical library configurations.
– Technical effect at issue: This address mapping allows a host configured for a known library model to access the partition without reconfiguration, a concrete technical interoperability effect (Reasons 5.6-5.7).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Storage elements, controllers and address mapping are technical elements in a physical data-library system.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The effect was technically relevant but the claimed mapping followed obviously from D4 combined with the virtual-to-physical mapping taught in D2 (Reasons 5.8-5.9).
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns interoperable computer data storage infrastructure.
– Decisive legal issue: The main request failed for added matter and clarity; the first auxiliary request failed for lack of inventive step (Articles 123(2), 84 and 56 EPC).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed; neither request on file was allowable.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Hewlett Packard Enterprise Development LP
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 84, 123(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Amendments – added subject-matter – main request (yes); Claims – clarity – main request (no); Inventive step – first auxiliary request (no)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0489/14; 2019-2-22; Pedestrian simulation/CONNOR

TECHNOLOGY: #Simulation_CAD_and_Engineering_Design #Computer_Simulations
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Effect_of_Simulation_Undetermined
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Not_Finally_Determined
APPLICATION FIELD: #Building_and_Construction
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Referral_to_Enlarged_Board_of_Appeal
OUTCOME: #Questions_Referred_to_Enlarged_Board_of_Appeal

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The interlocutory decision concerns computer-implemented simulations of pedestrian movement and their possible use in design verification.
– Technical effect at issue: The Board questioned whether simulated trajectories, without an external physical result, yielded a technical effect beyond ordinary computer implementation; it referred that legal question rather than resolving it finally.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The mandatory computer implementation supplied technical means, so the claimed method was not excluded from patentability as such (Reasons 4-6).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board considered conventional implementation insufficient on its own but did not conclusively rule on whether the simulated results supplied an additional technical contribution. It referred three questions to the Enlarged Board.
– Applicatioin field: The simulation concerns pedestrians in modelled environments, with building design and verification among its possible applications.
– Decisive legal issue: The decision addresses the legal criteria for a simulation-related technical effect in the inventive-step analysis and makes a referral under Article 112(1)(a) EPC.
– Outcome: This was an interlocutory referral, not a final dismissal or grant. The later substantive decision of 26 November 2021 is separately classified above.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
The following questions are referred to the Enlarged Board of Appeal for decision:
1. In the assessment of inventive step, can the computer-implemented simulation of a technical system or process solve a technical problem by producing a technical effect which goes beyond the simulation’s implementation on a computer, if the computer-implemented simulation is claimed as such?
2. If the answer to the first question is yes, what are the relevant criteria for assessing whether a computer-implemented simulation claimed as such solves a technical problem? In particular, is it a sufficient condition that the simulation is based, at least in part, on technical principles underlying the simulated system or process?
3. What are the answers to the first and second questions if the computer-implemented simulation is claimed as part of a design process, in particular for verifying a design?

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Connor, James Douglas
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(1), 52(2), 52(3), 56, 112(1)(a)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Patentable invention – simulation method; Referral to the Enlarged Board of Appeal
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/03, G 0001/04, G 0002/07, G 0003/08, G 0001/12, T 0208/84, T 0115/85, T 0163/85, T 0453/91, T 0769/92, T 0939/92, T 0190/94, T 1173/97, T 0641/00, T 0125/01, T 0914/02, T 0258/03, T 0424/03, T 0154/04, T 1351/04, T 0365/05, T 0471/05, T 1147/05, T 1227/05, T 1567/05, T 1029/06, T 1820/06, T 0887/07, T 1670/07, T 1806/07, T 1875/07, T 0531/09, T 1265/09, T 0309/10, T 1842/10, T 0625/11, T 1630/11, T 0988/12, T 2330/13, German Federal Supreme Court: BGH, 13 December 1999, X ZB 11/98, GRUR 200, 498 – Logikverifikation, Halliburton Energy Services, Inc. v Smith International (North Sea) Limited et al. [2005] EWHC 1623 (Pat) (21 July 2005), Halliburton Energy Services, Inc. v Comptroller-General of Patents [2011] EWHC 2508 (Pat) (5 October 2011)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1895/13; 2019-1-17; Reducing delta values of credit risk positions/CREDITEX

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Distributed_Computing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: An electronic trading system receives and processes credit-risk positions from networked trading clients to reduce the financial delta of derivatives portfolios.
– Technical effect at issue: The delta reduction and hedging improvements were financial, not technical results. The claim specified no non-routine technical implementation (Reasons 1.1-1.7).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Processors, a user interface and a communication network were sufficient to establish technical character under Article 52 EPC.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The trading and risk-hedging rules were non-technical; conventional processors, communications and spreadsheet input did not contribute inventively.
– Applicatioin field: The field is financial trading and credit-risk administration.
– Decisive legal issue: Lack of inventive step under Article 56 EPC was decisive; the Board also rejected requests for remittal and a European search-fee refund.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed, and both ancillary requests were rejected.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
See Reasons for the Decision, points 7 and 8.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Creditex Group, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 106(1), 111(1), 113(1); EPC R. 4(1), 4(5), 63(1), 63(2); Rules Relating to Fees Art. 9(1)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – improved risk-hedging approach in credit derivative trading (no – non-technical, implementation common general knowledge); Refund of search fee upon no-search declaration – (no); Remittal to the department of first instance – (no)
CITED DECISIONS: J 0014/87, T 1194/97, T 0641/00, T 0258/03, T 1411/08, T 2249/13
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1150/13; 2020-5-26; Linking data/TRA

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Privacy_Technologies
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed architecture combines household data from different suppliers through a third-party list matcher and a pseudonymous key for advertising-effectiveness research (Reasons 1.2-1.4).
– Technical effect at issue: The Board rejected the alleged bandwidth savings as unsupported by the claim and disclosure, and distinguished replacement of personal information with a key from technical data security (Reasons 2.2).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A computer system with processing modules and networked data sources uses technical means; this does not make the privacy policy or identifier-matching scheme itself technical.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The trust-based matching scheme was treated as an administrative requirement. Implementing it with ordinary computer and network means did not provide a non-obvious technical contribution (Reasons 2.1-2.4).
– Applicatioin field: The described use is household-level marketing research, including measuring advertising effectiveness from television and other customer data (Reasons 1.2-1.4).
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC decided the appeal; the Board also identified support/added-matter concerns and separately ruled on postponement and public file inspection (Reasons 1.5, 2 and 3).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed. The separate request to exclude the letter of 31 January 2020 from file inspection was also refused (Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Tra Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 84, 123(2), 128(4); EPC R. 144; RPBA 2020 Art. 15
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – protection of privacy by linking customer data with a key instead of personally identifiable information (no – not technical); Postponement of oral proceedings – representative unable to identify authorised person (no – reason in sphere of appellant); Exclusion from file inspection – details of arrangements for providing instructions to a representative (no – not prejudicial to appellant’s legitimate interest)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0003/90, T 1839/11, T 2522/10, T 0379/01
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0748/13; 2019-8-20; Queue image/Q.NOMY

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Information_Presentation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Clarity_of_Claims #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Clarity_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The queue-management system displays a customer-selected image instead of a conventional ticket number when calling the customer (Reasons 2.1-2.3).
– Technical effect at issue: The suggested lower risk of a missed summons depended on human recognition and memory. The Board characterised that effect as psychological or speculative, rather than technical (Reasons 4.5-4.7).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The queue-management and display equipment provides technical means, but choosing a personally recognisable image adds no technical character beyond that implementation.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Implementing the non-technical user-selection requirement in the known queue-management system was straightforward and obvious (Reasons 4.4-4.9).
– Applicatioin field: The claims concern administration of customer queues and how customers are summoned in a service setting.
– Decisive legal issue: Article 84 EPC clarity, Article 123(2) EPC added subject-matter and Article 56 EPC inventive step were adverse to claim 1; the fee-reimbursement procedural allegation was rejected (Reasons 3-5).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed; the Board also rejected reimbursement of the appeal fee because it found no substantial procedural violation (Reasons 5.5-5.6; Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Q.nomy
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 116(1), 84, 123(2), 56; EPC R. 103(1)(a), 111
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Oral proceedings – withdrawal of request for oral proceedings; Reimbursement of appeal fee – appealed decision reasoned (yes); Claims – clarity (no); Amendments – added subject-matter (yes); Inventive step – allowing the user to select an image representing him in a queue (no – not technical)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0003/90, T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1248/12; 2019-3-12; Privacy preserving data mining/CROSSIX

TECHNOLOGY: #Cybersecurity_and_Digital_Identity #Privacy_Technologies
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Healthcare_and_Medical
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The protocol de-identifies database records at source entities and aggregates query responses through a central aggregator, with health-care data used as a principal example (Reasons 1-2).
– Technical effect at issue: De-identification and selective disclosure were privacy objectives, not a demonstrated computer-security or processing improvement. The Board expressly distinguished data privacy from data security (Reasons 3.1-3.2).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claim uses database and processor infrastructure, which supplies technical means; the privacy and aggregation rules were not technical merely because the system was computer-implemented.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The requirement to de-identify and aggregate was placed in the non-technical specification under COMVIK. An aggregator, data exchange and conventional files or lists were obvious implementation measures (Reasons 3.3-3.7).
– Applicatioin field: The Board illustrated the invention with privacy-regulated medical records and health-care providers; the claimed protocol was not confined to that example (Reasons 1.2 and 2.1).
– Decisive legal issue: Lack of inventive step under Article 56 EPC was decisive; the Board also did not admit a late fourth auxiliary request (Reasons 3 and 7).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because the admitted claim requests did not establish an inventive technical contribution (Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Crossix Solutions LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – de-identifying data (no – not technical)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0424/03, T 0769/92, T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2491/12; 2018-11-13; Tracking derivative positions / TRADEWEB

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Databases
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Clarity_of_Claims
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Clarity_and_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed trading engine and trade-history database process and communicate information about derivatives positions, assignments and credit limits (Reasons 2.1-2.6).
– Technical effect at issue: Making financial information available quickly did not demonstrate reduced technical processing latency or a real-time technical improvement; no technical mechanism for such an effect was claimed or disclosed (Reasons 2.4 and 8.2).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The Board expressly acknowledged the technical character of the networked computer system under Article 52(1) EPC, while distinguishing that from the financial rules it executed (Reasons 2.1-2.2).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Mapping derivatives transactions onto a conventional client-server architecture, including storage, messaging and a GUI, added no inventive technical contribution (Reasons 2.3-2.10 and 4).
– Applicatioin field: The system supports financial trading and the administrative monitoring of derivatives and credit positions.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was rejected for the main request and all six auxiliary requests. Some auxiliary claims also lacked clarity and support for added real-time limitations (Reasons 2, 6-10).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed; the Board did not accept either the alleged real-time effect or the inadequately supported amendments (Order).

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
The claimed invention is not directed to a real-time problem in the sense of improving a technical process, but rather to automation in the sense of making (non-technical) financial information available quickly. This automation is achieved by mapping the financial concept of derivative transactions on a client-server computer system (see reasons, point 8.2).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: TRADEWEB MARKETS LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 84, 123(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – (no) – main request and auxiliary requests 1 to 6; Inventive step – mixture of technical and non-technical features – making financial information available in real time (no – not a credible technical effect) – common general knowledge; Claims – clarity (no) – auxiliary requests 2 and 3; Amendments – added subject-matter (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1194/97, T 0641/00, T 0258/03
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0988/12; 2018-7-17; Network deployment simulator / ACCENTURE

TECHNOLOGY: #Simulation_CAD_and_Engineering_Design #Computer_Simulations
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Telecommunications
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claimed computer simulation evaluates alternative scenarios for deployment of a 4G broadband service using network, bandwidth and cost models (Reasons 1.1-1.3).
– Technical effect at issue: No adequately defined technical system, simulation model or technical purpose was established; the example concentrated on capital and operating costs. Technical-sounding parameter labels did not suffice (Reasons 2.3-2.10).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Execution on a data-processing system provides technical means, but the claimed simulation itself did not make an additional technical contribution; the Board distinguished T 1227/05 (Reasons 2.2-2.8).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The simulation was a high-level, partly commercial metaspecification implemented on an ordinary computer. Routine implementation did not support inventive step (Reasons 2.7-2.11 and 3-4).
– Applicatioin field: NEW APPLICATION FIELD TAG #Telecommunications: 4G service and communications-network deployment are not precisely covered by the supplied application-field labels; the model also treated commercial deployment costs.
– Decisive legal issue: The decisive issue was Article 56 EPC: whether the simulation had an adequately defined technical purpose and thus a contribution capable of supporting inventive step (Reasons 2-4).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed for lack of inventive step across the main and both auxiliary requests (Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Accenture Global Services Limited
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – simulating scanarios for a 4G broadband service (no – inadequately defined technical purpose)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1227/05, T 0641/00, T 0049/99
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1989/12; 2018-4-26; Calendar-based profile switching / MICROSOFT

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Human_Computer_Interaction
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention provides notification profiles for a mobile device and optional automatic switching of profiles in response to calendar events (Reasons 1 and 3.2-3.3).
– Technical effect at issue: The selectable global and event-specific settings were user preferences rather than an independently demonstrated technical improvement; avoiding checks when switching is off is an expected consequence (Reasons 3.6 and 3.11).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Mobile devices and event notification mechanisms are technical means, but the Board treated the claimed selection of modes as a non-technical requirements specification.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Given the desired user options, conventional implementation on the phone was obvious; alternatively, D1 and D3 led to the automatic-switching arrangement (Reasons 3.6-3.13).
– Applicatioin field: The invention concerns general-purpose portable computing devices and their notification behaviour, rather than a sector-specific application.
– Decisive legal issue: The main request was inadmissible because the appeal grounds did not substantiate it; the auxiliary request failed for lack of inventive step under Article 56 EPC (Reasons 2-3).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed; the procedural inadmissibility of the main request is an additional qualification to the inventive-step outcome (Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Microsoft Technology Licensing, LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC R. 99(2); RPBA Art. 12(2); EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Admissibility (main request) (no – unsubstantiated grounds); Statement of grounds of appeal – reference to submission before the first instance; Inventive step (auxiliary request) – calendar-based profile switching (no – obvious)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1965/11; 2017-3-24; Cost-based materialised view selection/MICROSOFT TECHNOLOGY LICENSING

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Query_Optimisation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Processing_Efficiency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The method integrates matching of materialised database views into the exploration stage of a relational query optimiser and its table of alternative execution plans (Reasons 2 and 5.3).
– Technical effect at issue: The Board identified feasible cost-based optimisation of computer resource use and acceptable time complexity; query graphs reduce the complexity of extracting operator trees (Reasons 5.1 and 5.3).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Cost-based optimisation of relational queries was expressly considered technical because it takes account of CPU, memory, disk and the internal operation of the database system (Reasons 5.1).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The technical implementation was not taught or suggested by the cited art; the Board acknowledged inventive step for independent claims 1-3 (Reasons 5.2-5.4).
– Applicatioin field: This is database query optimisation in general-purpose computing systems.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was positively resolved under Article 56 EPC, following resolution of the Article 123(2) EPC amendment objection (Reasons 4-6).
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted with an express order to grant a patent on the specified documents (Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Microsoft Technology Licensing, LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56, 123(2)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Added subject-matter – (no); Inventive step – (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0003/08, T 1569/05, T 1003/09
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0104/12; 2016-9-8; Metadata-based query/SAP

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Databases
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Data_Interoperability
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The OLTP database communicates metadata about available entities and fields to a data sink and returns extracted data through an entity-oriented interface (Reasons 2-3).
– Technical effect at issue: The applicant argued for generic extraction and decoupling from physical database structure. The Board found these interoperability properties already available through database views; extra extraction work supplied no unexpected advantage (Reasons 3.5-3.9).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Database querying, view execution and remote function calls take place in a technical system; the case turns on obviousness rather than a finding that database operations are excluded as such.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Known metadata discovery, database views and standard remote function calls provided the relevant technical implementation. The obvious, potentially inefficient approach did not involve an inventive step (Reasons 3-6).
– Applicatioin field: The subject matter concerns general database and data-extraction infrastructure, not a particular customer-facing application.
– Decisive legal issue: Article 56 EPC inventive step was decisive for the main and all auxiliary requests (Reasons 3-7).
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because no claimed request was allowable (Reasons 7; Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: SAP SE
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – all requests (no)
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0651/12; 2016-4-14

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Data_Storage
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Lower_Memory_Usage
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Transportation_and_Travel
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Novelty #Additional_Prior_Art_Search
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention stores area-based altitude data and road-element coordinates to generate three-dimensional bird’s-eye-view maps on navigation displays (Reasons 3.2-3.4).
– Technical effect at issue: The Board recognised reduced height-data storage and faster calculations, as well as an ergonomically improved map display that can reduce driver distraction (Reasons 3.2-3.3).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The computer-implemented method was technical both because of its technical means and because the storage and ergonomic display features served technical purposes, not mere information content (Reasons 3.2-3.5).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The identified storage and map-display features made a genuine technical contribution. The Board did not finally determine inventive step for the first auxiliary request because a proper search was missing (Reasons 3 and 5-6).
– Applicatioin field: The discussed use is a map display for car navigation, improving driver orientation and safety (Reasons 3.2-3.3).
– Decisive legal issue: The main request lacked novelty over D2. A supplementary search encompassing the technical features was necessary before deciding the first auxiliary request (Reasons 4-6).
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted for further prosecution including an additional search; no grant was ordered (Order).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Xanavi Informatics Corporation
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 153(7); EPC 1973 Art. 54(1)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Supplementary European Search Report – no documents cited; Technical subject-matter (yes); Novelty (no) – main request; Remittal to examining division
CITED DECISIONS: T 0258/03
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 2035/11; 2014-7-25; Navigation system/BEACON NAVIGATION

TECHNOLOGY: #Navigation_and_Positioning_Technologies #Route_Planning_and_Guidance
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Human_Machine_Interaction
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Transportation_and_Travel
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Additional_Prior_Art_Search
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: NEW TECHNOLOGY MAIN GROUP #Navigation_and_Positioning_Technologies and SUBGROUP #Route_Planning_and_Guidance: the case concerns optimisation of road-segment routes in a navigation system, for which no suitably specific supplied technology tag exists (Reasons 3 and 5).
– Technical effect at issue: A route computed merely for visual consideration has no technical purpose by itself. By contrast, real-time position-dependent guidance and real-world congestion information used for actual navigation can serve a technical interactive task (Reasons 5.1.3, 5.2.1-5.2.3 and 7.4).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Both interpretations use technical computer means. The Board further recognised that position-dependent route guidance can form part of a technical process, unlike mere display of an abstract optimum path (Reasons 5.1-5.2).
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The main request’s user-selectable congestion weights reflected non-technical personal preferences and were obvious to implement. The first auxiliary request added automatic receipt of real-world congestion information, giving potential for an inventive technical contribution (Reasons 5.2.7-5.2.12 and 7.1-7.4).
– Applicatioin field: The invention concerns road navigation, including route planning, traffic information and driver guidance.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step defeated the main request. The auxiliary request overcame the refusal grounds but required further prior-art investigation before its inventive step could be finally assessed (Reasons 5-7).
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted for further prosecution; the Board did not order grant (Order).

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
See points 5 to 5.3 of the reasons

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Beacon Navigation GmbH
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – main request (no); Remittal to the department of first instance – (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0154/04, T 1784/06, T 1670/07, German Federal Supreme Court: BGH, 18 December 2012, X ZR 3/12, GRUR 2013, 275 – Routenplanung
=================
=================

EPO’s BoA: T 0909/14; 2022-6-3; Web service without upfront storage/MICROSOFT

TECHNOLOGY: #User_Interfaces_and_Extended_Reality #Graphical_User_Interfaces
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Lower_Memory_Usage #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention uses a document-sharing web service with different full-user and prospective-user interfaces, including document containers and an account-upgrade prompt (Reasons 2.1-2.3).
– Technical effect at issue: Reduced server-resource consumption was asserted, but the claims do not define which specific storage resources are saved. The Board found that limiting functionality and displaying unavailable options did not establish a further technical effect (Reasons 3.6-3.7).
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The web-service implementation uses technical computer and interface means. However, differentiated user entitlements and the presentation of an empty document container are business or informational choices, not technical contributions in themselves.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The notional business person could require reduced functionality and fewer resources for prospective users. Implementing those requirements and an upgrade button in the known service D5 was obvious (Reasons 3.8-4.2).
– Applicatioin field: The application concerns commercial account tiers and collaborative online document services.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC was decisive for both the main and auxiliary requests; the COMVIK/CardinalCommerce distinction between business requirements and their technical implementation governed the analysis.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because neither request involved an inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Microsoft Technology Licensing, LLC
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step – limiting functionality for new users and giving them fewer resources (no – not technical) – showing in a user interface features which can only be used after an upgrade (no – not technical)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/19, T 0641/00, T 1463/11, T 1635/09, T 1670/07
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1500/08; 2011-11-4
Generation of database queries/UBS

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Query_Optimisation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Processing_Efficiency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised_but_Obvious
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Novelty #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Novelty_and_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention concerns database-independent selection conditions and the generation of database-specific queries, particularly placeholders for selection operators and values.
– Technical effect at issue: Leaving value placeholders for substitution at the database server was said to permit reuse of earlier query processing. The Board doubted whether that advantage was actually achieved and held that the claimed approach was obvious even on the assumption that it was.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claimed query-generation method operates with technical computing infrastructure. Its computer implementation is not rejected as excluded subject-matter as such.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The main request was anticipated by D2. For auxiliary request 2, retaining placeholders at the server might provide a technical advantage, but doing so followed obviously from the known reuse capabilities of database servers; auxiliary request 1 was also obvious.
– Applicatioin field: The claimed database-query mechanism is of general application. UBS being the applicant does not restrict the claims to banking or commercial administration.
– Decisive legal issue: Novelty under Article 54 EPC determined the main request; inventive step under Article 56 EPC determined auxiliary requests 1 and 2. The Board also discussed the uncertainty of the asserted performance effect.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed: the main request lacked novelty and both auxiliary requests lacked inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: UBS AG
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(1); EPC 1973 Art. 54(1), 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Novelty (no): main request; Inventive step (no): auxiliary requests 1 and 2
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0528/07; 2010-4-27
Portal system/ACCENTURE

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Web_Technologies
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claims concern a client-server business-to-business web portal with graphical channels, hyperlinks, access permissions and business-opportunity applications.
– Technical effect at issue: Alleged rapid information exchange, synergy and lower network traffic did not establish a non-obvious technical effect. The conventional network behaved as expected, and reduced traffic from restricting users was attributed to administrative choices, not network technology.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Networked computers, browsers and permission-based enabling or disabling of functionality provided technical character, notwithstanding the commercial information presented.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The technical implementation was conventional. The remaining differentiating features related to business information, administrative roles and its presentation; no non-obvious technical contribution was established.
– Applicatioin field: The portal is specifically intended for business launch centres and exchange of information concerning business opportunities.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC was decisive. The Board also explained that Article 27 TRIPS does not oblige member states to apply an identical inventive-step standard.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because neither the main request nor either auxiliary request involved an inventive step.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
TRIPS member states are free to adopt different standards as to inventive step (see point 2).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Accenture Global Services GmbH
LEGAL PROVISIONS: TRIPS Art. 27; EPC 1973 Art. 56
CITED DECISIONS: T 0115/85, T 0833/91, T 0769/92, T 0790/92, T 0953/94, T 0641/00, T 0643/00, T 0467/03, T 0049/04, T 1161/04, T 0717/05, T 1567/05, T 0756/06
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1569/05; 2008-6-26
Method for retrieving data/CANON

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Search_Engines
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The application searches stored information using a mathematical semantic-space model, keywords and context words; retrieval of stored images is an illustrative embodiment rather than a limitation to image data.
– Technical effect at issue: More accurate and potentially faster semantic matching was asserted. The distinguishing change concerned linguistic meaning and mathematical selection of semantic axes, not technical control of database access or physical image processing. Any possible search-speed benefit would in any event have been obvious.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The explicitly computer-implemented method used technical means and therefore qualified as an invention under Article 52(1) EPC.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Reducing the semantic subspace by removing common, non-distinctive meaning components did not introduce a non-obvious technical improvement to database retrieval. The known retrieval implementation remained conventional, and the semantic-model modification was also considered obvious.
– Applicatioin field: The claims cover general database retrieval; examples involving image descriptions do not turn this into a specific image-processing application.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step was decisive for the main request. The auxiliary claims also suffered from clarity and added-subject-matter objections under Articles 84 and 123(2) EPC.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed. The main request failed for lack of inventive step, while the auxiliary requests also failed on clarity and added-matter grounds.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: CANON KABUSHIKI KAISHA; Kitagawa, Takashi; Kiyoki, Yasushi
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(1), 123(2); EPC 1973 Art. 56, 84; EPC 1973 R. 29(1)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0208/84, T 0052/85, T 1351/04
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0862/05; 2008-2-20
Sales system/CITIBANK

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Databases
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention uses a central customer database, graphical query input, branch workstations and network communications to support the generation and distribution of banking sales leads.
– Technical effect at issue: Faster lead distribution and fewer query errors were alleged, but the claims did not define a special technical mechanism achieving these effects; the telecommunications, queries and workstations were conventional.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): Database, workstation and communications components are technical means, so the claimed system and its computer-executed method were not excluded merely because they pursued sales goals.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The claimed allocation of information and marketing tasks was dictated by non-technical business requirements. Implementing those requirements with standard data-processing and communication means did not establish an inventive technical contribution.
– Applicatioin field: The described use is targeted marketing and customer-service support in the banking sector.
– Decisive legal issue: Article 56 EPC was decisive. The Board emphasised that non-technical ingenuity cannot satisfy the technical part of the could-would analysis.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed: the main and auxiliary requests lacked inventive step.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: CITIBANK, N.A.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC 1973 Art. 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0273/02
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0279/05; 2007-10-5
Predicting availability/ITA

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Query_Optimisation
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Processing_Efficiency
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Transportation_and_Travel
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Additional_Prior_Art_Search
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention concerns an airline-seat availability system in which a travel-planning server stores previous query responses and predicts the responses to later availability enquiries.
– Technical effect at issue: The asserted technical effect is to relieve processing load on remote airline-availability systems by avoiding certain repeated queries. The Board treated the location of prediction and storage in a server as technically material, without finally establishing inventiveness.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The amended claims require a travel-planning server and database operations; they therefore define technical implementation rather than a manual travel-agent prediction or a purely abstract business rule.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The Board recognised technical considerations beyond the mere automation of a known business activity. It held that the differentiating features could not be dismissed as notorious common knowledge without an evidential prior-art search, but did not decide that they were inventive.
– Applicatioin field: The actual application is flight and airline-seat availability within travel planning.
– Decisive legal issue: The issue was whether an inventive-step objection could be maintained without further prior-art evidence after a Rule 45 EPC no-search declaration. A supplemental search was required.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside and the case remitted for an additional search and further examination of the main request; no patent grant was ordered.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: ITA Software, Inc.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC 1973 Art. 56; EPC 1973 R. 45
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Additional search of amended claims
CITED DECISIONS: T 0641/00, T 0258/03, T 0690/06
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0471/05; 2007-2-6

TECHNOLOGY: #Simulation_CAD_and_Engineering_Design #Product_Design
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Optical_Performance
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Optics_and_Photonics
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Patent_Eligible_Subject_Matter #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The subject matter is the computational design of an optical system, balancing image-space volume, field size and optical aberration through a specified algebraic design condition.
– Technical effect at issue: The accepted technical aim was a relatively large image-space volume with relatively low aberrations, achieved by a particular non-arbitrary compromise between competing optical design conditions.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The main and first auxiliary design-method claims were not confined to physical or technical implementation and were excluded as abstract mathematical or mental methods. The allowable second auxiliary request expressly required an optics-design program running on hardware, establishing technical character.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): For the second auxiliary request the Board accepted both novelty and inventive step: the particular interpolation and optical balance were not suggested by the prior art, and the earlier rejection relied on hindsight.
– Applicatioin field: The invention concerns the design and manufacture of optical imaging systems.
– Decisive legal issue: Patent eligibility of an abstract design method under Article 52 EPC, and novelty and inventive step of the hardware-implemented form under Articles 54 and 56 EPC, were decisive.
– Outcome: The appeal succeeded on the second auxiliary request. The decision was set aside and the case remitted with an express order to grant a patent in the approved form, not merely for continued examination.

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Koninklijke Philips Electronics N.V., et al
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(1), 52(2), 52(3), 54, 56
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Entitlement to patent protection of a method of designing an optical system: main and first auxiliary requests (no: subject-matter for which protection is sought not confined to physical, technical implementations) – second auxiliary request (yes); Novelty and inventive step – second auxiliary request (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: G 0001/03, T 0453/91, T 0953/94, T 1173/97, T 0619/02, T 0914/02, T 0258/03, T 0388/04, T 0930/05
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 1242/04; 2006-10-20
Provision of product-specific data/MAN

TECHNOLOGY: #Data_Management_and_Information_Retrieval #Databases
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Technical_Data_Communication
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #Automotive_Maintenance_and_Service
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step #Additional_Prior_Art_Search
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The application concerns a central database, archival files and service-station interfaces that supply updated equipment data concerning individual commercial vehicles.
– Technical effect at issue: The higher-ranking requests mainly supplied maintenance information through a conventional database, without a proven inventive technical effect. The remaining request required an interface physically connected to the serviced product through a converter for data transmission; its technical significance required prior-art investigation.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The claims recite a computing, database and telecommunications system. The Board rejected treating the entire claimed subject matter as non-technical merely because the underlying information service included administrative aspects.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The conventional electronic maintenance-manual implementation was obvious. However, the device-to-interface converter in the remaining auxiliary request went beyond what could be assumed as notorious common knowledge; any inventive contribution was left open pending a search.
– Applicatioin field: The context is product-specific servicing of vehicles in maintenance workshops.
– Decisive legal issue: The central procedural issue was the limited scope of Rule 45 EPC no-search declarations and the need for an additional prior-art search. Inventive step was rejected for higher-ranking requests but remained open for the remitted claim set.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside. Only the further auxiliary request was remitted for additional search and examination; the higher-ranking requests were refused.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
I. Rule 45 EPC relates only to the practicability of a search and not to the potential relevance of its results in subsequent substantive examination (Reasons 8.3).
II. Where the application’s subject-matter has non-technical aspects, a declaration under Rule 45 EPC may be issued only in exceptional cases in which the claimed subject-matter, i.e. the entire set of claims including all independent and dependent claims, clearly has no technical character (Reasons 8.4).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: MAN Nutzfahrzeuge Aktiengesellschaft
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(2), (3), 56, 111(1), 112(1)(a); EPC R. 44(1), 45, 86(4); Guidelines for Examination in the European Patent Office, B-VIII, 3; Notice from the European Patent Office dated 26 March 2002 concerning business methods (OJ EPO 2002, 260)
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Declaration under Rule 45 EPC; Additional search; Enlarged Board of Appeal – referral by board of appeal (no); Remittal (yes – on basis of “further” auxiliary request)
CITED DECISIONS: T 931/95, T 258/03, T 641/00, T 1194/97, T 939/92, T 271/85, T 390/90, T 198/88, T 972/91, T 181/82
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0424/03; 2006-2-23
Clipboard formats I/MICROSOFT

TECHNOLOGY: #Software_and_Computer_Architecture #Operating_Systems
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #Improved_Data_Interoperability
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #Technical_Contribution_Recognised
APPLICATION FIELD: #General_Purpose_Computing
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Patent_Eligible_Subject_Matter #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Decision_Set_Aside_and_Remitted_with_Order_to_Grant

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention introduces interacting clipboard data formats that permit transfer of non-file data between applications and encapsulation into a file at the destination.
– Technical effect at issue: The functional clipboard formats improve interoperability between programs and the internal operation of a computer system, independently of the cognitive content of the data being exchanged.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): The computer-implemented method has technical character. The Board distinguished a method of operating a computer from a program as such and held that a computer-readable storage medium is a technical product.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): The interplay of the file-contents format and file-group descriptor produced a technical transfer function not suggested by Windows 3.1 or the cited scrap-object prior art. Novelty and inventive step were acknowledged.
– Applicatioin field: The improvement concerns general-purpose computer operating systems and application-to-application data exchange.
– Decisive legal issue: Patent eligibility under Article 52 EPC and inventive step under Article 56 EPC were central, with novelty, clarity and sufficiency also examined.
– Outcome: The refusal was set aside; the case was remitted with a binding instruction to grant a patent in the specified version.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
1. The claim category of a computer-implemented method is distinguished from that of a computer program. Even though a method, in particular a method of operating a computer, may be put into practice with the help of a computer program, a claim relating to such a method does not claim a computer program in the category of a computer program (point 5.1 of the reasons).
2. A computer-readable medium is a technical product and, thus, has technical character (point 5.3 of the reasons).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: MICROSOFT CORPORATION
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(1)(2)(3), 54, 56, 83, 84, 123(2); RPBA Art. 10b
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Late-filed request responding to objections – admitted (yes); Method of operating a computer – excluded as being a computer program (no); Novelty/inventive step (yes)
CITED DECISIONS: T 1173/97, T 1194/97, T 0258/03
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 258/03; 2004-4-21
Auction method/HITACHI

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Distributed_Computing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Patent_Eligible_Subject_Matter #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The claims concern a networked, computer-executed auction in which a server receives bids and applies price-setting and bidder-selection rules.
– Technical effect at issue: The applicant invoked transmission delays in real-time auctions. The Board held that changing auction rules to make those delays irrelevant circumvents a technical problem through a business scheme rather than solving it by technical means.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): An apparatus and a method making use of technical means constitute inventions within Article 52(1) EPC, even where their commercial purpose does not contribute to technical character.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): Network transmission and storage were conventional. The auction conditions were non-technical; even a potentially computer-specific incremental price step was routine programming and therefore obvious.
– Applicatioin field: The system is used for electronic commercial auctions.
– Decisive legal issue: The decision distinguishes the low threshold for technical character under Article 52 EPC from the COMVIK assessment of inventive step under Article 56 EPC.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because none of the main or auxiliary requests involved an inventive step.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
I. A method involving technical means is an invention within the meaning of Article 52(1) EPC (as distinguished from decision T 931/95-Controlling pension benefits system/PBS PARTNERSHIP)(see points 4.1 to 4.4 of the reasons).
II. Method steps consisting of modifications to a business scheme and aimed at circumventing a technical problem rather than solving it by technical means cannot contribute to the technical character of the subject-matter claimed (see point 5.7 of the reasons).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Hitachi, Ltd.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(1), 52(2), 52(3), 54, 56, 57
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Presence of an invention – method involving technical means (yes); Inventive step: treatment of non-technical aspects
CITED DECISIONS: T 931/95, T 38/86, T 769/92, T 1173/97, T 26/86, T 641/00, T 52/85
=================
=================
EPO’s BoA: T 0172/03; 2003-11-27
Order management/RICOH

TECHNOLOGY: #Networks_Cloud_and_Web_Technologies #Distributed_Computing
TECHNICAL EFFECT AT ISSUE: #No_Demonstrated_Technical_Effect
TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 52 EPC): #Technical_Character_Established
CONTRIBUTION TO TECHNICAL CHARACTER (ACCORDING TO ART. 56 EPC / COMVIK): #No_Technical_Contribution_Beyond_Conventional_Implementation
APPLICATION FIELD: #Business_and_Administration
DECISIVE LEGAL ISSUE: #Inventive_Step
OUTCOME: #Appeal_Dismissed_Lack_of_Inventive_Step

AI-FEEDBACK:
– Technology: The invention implements departmental ordering, budget checks and supplier selection using linked terminals, a network, and a central table-oriented information system.
– Technical effect at issue: Administrative centralisation was said to reduce network traffic or save time, but the Board considered those results either unsupported by the claimed network architecture or attributable to business organisation rather than technical measures.
– Technical character (according to Art. 52 EPC): A programmed, distributed computer system has technical character even when the ordering scheme itself is commercial or administrative.
– Contribution to technical character (according to Art. 56 EPC / COMVIK): A software project team would treat the business rules as requirements and implement them with standard distributed hardware, databases and programming. That automation was obvious and made no inventive technical contribution.
– Applicatioin field: The claims concern procurement and order administration across organisational departments.
– Decisive legal issue: Inventive step under Article 56 EPC was decisive; the Board also clarified that the relevant prior art under Articles 54 and 56 EPC is technological information, not business-method knowledge as such.
– Outcome: The appeal was dismissed because the main and auxiliary requests lacked inventive step.

ORIGINAL-HEADNOTE:
1. The term “state of the art” in Article 54 EPC should, in compliance with the French and German text, be understood as “state of technology”, which in the context of the EPC does not include the state of the art in commerce and business methods. The term “everything” in Article 54(2) EPC is to be understood as concerning such kind of information which is relevant to some field of technology.
2. From these considerations it follows that anything which is not related to any technological field or field from which, because of its informational character, a skilled person would expect to derive any technically relevant information, does not belong to the state of the art to be considered in the context of Articles 54 and 56, even if it had been made available to the general public before the relevant priority date (see points 8 to 10 of the reasons).

PATENTOWNER/-APPLICANT: Ricoh Company, Ltd.
LEGAL PROVISIONS: EPC Art. 52(1), 56, 54
ORIGINAL-KEYWORDS: Inventive step (no)
CITED DECISIONS: T 0769/92, T 0931/95, T 0967/97, T 0049/99, T 0641/00
=================
=================